Another news scam exposed

langeweile said:

Try this one on for size.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6346471/site/newsweek/

But while the dispute has grabbed the headlines, United Nations officials tell NEWSWEEK that the Al Qaqaa case may only be the tip of the iceberg. As many as 10,000 other conventional-arms dumps dotted around Iraq are believed to have been looted after the U.S. invasion, the officials say. In addition, as many as 30 out of 90 of Saddam's known nuclear research facilities were also stripped down—some to the ground—by looters.

While much of the material taken from the nuclear sites is believed to have been "dual use" manufacturing equipment largely useless to terrorists, the looting of conventional-arms depots means that Zarqawi and the ex-Baathists are not unlikely to run out of weapons any time soon—and that the insurgency may have a long way to go before it runs out of steam.
 
http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,137017,00.html


Interesting to note:
The four boxes in the bunker are 2 from Yugoslavia, 1 from China and one from France.
This is according to the UN inspection report. Please read the PDF file available on this site.
It's just Fox News they have to be lying...
 
What is interesting about this is that it seems to confirm the Frontline documentary about the lead up to the war in Iraq. This documentary states that in the lead up to Gulf War Two (Revenge of the Younger) that Donald Rumsfeld, in essence, took over the planning of the War and despite the prtestions of Gen Tommy Franks et al decided to go with a much smaller force than the Pentagon (and Colin Powell) recommended.

The army told Rumsfeld that taking Bagdad would be easy even with a small force but that containing and managing the peace would be impossible with the number of US troops on the ground.

It appears Franks et al were right. Seems that Canada is not the only country where the beaurocrats can fuck it all up. Everyone is playing loyal soldier now but it appears that the Rumsfeld/Cheney coalition have gotten us into a real mess...
 
War is an extension of politics with different means.
If a country feels that it has reached the point, that it needs to go to war. It can't be done halfway or with one hand tight behind the back.
It prolongs the horror and in some cases kills more people than necessary.
 
I agree with you there -- if yer gonna fight, fight.

But what I think the point of the Frontline documentary was that Rumsfeld CHOSE to go in with fewer troops than the folks in the army recommended. It was not a political decision to go in with fewer guys -- it was a decision Rumsfeld made because he arrogantly believed that his theory of warfare was superior to a "muddy boots" general like Tommy Franks or Colin Powell.

He, with the backing of Cheney, made the decision that they could win this war with a much lower number of troops than anyone else in the military recommended. Bush, of course, listened to these two (not Franks, Not Powell) and that's how the US (and the largely innocent population of Iraq) ended up in this shithole.

It was Rumsfeld's desire to be a part of history and be seen as a person able to "think outside the box" that got his boss into a situation he is barely able to control.
 
lenharper said:
I agree with you there -- if yer gonna fight, fight.

But what I think the point of the Frontline documentary was that Rumsfeld CHOSE to go in with fewer troops than the folks in the army recommended. It was not a political decision to go in with fewer guys -- it was a decision Rumsfeld made because he arrogantly believed that his theory of warfare was superior to a "muddy boots" general like Tommy Franks or Colin Powell.

He, with the backing of Cheney, made the decision that they could win this war with a much lower number of troops than anyone else in the military recommended. Bush, of course, listened to these two (not Franks, Not Powell) and that's how the US (and the largely innocent population of Iraq) ended up in this shithole.

It was Rumsfeld's desire to be a part of history and be seen as a person able to "think outside the box" that got his boss into a situation he is barely able to control.

Rumsfeld's calculation or now misscalculation, was that the Iraquis would welcome the "liberators" with open arms. In that case with the full support of the people it could have been possible to "win" this war with a small force.

I wish GWB, Rumsfeld and others would come out and admit their misscalculation on this aspect.
I could never understand while politicians can't publicly admit their mistakes.
I believe most reasonable people would accept this more than the denial.
if Clinton would have said. Yeah, she s....d Mr.Happy, we would have been spared the whole impeachment drama. Which one of us guys could have blamed him for that?
Same with Bush, if he would have come out 6 month in to the conflict, saying "Shit we all thought those guys would be happy being freed" and we were wrong about that. The whole climate would be different today.
maybe that is a little blue eyed from me, but I want to believe that honesty still counts for something in this world.

To error is human to forgive is divine.
 
I tend to agree with you. In all aspects of life I've found that admitting to a mistake is much more effective than practicing the policy of deny deny deny...

The sad thing is that the electorate on both sides of the border has too much fun playing politics (see Americanson's posts) than to really think about the issues at play in this (hyperbole noted) "most important election in this generation's lifetime".

As I noted earlier the electoral process in the US (and probably Canada as well) has descended into WWE farce. While I prefer Kerry to Bush I certainly don't think Bush is as stupid as he is made out to be but neither do I think that Kerry thinks that "terrorism is akin to prostitution". The problem is those who are fighting this election lower the standard of debate to such a degree that it is impossible to take either side seriously.
 
Wasn't the 3rd Army stuck in Turkey because they wouldn't let us use their bases for a Northern Front, thus delaying those troops (by something like 3 months) entering Iraq? I remember Rumsfeld having fewer troops than he wanted for the war as well.

OTB
 
Don't know about that but I believe the differential between what the Army wanted and what Rumsfeld wanted was huge ( not something that could have been remedied by the troops stuck in Turkey).

What I think is more to the point is that the mistake that was made was that Rumsfeld was so completely in charge of the strategy and went sideways everytime he could so as to not involve key members of the Joint Chiefs of Staff in the planning of the invasion.

I think the "loveseeker" has it right in saying that the grievous miscaculation was the belief that the Iraqi's would see this as a liberation.