Americans getting to the breaking point

It all depends upon whether they have "probable cause"

Sure. It is clear that they do not have probable cause, they are just stopping everybody and asking whether they are citizens, before they have any grounds at all. They clearly have no probable cause.

if the guy is merely being a jerk they may feel that it isn't worth the effort, however, I would STRONGLY advise against just driving off, when requested to report for secondary inspection.

In the video he appears to have been compliant with anything described as an "order" while he refused anything phrased as a request. He seems to have asked "am I free to go" and gotten an affirmative response before driving off in each case.
 
Sure. It is clear that they do not have probable cause, they are just stopping everybody and asking whether they are citizens.
As the cat wrote you can be assured that these folks are now "in the system." As the song does "When I fight authority, authority always wins" "you" may be able to get away with being a jerk today, perhaps tomorrow and even the day after tomorrow as well, but when you are under a microscope year after year. . . . one day. . . and with this sort of attitude "you" are not going to be a sympathetic defendant.
 
Silly Americans. They should learn from us and just conduct "RIDE" checkpoints ALL YEAR LONG - anywhere and everywhere a suspected trafficker of anything illicit travels. Conduct a joint stop with ATF, US Border Guards and State Police. Then everyone that shows up with a "flag" on them from one of their databases they can go to town on them. IN this country there is a requirement to identify yourself to LE.
999
 
As the cat wrote you can be assured that these folks are now "in the system." As the song does "When I fight authority, authority always wins" "you" may be able to get away with being a jerk today, perhaps tomorrow and even the day after tomorrow as well, but when you are under a microscope year after year. . . . one day. . . and with this sort of attitude "you" are not going to be a sympathetic defendant.

Sounds like a police state, you are right, the Gestapo always win.

Why do Americans tolerate living in a police state where the authorities can stop you anywhere, anytime, and demand to see your papers?
 
Sounds like a police state, you are right, the Gestapo always win.

Why do Americans tolerate living in a police state where the aurhorities can stop you anywhere, anytime, and demand to see your papers?

With the damage that Obama is doing to the Gun Control debate (by trying to have one that is).... and the amount of new weapons purchased since Sandy Hook..... I doubt many will be "taking it" for long. Civil Liberties is fast becoming a hot button.... White Hot.... more so than it was before.
 
It all depends upon whether they have "probable cause" and for how long you are being detained. If the guy is merely being a jerk they may feel that it isn't worth the effort, however, I would STRONGLY advise against just driving off, when requested to report for secondary inspection.

Yes, you do have to identify yourself and you can be detained until you do.

The government has almost unlimited power at the border itself, the government's position at "interior roadblocks" is thus far not as strong, but there is a lot of judicial rumbling about it.


legal aside. how do you feel about it as a free american citizen?
 
Silly Americans. They should learn from us and just conduct "RIDE" checkpoints ALL YEAR LONG - anywhere and everywhere a suspected trafficker of anything illicit travels. Conduct a joint stop with ATF, US Border Guards and State Police. Then everyone that shows up with a "flag" on them from one of their databases they can go to town on them. IN this country there is a requirement to identify yourself to LE.
999

At a RIDE checkpoint they stop you and ask for your drivers license, and use the opportunity to sniff out whether you are drunk (literally), which they're entitled to do when you are on the road. Your license does not indicate what your immigration status is, but it verifies that you are entitled to be driving and that's what they can check.

To wit, a guy driving a car with Mexican plates who has a Mexican drivers license can pass a RIDE check, ditto Canadian. There is no reason for him to tell the RIDE people what his citizenship is or why he is in the United States. Just being on the road with foreign plates and a foreign license is not probable cause to suspect an immigration violation--lots of foreigners come to the US legally and on valid business.
 
Sounds like a police state, you are right, the Gestapo always win.

Why do Americans tolerate living in a police state where the authorities can stop you anywhere, anytime, and demand to see your papers?
Because there is a difference (and not merely semantic) between "Good morning. Are you a U.S. Citizen? Where do you live? Would you mind showing me your driver's license/or if a non-national do you have your Green Card or Passport with you?" and "Your papers!"
 
What's the difference? Watching the video it seems they very clearly were demanding his papers.

I suspect the Gestapo were quite well spoken when asking for papers. The Germans were somewhat infamous for maintaining good manners and proper decorum, regardless of the level of atrocity they were engaged in.
 
legal aside. how do you feel about it as a free american citizen?
How difficult is it to merely answer the questions? I've been through these sorts of checkpoints many times, are they mildly annoying - yes; are they a threat to my fourth amendment rights - no. Are you a U.S. Citizen? Where where you born? - Most of the time it goes no further than that. By the way you are aware that in the U.S. a legal non-Resident is supposed to have either their "Green Card" or if they are on a Visa their I-94 on them?

A car is not a house.
 
By the way reference the California Agricultural Inspection Station

California Code §42948.
(a) It is unlawful for any person to refuse to submit any container, subcontainer, load, or display of fruits, nuts, or vegetables to the inspection of any enforcing officer, or to refuse to stop any vehicle which contains any fruits, nuts, or vegetables, for the purpose of inspection by an enforcing officer.

(b) A violation of this section is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of not less than one hundred dollars ($100) nor more than three thousand dollars ($3,000) or by imprisonment in the county jail for not more than six months, or by both the fine and imprisonment.
 
Your argument continues to be that those who stand up for their rights should be beaten down by the authorities.
To me and many others is a significant difference between illegal search and seizure especially involving a dwelling place and this sort of just plain behaving like a jerk over normal police functions.

It is ironic that this sort of behaving like a jerk is popular with some on TERB, while folks like the Tea Party (who are their philosophical siblings) are called every name in the book.
 
How difficult is it to merely answer the questions? I've been through these sorts of checkpoints many times, are they mildly annoying - yes; are they a threat to my fourth amendment rights - no. Are you a U.S. Citizen? Where where you born? - Most of the time it goes no further than that. By the way you are aware that in the U.S. a legal non-Resident is supposed to have either their "Green Card" or if they are on a Visa their I-94 on them?

A car is not a house.

i have no problem with that at the border. i think a hundred miles from the border is something else. if you live in an area that close the border- you could be stopped all the time- it would be extremely annoying.
 
i have no problem with that at the border. i think a hundred miles from the border is something else. if you live in an area that close the border- you could be stopped all the time- it would be extremely annoying.
In my part of the world I'm familiar with two such checkpoints, both on interstate highways that funnel traffic away from the border. It really isn't much different an experience than a DUI/OUI/DWI checkpoint.

The U.S. Border Patrol has jurisdiction up to 100 miles from the border (including the coastline) after that it is ICE.
 
There was a long thread about this before. There's lots of vids like this on the internet with amateur lawyers (and in some case real lawyers) giving the cops a hard time.

While I respect their right to do so, to me these guys just look like assholes.

They also put dangerous ideas into the minds of people who don't fully understand their rights and obligations, potentially getting people into a lot of trouble that could otherwise be easily avoided by answering a few simple questions.
 
Well Keebler, as a real lawyer, I've never had a problem answering simple questions. On the other hand things like can we search your vehicle with no probable cause are an entirely different kettle of fish!