Alexander the Great: Logistics

Having learned more about ancient history from popular culture than school I thought I had the perfect video to respond to this... But, it turns out it was Eddie Izzard saying Latin is a silly, silly language and using the example of trying to explain that Hannibal was coming. Quid the f@#k.
Still, popular culture delivers and Iron Maiden give a great summary of Alexanders achievements.


 
  • Like
Reactions: mandrill
Warmonger. Alexander the Terrible is a more fitting title.
Probably killed more Greeks than he did Persians , one of the reasons he was greatly despised by the Athenians and other City states ... was truly ruthless when he needed and a brilliant tactician when planning his battles ... genius level when one studies them closely ...... he spread Greek culture to the East with his new found empire after the usual battles/casualties and massacres ... we shall never know how far he could have reached had he not died so young ( probably murdered) ..... One things for sure the dude knew that there was a lot of Gold $$$$ to be had going East , definitely knew were it was haha
 
No replies so far. This thread deserve at least one reply.

Question: What happens if Alex the Great had met Genghis Khan?
Different tactics mate but the Mogols did a lot of hit and run ... I’d say Alex in 6 , but I’m biased
 
The Romans met up against a very different Phalanx than the Persians. Just saying.
Very true , different Phalanx than the ones the Romans later encountered
Alexander’s Macedonian phalanx had * Elite cavalry and many skirmishers to protect their flanks ... without these two units to protect them they were exposed ....... one wonders what would have happened had Alexander survived his Asian campaigns and turned his attention towards the Greek City states of south Italy ... I’m not certain but Im guessing that the legion was not yet fully developed or perfected by the Romans ...he could have changed history as we know it
 
Very true , different Phalanx than the ones the Romans later encountered
Alexander’s Macedonian phalanx had * Elite cavalry and many skirmishers to protect their flanks ... without these two units to protect them they were exposed ....... one wonders what would have happened had Alexander survived his Asian campaigns and turned his attention towards the Greek City states of south Italy ... I’m not certain but Im guessing that the legion was not yet fully developed or perfected by the Romans ...he could have changed history as we know it
Greek City states would have standard Greek tactics and may have started to think about adopting the phalanx. So he would have rolled over them.

The legion took centuries to develop and was always changing. The Romans subsequently fought a series against a Macedonian type phalanx led by a good general, Pyrrhus the Epirote and it ended up a messy tie, with the Romans winning by attrition and by dint of greater resources. By that time, the phalanx had added elephants.

My guess is that Latium had greater agricultural, financial and people resources than anyone else of the time. Because the Romans always bounced back with yet another big army whenever Hannibal or Pyrrhus or the Gauls defeated them.


 
Cleopatra was descended from a Greek general appointed by Alex as boss of Egypt.
 
Not as knowledgeable as some of you on ATG....

I am seeing a lot of overseas middle easterners on FB comments citing Afganistan as the "Graveyard of Empires". America. Russia. Alexander the Great.

It's an America is pulling out article from the Economist.

Why would someone believe ATG lost there?
 
^^
Haven’t read up in a long time but from what I can remember it took him years to subdue a lot of tribes in that area .... kind of hard to beat a foe using guerilla tactics...
 
I am seeing a lot of overseas middle easterners on FB comments citing Afganistan as the "Graveyard of Empires". America. Russia. Alexander the Great.
I've seen a video recently that suggests it's rep is a bit of an overstatement. I don't care enough to push the issue though.
 
Not as knowledgeable as some of you on ATG....

I am seeing a lot of overseas middle easterners on FB comments citing Afganistan as the "Graveyard of Empires". America. Russia. Alexander the Great.

It's an America is pulling out article from the Economist.

Why would someone believe ATG lost there?
IIRC, he just pushed through on the way from Persia to India. I guess you either go through the mountains - i.e. Afghanistan - or the desert.

I think he was ambushed a lot and had to storm hill forts. But it wasn't worth his time to conquer. There's fuck-all there worth the effort.
 
  • Like
Reactions: poker