Price-wise it can be hard to advise you on who's a good insurance company to go with. Your life and mine are different (where we live, what age/sex/driving experience/type of car/claim history....) so a company that will insure me for the best price won't necessarily be the same for you.
Currently I am with Belair as I have had good service with them for the one claim I did have to make (apartment break-in) and the fact that they were willing to consider me as an experienced driver even though it had been approximately 7 or 8 years since I had last had auto insurance in my name. Their prices have also been comparable to other companies I checked out. Not always the cheapest, but close enough that their service keeps me with them.