Any recommendations for nice Caribbean island?

Avoid St Maarten if you can IF your NOT going for SP's...seriously, that island is overly congested...I"ve gone in the height of tourish season and the driving is insane on those roads in the daytime...and it was no better on the offpeak..if you can afford to yatch it around that island, you will have fun..once again...money comes into play...

I've been to quite a few island now so if you have a budget in mind/duration, then I can prob give you something better than a island name without explaination..

For Antigua, I never experienced any proglems and stayed in the Jolly Harbor area...another nice island is St Kitts, its kinda undeveloped but in the last 2yrs has evolved alot and more foreign money is being pumped in..construction of high end resorts all over...prices are still cheap compared to other island, but not much to do but relax

Nevis, same as above...if your going to go here, your going to want to stay at the 4seaons which is the best in all of the Caribbean...I stayed there and could not tell the difference except for the fact it cost $400/night...

Barbados is the best overall IMHO...it has the facilities for familes, some nightlife..locals are nice and there are things to see and do.

Kinda in a rush right now so cant type more, but hope this helps in your search.
 
I like St. John.

OTB
 
Take a 5 or 7 night Caribbean cruise with sevaral stops. Visit every island and determine which one you'd like to go back to for a week.

My parents did it that way for a while. They fell in love with St. Martten