Try spinning two eggs, one boiled and one raw, I think this will give you a good indication of what to expect...
I was going to bring this one up but then I had a vision of some of the members on this board trying to boil an egg
Try spinning two eggs, one boiled and one raw, I think this will give you a good indication of what to expect...
But don't forget one is liquid-filled and the other is solid and they are rolling, not dropped.
I saw this demonstrated on one of those tv science-shows-on-a-budget (not Mythbusters) but can't remember off-hand what the answer was, but believe the two did not roll at the same rate.
I believe Moraff has the right answer (#13), and that landscaper (#16) has the right idea but I think the effect leads to the opposite result of that post.
Consider a wider range of barrels: one, filled with water. Another, filled with a very thick oil or molasses. Another filled with ball bearings. And finally, one filled with concrete.
We can agree that all are subject to the same graviational forces, so if they were dropped through air they'd fall at the same rate.
But when they're rolled down the ramp, then they have to start, well, rolling. The barrel filled with concrete can only roll as fast as the concrete inside is rolling (spinning with the barrel), while the barrels filled with more viscous fluids do not have to get those fluids rolling (spinning with the barrel) as quickly in order for the barrel itself to roll.
As less energy is transferred to the angular momentum of the barrel's contents, I believe more energy is available to roll the barrel itself. As a result, I expect the barrel filled with water to reach the bottom first.
Stopping the barrels is a different story.
Until it runs over that bird in the box.
You'll also have internal friction to deal with, between the water and barrel walls. Or ball bearings, etc.
Gut tells me the water barrel will get off the mark faster, but a solid barrel of equivalent mass will have better sustained acceleration up to terminal velocity. Thus, on a long run, will get there sooner.
Gut has been wrong before.
This is where experiments lead scientists to rationalize rather than predict.
Decrease the viscosity of the fluid from water, to molasses, gelatin, uncured concrete, cured concrete (etc), and all you've done is increase the friction within the fluid. As you suggest, there are other factors at play as the angular momentum of the water will take longer to reach its maximum than that of the solid. The question is what that angular momentum of the contents means to the linear travel of the barrel (or, the angular momentum of the barrel).
I'm pretty sure, though, that a barrel of beer would quickly be stopped and turned into a barrel of air.
I'm pretty sure, though, that a barrel of beer would quickly be stopped and turned into a barrel of air.
According to Newton acceleration of falling objects is constant at 9.8 meters per second per second, regardless of mass. Wind resistance and other forces may act on the objects, such as delayed rolling from sloshing of water. But if a water barrel does not slosh it will roll at the same velocity and acceleration as the concrete barrel.
btw, The feather and rock test (Galileo's theory) was conducted on the moon and proven to be accurate.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5C5_dOEyAfk
I'm sure someone could model this and make a prediction before an experiment, but that would take the fun out of it.
As I mentioned in my earlier post I found a person who did the experiment using a full bottle of water and a full bottle of ice. The bottle of water was faster than the bottle of ice.
Or roll two empty barrels, one with a thin outer layer and one with a very thick outer layer.You are confusing falling with rolling. Drop the barrels of water and concrete and you are 100% correct that both will hit the ground at the same time (all other conditions being equal).
But with rolling you now have angular inertia to contend with which is all about mass and how far it is from the centre of rotation. With the concrete barrel the entire mass has to rotate. With the water only the barrel itself must rotate, hence it accelerates more quickly. Friction between the water and the barrel cause the water to begin to rotate... stealing some of the rotational energy from the barrel. Which means that if we did it in a vacuum (to negate air resistance effects) and empty barrel would roll even faster than the water filled one. Replace the water with a liquid with a higher viscosity (like molasses) and the barrel will roll faster than concrete but slower than water because the higher viscosity steals more of the rotational energy from the barrel to start moving the liquid.
the viscopsity of the liquid has an effect on the rotational momentum. The basics are that the concrete filled barrel or an empty one for that matter will roll faster than a barrell full of water the water starts rotating after the barrel starts rolling. The hard boiled soft boiled egg thing.
Eventually the barrels will get up to the same speed but at that point the concrete filled one will be further doen the slope
Again, you have the results confused.
Let's try this: fill one (short) flat-bottomed glass with water, and another glass with flour. Apply an equal effort to "spin" each glass on its bottom (on a smooth surface, maybe a plate), and see what happens.
You'll find that the glass filled with water spins much more easily than does the glass filled with a solid. That's because in order to get the glass to spin, you don't have to get the liquid contents to also spin, but you do need to get the solid contents to spin with the glass.
Thought experiments are fun!
What happens if you apply only one quick spin to each? Do both of them maintain their spin equally well?
If you apply additional spins, which one will accelerate more?
Ie hard-boiled versus raw egg.
The hard-boiled versus raw egg is a very different problem, as the raw egg won't spin on an end and the "egg shape" won't allow the fluid to move easily inside (relative to the shell) but instead causes all sorts of pressure currents interfering with the spinning of the shell.
The hard-boiled versus raw egg is a very different problem, as the raw egg won't spin on an end and the "egg shape" won't allow the fluid to move easily inside (relative to the shell) but instead causes all sorts of pressure currents interfering with the spinning of the shell.
Still have the link? Been trying to find anything similar.