any auto racing fans here?

IRL sucks ass

riley36 said:
F1? :rolleyes:

With computer-controlled cars even a chimp could drive, orchestrated pit strategies employing a gazillion guys, stupid time-limits so Euro TV fans can get their hour and a half of pure racing, and wholly predictable results (unless someone fixes the finish), it does leave a bit to be desired.

CART? Sorry, the "Champ car series powered by Ford, run on Bridgestones, and fueled by crusty, bitter Paul Newman's dressings and cheesy glop". A bunch of no-names that complain that someone "took the wind off my spoiler" when they come within a mile of each other. And Paul Tracy? If he had of been in any other racing series (except F1) he would have had someone lay a beating on him for some of the stupid crap he pulls.

At least the IRL guys can run at 200+mph within a car-length of each other without crapping themselves.

And nothing beats the atmosphere at a NASCAR race. Its like the Superbowl every week.

typical drivel by uninformed people.

first off, CART does not exist anymore, call it right, the champ car world series. no-names eh? hmmmmm....tell me the last driver from the idiotracingleague to get a drive in the pinnacle of motorsports, formula one? that's right, you can't! at least CCWS has had prime F1'ers come and drive in it's series. the names of tracy, bourdais, junquiera, servia, allmendinger, wilson, etc;... sure have alot more collective talent than the never-will-be's in the earl.

as for the IRL, enjoy it, while it lasts. major sponsorships. major network television exposure. the supposed crown jewel of races, the indianapolis 500, and, oh yeah, the topper, no fans. dont worry, the traitors, like penske, ganassi, and rahole will have to crawl back to the CCWS in short order. most of the drivers in the IRL are guys who did nothing in CCWS anyways. and, you wanna talk about tracy and his dumb moves, hmmmm, ever see tomas scheckter drive? ever see an IRL race without some kind of stupidity in the pits? ever have an IRL season, where a driver didnt get seriously injured?

close races??? yeah, the cars are so down on power, and when things are looking like one driver will run away with it, boom, yellow flag, let's bunch them up yet again! hey, that sounds like nascar! at least NASCAR is fun to watch. stick your IRL where the sun dont shine.

those who knock F1, dont understand it. sure, schumi winning all the time gets stale, but, appreciate it for what it is, you are watching a true master behind the wheel. you think just anyone would step into his car and win? hardly, just look at his flunky, rubens barrichello, half the time, he is lucky to step onto the podium. take schumi away, and we wont have talk of no competition in F1. the part of having a good car, is true, because if you drive a midland/jordan, a minardi, or a red bull car, you simply wont win. but, that is true of almost every series, you need to have a good car under you.

F1 is also not a spec series, it is all about pushing the limits, a catch-me if you can series. dont like it, dont knock it, just dont watch it! hell, you got a while, i'll rip into the IRL all day long!

Plyrs99

as for the ladies, every series has it's fair share of babes.
 
It's true, like I stated previously, f1 is about cutting edge technology. Shumacher won with Minardi, than he took his mechanics and engineers and started his work on the ferrari team. He helped build that car to what it is today. In the old days the drivers would just jump into the cockpit and drive the the wheels off of the darn thing. Now, it's a serious profession. Strict diet and workout regime, and development schedule. Just look at what happened to Kimi Raikkenon. 30 Years ago, his behaviour would have been lauded by his peers.
 
some good comments plyrs99

plyrs99 said:
... sure, schumi winning all the time gets stale, but, appreciate it for what it is, you are watching a true master behind the wheel. ...
a good 'glass half full' comment. But it's one of the reasons I lost interest, kinda like the NYyankees thing.

Regarding Barrichello, a microcosm of above... F1 top teams years ago
adopted #1 #2 driver thing with #1 a parasite, leaving #2 lame and target
only for criticism, Barrichello unjustly I think. At the time, Jackie Stewart
pronounced only one driver he thought fit for his new team - Barichello.
Quite the complement I thought. The infamous race that had Ecclestone
apoplectic with Ferrari fixing was evidence that given equal cars, pit
strategies and no 'incidents' Barichello can beat Schumacher and had the
skills to hold off MS' ferocious lapping, that is until last lap Ferrari boss' pull
over order feeding the #1 parasite.

It's rare to see top teams' drivers compete like that because of this 1-2
driver thing. The other times were Senna-Prost Mclaren, where Senna
demolished Prost, and Villeneuve-Schecter back and forth. The Senna-Prost
hate was news over several seasons, every race had promise of what-if.
When it did it was awesome, dramatic racing and hastened Prosts retirement.

This never happens anymore in F1. The sport has completely subverted any
semblence of fan appreciative competetive athleticism to money like no other
pro sport. F1 races are amazing, the technology is awesome but without real
competition it's boring.
 
Maclaren now has Juan Pablo Montoya and Kimi Raikkonen. They will certainly be at each other's throats. Plus, once again, we must support JV! Hopefully he will have competitive equipment so he can take it to schumi once again. Or at least redeem himself over the ebarrassment of the past 5 seasons.
 
smart_alek, you stated schumi won in a minardi? i must have slept through those years then....he NEVER drove for minardi. he has driven for jordan, bennetton and ferrari.

and anyone who thinks rubens is on a par with michael, with only team orders holding him back, needs to watch a little more closely. sure, there have been times that rubens actually matches the pace, but, those are few and far bewtween.

i do agree, that at one time, driver skill meant alot, and that a great driver could take a seemingly bad car, and will it to a good result, those days are gone.

it was also suggested by someone here that a chimp could drive today's F1 car. i say to you, then why are you not in an F1 car then? it still takes skill to drive one of these machines. sure, with all the tech toys these drivers enjoy, they have less to do than in years past, but, make no mistake about it, you dont just get in these cars and just turn the wheel, it is not that easy.

and smart_alek, you mentioned supporting JV again. man, this guy is like the local town drunk, who just keeps coming back for more, not seeing that he is just embarrassing himself. he was way off his teammates pace for the last 3 races of last year at renault, and, if you have been following this year pre-season tests, his teammate, felipe massa has been competitive with the front-runners, while JV has consistenly been the slowest guy on the track, by a considerable margin. he has already begun the whining.... :rolleyes:

Plyrs99
 
This never happens anymore in F1.The sport has completely subverted any semblence of fan appreciative competetive athleticism to money like no other pro sport. F1 races are amazing, the technology is awesome but without real competition it's boring.

Right on.

it was also suggested by someone here that a chimp could drive today's F1 car. i say to you, then why are you not in an F1 car then?

I think it has something to do with certain drivers being able to afford to buy a ride. If joe average had the money I'm sure there would be some f1 (and Champ Car, and IRL) team giving them an opportunity. Simple as that. It would be foolish to assume that everyone with a ride right now is simply the most qualified drivers out there.

F1 is also not a spec series, it is all about pushing the limits, a catch-me if you can series.

Well, give me guys going 10 mph slower and are actually racing together, rather then the field split by 20 sec. If you gotta tighten them up occassionally, fine, but I'd rather see racers race then parade around. Great technology we can ohh and ahh over? I wouldn't disagree. Don't call it racing though.

By the way, I think you have me confused with someone who care about open wheel racing in NA. I don't, unless Sprint cars are open wheel. It is fun to see the complete cock-ups that have been made by CAR... (sorry Chump car), the IRL and F1.
 
riley36 said:
I think it has something to do with certain drivers being able to afford to buy a ride. If joe average had the money I'm sure there would be some f1 (and Champ Car, and IRL) team giving them an opportunity. Simple as that.

I doubt it otherwise that would have happened already. It takes alot more than you think to drive a Formula 1 car consistently. If it were that easy then anyone making the jump from CCWS/CART would have success in the series. To date only Montoya and Villeneuve have had any success. And I wouldn't even consider Montoya a CCWS driver because he was testing for Williams for a year before heading to North American. When he arrived he "put some manners" on the field including the IRL at his INDY win. There are many examples of Formula 1 drives having success in North America. Too many examples. It's an easier car to run and set up because of the spec nature of CCWS/CART/IRL series.

riley36 said:
Well, give me guys going 10 mph slower and are actually racing together, rather then the field split by 20 sec. If you gotta tighten them up occassionally, fine, but I'd rather see racers race then parade around. Great technology we can ohh and ahh over? I wouldn't disagree. Don't call it racing though.

Formula 1 is designed to produce winners. CCWS/CART/IRL/NASCAR is designed to produce close finishes.
 
My mistake plrs, I was thinking of Benneton when talking about Schumi. I know it was not a top flight team, like a Maca or Williams. I think JV still has a chance, we haven't seen him in a race with him at full fitness yet.
 
Of course I wasn't talking about some rich guy off the street who uses the curb as a guide when he drives, but some series have a preponderence of guys who bring money to the table and end up in a cockpit, rather then a driver who's actually qualified.

If they can’t drive then no amount of money should matter. They should be denied a license just as Shigeaki Hattori was last year.

Recently, critics have been saying that the CART FedEx Championship Series has been taken over by rent-a-riders

There are a certain percentage of ride-buying drivers in all forms of motorsports.

Racing, all forms of racing, would be better if you eliminated this and allowed everyone to use equipment which resulted in drivers actually racing. This is an interesting link, a bit out of date, but I'd think the trend has been more of this:
http://www.autoracing1.com/MarkC/2001/0116Americans.htm

Formula 1 is designed to produce winners.

So, outside of the speed, why is it any different then watching a guy tool down the 401 by himself? Both are pretty damn boring.
 
Speaking of pay drivers, anyone remember Alex Yoong? arghh! Man was he lame. Didn't he get suspended for not making the cut in qualifying 3 times in a row?