Anyone knowledgable about kidney disease?

Check the parallel thread on high blood pressure and that her son has the creatinine level of an 80 year old. What is wrong is that her son's kidneys are not functioning properly. Do you seriously think that her son should have an unrestricted diet in his condition (like maybe a lot of oranges and tomatos high in potassium)?

I didn't realize there was a parallel thread regarding her son. My bad.
However, this still doesn't mean she should go seeking out a renal nutritionist. Her son's doctors will be quite capable in managing his electrolytes, and if he does indeed have chronic renal insufficiency, for whatever reason, then as I said, specialists would get involved and the team may end up including a renal nutritionist if those doctors deem it necessary.
 
if a specialist feels kidney disease might be a possibility, they will have to do a biopsy on some kidney cells..the disease is iga nephropathy. My 26 year old daughter discovered through a routine medical that her kidneys are functioning at only50% efficiency. we were all in a panic for months. after the biopsy and a few weeks of nail biting she was diagnosed as not having iga nephropathy.. WHEW.so they still cant figure out her efficiency rate other than maybe injury from a bad fall during a snowboarding outing. but she doesnt have the disease. all work done in edmonton teaching hospital by top specialists in the field. forget chatham or other bum fuck town hos;itals
 
agreed personal info needs to stay personal
find a friend and talk or wait to talk to a doctor
this is not the place to find the answers your needing

Who put you in charge? It's not your business to decide what type of questions can be asked in this forum.

She's reaching out to her online friends for assurance and support. I don't see anything wrong with that.

When you are made the moderator of this forum(and pigs fly), you can decide what can and cannot be discussed.
 
BUT, she was asking for medical advice.

Where did she specifically ask for information about how to treat her son? She wanted to know more about kidney disease. I don't see her asking for treatment options or second opinions on the diagnosis.
 
Where did she specifically ask for information about how to treat her son? She wanted to know more about kidney disease. I don't see her asking for treatment options or second opinions on the diagnosis.

That is asking for medical advice. I've already seen a few people post in this thread who do not have any training in nephrology, and based on personal experience with a specific cause of kidney pathology, have piped in telling her what disease her son has just because they or a relative had this ailment.
Kidney disease can be caused by a SHITLOAD of things. Nobody here should be giving advice on it...even if they have an MD and they are correct. This is not the right place, because for the rare person that does know what the hell they are talking about, there are 10 others who give their misinformed $0.02.
Again, if a person wants to come on here for support or to vent because they or a family member is ill, then certainly, they should feel free. But don't ask for medical information.
 
Christ this went off the fucking rails, I'll bet all this pissing and moaning is REALLY helpin her feel better. If you don't have anything helpful to say, maybe STFU???
 
<siiiiiiiiiigh>
whitewaterguy told the OP that IgA nephropathy is kidney disease. This is not true. IgA nephropathy is one of numerous causes of chronic kidney insufficiency.
And as for the rest of what you said...yes, MDs are getting pretty frustrated with people coming in with their own internet diagnosis and then having to talk their patients down off the ledge. And yes, I REALLY think people would go to their MD with TERB advice. And while I hope to hell that no MD would ever act on it, what I'm saying is that there are going to be a bunch of people on this ESCORT REVIEW BOARD putting forth information about medicine that is INCORRECT/INACCURATE, and this could potentially worry a person more than is necessary.
If you want to research medical issues on the internet, go for it. Don't do it on TERB.
 
I never said don't do your own internet research. I said don't do it on TERB. If you do that you're going to get far more BS than truth.
 
There is a right way and a wrong way to do your own medical research on the internet.

The wrong way is to go off and try and come up with your own diagnosis or treatment plan independent of anything your doctor said, then trying to convince your doctor that it's the way to go. This is a stupid waste of your time, and a stupid waste of your doctor's time.

The right way is to listen carefully to what your doctor says the diagnosis is, ask what he's trying to rule out, what the complications can be, and so on. What treatment is he considering? What drugs? What side effects? What's the prognosis? Make notes. Go home and look up all the things your doctor mentioned and educate yourself about them. Your primary goal here is to gain a better understanding of your condition so you can ask better questions next time you see your doctor, and more clearly understand the answers he provides. Note the emphasis on asking questions and listening--you are trying to get the maximum value out of the time you spend with the expert by being as well informed as you can, you are NOT trying to replace your doctor with a website.

The internet is NOT a replacement for your doctor, but if used properly, it can help you have a better, more informed conversation with your doctor.
 
She asked specifically for information about kidney disease. I see no problem with coming here to share experiences relating to dealing with loved ones undergoing medical treatment, BUT, she was asking for medical advice. I don't think it's a good idea and I stand by what I said.

You are absolutely right, I did indeed ask for advice.....I was upset and frightened and came to a place that is full of bright, educated and intelligent people. I wanted reassurance more than anything but also ideas so as to know what to ask the Dr.'s and what to push for.
The advice given here has been wonderful and has been a tremendous help so far. :)
He is on a salt free diet for the time being and is on 4 different bp meds. The appointment with the nephrologist is tomorrow and thanks largely to the advice and information given here I was able to ask intelligent questions and listen to the answers carefully while he was in the Hospital. My stress level was under control so I was able to reassure my Son. Thank you everyone
 
Last edited:
There is a right way and a wrong way to do your own medical research on the internet.

The wrong way is to go off and try and come up with your own diagnosis or treatment plan independent of anything your doctor said, then trying to convince your doctor that it's the way to go. This is a stupid waste of your time, and a stupid waste of your doctor's time.

The right way is to listen carefully to what your doctor says the diagnosis is, ask what he's trying to rule out, what the complications can be, and so on. What treatment is he considering? What drugs? What side effects? What's the prognosis? Make notes. Go home and look up all the things your doctor mentioned and educate yourself about them. Your primary goal here is to gain a better understanding of your condition so you can ask better questions next time you see your doctor, and more clearly understand the answers he provides. Note the emphasis on asking questions and listening--you are trying to get the maximum value out of the time you spend with the expert by being as well informed as you can, you are NOT trying to replace your doctor with a website.

The internet is NOT a replacement for your doctor, but if used properly, it can help you have a better, more informed conversation with your doctor.
This the half the time when I entirely agree with you. Wise advise!
 
They gave him an Ultra Sound yesterday which ruled out any abnormalities in the kidneys as far as they could tell. His creatinine levels are still too high to give him a cat scan but his bp has been under control (with serious meds) for three days now so they felt it was safe to release him. I did express my concern to his Dr. about releasing him without knowing the cause but it was his opinion that the phrenologist will be looking for answers aggressively. After assuring me that they are not just brushing him under the carpet I brought him home. I asked specifically about diet and was told that he only has to stay away from salt right now.....Apparently they are worried enough that they immediately called the specialist in London who rearranged his schedule so as to see him right away. We go tomorrow morning to get started on the blood/urine tests and find out what the next steps are.



Originally Posted by fuji
There is a right way and a wrong way to do your own medical research on the internet.

The wrong way is to go off and try and come up with your own diagnosis or treatment plan independent of anything your doctor said, then trying to convince your doctor that it's the way to go. This is a stupid waste of your time, and a stupid waste of your doctor's time.

The right way is to listen carefully to what your doctor says the diagnosis is, ask what he's trying to rule out, what the complications can be, and so on. What treatment is he considering? What drugs? What side effects? What's the prognosis? Make notes. Go home and look up all the things your doctor mentioned and educate yourself about them. Your primary goal here is to gain a better understanding of your condition so you can ask better questions next time you see your doctor, and more clearly understand the answers he provides. Note the emphasis on asking questions and listening--you are trying to get the maximum value out of the time you spend with the expert by being as well informed as you can, you are NOT trying to replace your doctor with a website.

The internet is NOT a replacement for your doctor, but if used properly, it can help you have a better, more informed conversation with your doctor.





Excellent advice and very well put.
​

 
LadyTY2Uall we are all keeping you in mind/in our prayers I am sure. Hope everything goes well, please keep letting us know how things are going.
 
I hope things go well for your son.
Just one thing..it's nephrologist, not phrenologist.