Are Vodka Martinis Heresey?

Diode said:
Actually a Gimlet is a Martini with a cocktail onion, not olive.
Works for both Gin and Vodka.

Wrong.

Gimlet

1 1/2 oz. Gin or Vodka, Splash of Lime Juice

Stir with ice & Serve on the rocks in a Lowball or Strain into a chilled cocktail glass, Garnish with a Lime wedge
 
bigdik said:
Wrong.

Gimlet

1 1/2 oz. Gin or Vodka, Splash of Lime Juice

Stir with ice & Serve on the rocks in a Lowball or Strain into a chilled cocktail glass, Garnish with a Lime wedge

That's what I thought a Gimlet was too.

Proper vodka martinis (or whatever the $#@&* they're called) always come with an onion, I understand.

As for those who've said "you shouldn't care what people think" - to be sure, I don't. But as I've said, being snobbish is part of the fun of cocktails.
 
Gee Whiz

Gimlet: as per 'THE COMPLETE BARTENDER"
2 oz gin
1/4 oz Rose's lime juice (1/2 oz fresh lime juice can be substtuted)
Garnish with lime wedge
serve in rocks glass

ok ok ok mea culpa
I stand corected
IT was a
GIBSON , That's what I should have wrote
OK :eek: