These folks are but a small step removed from "Sovereign Citizens," indeed many of them buy into that as well.He's polite, but in a smug, rude, condescending way. What an asshole!
These folks are but a small step removed from "Sovereign Citizens," indeed many of them buy into that as well.He's polite, but in a smug, rude, condescending way. What an asshole!
It all depends upon whether they have "probable cause"
if the guy is merely being a jerk they may feel that it isn't worth the effort, however, I would STRONGLY advise against just driving off, when requested to report for secondary inspection.
As the cat wrote you can be assured that these folks are now "in the system." As the song does "When I fight authority, authority always wins" "you" may be able to get away with being a jerk today, perhaps tomorrow and even the day after tomorrow as well, but when you are under a microscope year after year. . . . one day. . . and with this sort of attitude "you" are not going to be a sympathetic defendant.Sure. It is clear that they do not have probable cause, they are just stopping everybody and asking whether they are citizens.
As the cat wrote you can be assured that these folks are now "in the system." As the song does "When I fight authority, authority always wins" "you" may be able to get away with being a jerk today, perhaps tomorrow and even the day after tomorrow as well, but when you are under a microscope year after year. . . . one day. . . and with this sort of attitude "you" are not going to be a sympathetic defendant.
Sounds like a police state, you are right, the Gestapo always win.
Why do Americans tolerate living in a police state where the aurhorities can stop you anywhere, anytime, and demand to see your papers?
It all depends upon whether they have "probable cause" and for how long you are being detained. If the guy is merely being a jerk they may feel that it isn't worth the effort, however, I would STRONGLY advise against just driving off, when requested to report for secondary inspection.
Yes, you do have to identify yourself and you can be detained until you do.
The government has almost unlimited power at the border itself, the government's position at "interior roadblocks" is thus far not as strong, but there is a lot of judicial rumbling about it.
Silly Americans. They should learn from us and just conduct "RIDE" checkpoints ALL YEAR LONG - anywhere and everywhere a suspected trafficker of anything illicit travels. Conduct a joint stop with ATF, US Border Guards and State Police. Then everyone that shows up with a "flag" on them from one of their databases they can go to town on them. IN this country there is a requirement to identify yourself to LE.
999
Because there is a difference (and not merely semantic) between "Good morning. Are you a U.S. Citizen? Where do you live? Would you mind showing me your driver's license/or if a non-national do you have your Green Card or Passport with you?" and "Your papers!"Sounds like a police state, you are right, the Gestapo always win.
Why do Americans tolerate living in a police state where the authorities can stop you anywhere, anytime, and demand to see your papers?
How difficult is it to merely answer the questions? I've been through these sorts of checkpoints many times, are they mildly annoying - yes; are they a threat to my fourth amendment rights - no. Are you a U.S. Citizen? Where where you born? - Most of the time it goes no further than that. By the way you are aware that in the U.S. a legal non-Resident is supposed to have either their "Green Card" or if they are on a Visa their I-94 on them?legal aside. how do you feel about it as a free american citizen?
No, they'll say "at least we stuck with our original handles, unlike danzuchy2 who pops up in Feb 2013 talking like a TERB veteran."
Fuji, are you familiar with the expression "He was right, dead right."
To me and many others is a significant difference between illegal search and seizure especially involving a dwelling place and this sort of just plain behaving like a jerk over normal police functions.Your argument continues to be that those who stand up for their rights should be beaten down by the authorities.
How difficult is it to merely answer the questions? I've been through these sorts of checkpoints many times, are they mildly annoying - yes; are they a threat to my fourth amendment rights - no. Are you a U.S. Citizen? Where where you born? - Most of the time it goes no further than that. By the way you are aware that in the U.S. a legal non-Resident is supposed to have either their "Green Card" or if they are on a Visa their I-94 on them?
A car is not a house.
In my part of the world I'm familiar with two such checkpoints, both on interstate highways that funnel traffic away from the border. It really isn't much different an experience than a DUI/OUI/DWI checkpoint.i have no problem with that at the border. i think a hundred miles from the border is something else. if you live in an area that close the border- you could be stopped all the time- it would be extremely annoying.