Submissivedave
submissivedave said:
[PS - you noted earlier that you did not like postmodern shit ... but Popper has been labelled a postmodern dude ... are you not contradicting yourself?
No, not at all. I've read Philosopher David Stove's critique of Popper's epistemology and he makes some very good points . I was referring to Popper's book: "The Open Society and it's Enemies". This book stands on it's own.
Confucius once said: "When you know something, admit that you know it. And when you don't know it, admit that you don't know it. That is knowledge."
I very much agree. There's alot of things I don't know about, but philosophy I know, so what's your point? My wisdom and knowledge trumps your unprincipled understanding of philosophy.
Heidegger wrote three volume on Nietzsche and some other stuff on "Thus Spoke Zarathustra" and he, Heidegger confessed in his conclusions that he did not totally understood what Nietzsche was saying.
Many people believe that the more incoherent their prose is the more profound they are. The exact opposite is true. If a thinker is worth reading it's because they're attempting to be understood. When you're reading a philosophe who never attempts to define his terms and gives loose definitions (if that) you're most certainly reading a shyster. Post Modernist "Philosopher" Derrida uses this same weak argument about not being understood even against other philosophers.
http://reason.com/0002/fe.ef.reality.shtml
Now, being the little wimpy submissive boy that I am ...... I would never admit that I would totally understand a piece that I've read. For one thing, I have been reading Nietzsche and have read "Thus Spoke Zarathustra" many many times and still I am scratching my balls off trying to understand what the fuck he's talking about.
What a sense of efficacy you must feel while studying philosophy. It's true, some philosophers communicate their ideas better than others. But, lots of times it's the philosopher that is at fault when he fails to clearly communicate his ideas. Why? Because his, or her, thinking is most likely divorced from reality.
Consider this thought from Hegel: Being + Nothing = Becoming.
Abstract stuff. Hegel is a very compilcated philosopher, but don't mistake complicated with having anything to do with reality. The above formula leads you into what can only be called castle building in the sky. Philosopher David Stove also critiques Hegel in "The Plato Cult" (as he does Popper) it's quite funny actually.
To answer your question, I read both primary and secondary sources.
I've had many conversations with philosophers I respect. For example: I spoke with John Hospers, in person, about Kant's epistemology. I explained to him my understanding of Kant, in my own words, and he agreed that I had the gist of what was getting at.
For the benefit of others, just a few book I suggest you read to start you off:
WT Jone's: "A History of Western Philosophy". This book is a magnificent achievement from a great mind. He compares and contrasts Aristotles and Jesus's ethical theories, and does the same for other thinkers. Quotes thinkers, such as St Augustine, at length. It's a great book.
If want a book that just focuses on individual thinkers, Fredrick Copleston's "A History of Philosophy" will give you a really good working knowledge of the thinkers effecting the course of history.