GPIDeal - I liked the Torch. But for its weight (and the crappy touchscreen), it was the best of both worlds. I was a loyal BB user for over 10 years, right back to the first "pager" model. They made (and still make) very high quality hardware. My only complaint was that the touch screens always sucked (I had the Torch, 9900 Bold and Playbook). I have about a dozen friends with the Z10 and they say that they like it (all hardcore BB users), and maybe another dozen with the Q10. A couple of my partners recently switched to the Q10 and they like it. But, coming from the old Bolds, they bitch about the battery life.
If the keyboard is important to you, then go for the Q10. It's your only choice really. I understand. Its hard to type while driving on a touchscreen (I kid! I kid!). I still miss the keyboard myself, and I'm nowhere near as fast or accurate on the touchscreen even after nearly one year of use.
I'm all-in for the Apple ecosystem now. I like the ease of use and consistency across platforms (phone, tab and laptop/desktop). But, like everyone else, I'm wary of having so much content tied up in a proprietary system. I've got over 1,500 songs and 100 movies in iTunes (I know, sunk cost, but....)
Interestingly, I've noticed that Apple isn't that much more expensive now. It's no longer a premium product. Almost uniformly across the spectrum, if you price out similarly equipped hardware, Apple is quite competitive (the same, or maybe 5% to 10% more). In some cases (small office servers), it's actually cheaper!
I'm not sold on the Android system yet, although I've just picked up a Galaxy tab for fun. I'm nervous about the openness, bugginess and hassle of needing to tweak things to make them work. I just want plug and play.