Aircraft Noise in Toronto

I saw CP 24 interview a woman in Leaside. She said that since the change 4 years ago, Leaside is getting more than its fair share of aircrafts overhead, ...

She has some serious issues if she thinks planes flying over Leaside are creating too much noise.
 
The flight paths did changed a few years ago for scheduling purposes, reduce the time on approach which reduces fuel costs. There's many factors that contribute to noise. Humidity, precipitation, temperature variations, ambient air temperature, cloud cover, height of cloud cover, wind speed and direction.

It's a big city, if you don't like noise, move away. Far, far away.
 
What this doesn't mention is that the 1000+ complaints were lodged by 50 people. Don't quote me on the numbers but it was something like that.

When the clouds are low, and the airplanes cannot be seen on approach or departure, noise complaints drop to almost zero. Which is to say that people don't complain as a result of the noise per se, but because a plane flew over their house. They use noise as a pretext.
 
I live about 5KM, as the crow flies, from the west end of the southern east/west runway. And every night, at 1:00AM, I can hear what seems to be the same extra loud plane taking off...from inside my house.
It actually rattles the windows. I do not hear any other planes, and it does not bother me...but I can see why some are complaining.
 
I live about 5KM, as the crow flies, from the west end of the southern east/west runway. And every night, at 1:00AM, I can hear what seems to be the same extra loud plane taking off...from inside my house.

It actually rattles the windows. I do not hear any other planes, and it does not bother me...but I can see why some are complaining.

There's a curfew at 2300. There are curfew exemptions, and airlines are allowed a limited number in case of unplanned delays. Maybe a cargo carrier, but can't see why they wouldn't be gone before 2300.

Also, it's unlikely that an airline would have an airplane take off from the same runway every single day, as there would be days when the wind favours another runway....so you wouldn't hear it in that case, especially if it won't be flying overhead your house and thus loud enough to rattle your windows.
 
What this doesn't mention is that the 1000+ complaints were lodged by 50 people. Don't quote me on the numbers but it was something like that.

There was a retired and frustrated airline pilot who lived just off the approach path to a popular runway. He would sit in his lawnchair looking up and any time an aircraft would stray exactly over his house, he would dial in a noise complaint. That would be the difference between looking straight up and looking 30 degrees off to one side. IIRC, he was responsible for 20% of all noise complaints.
 
There's a curfew at 2300. There are curfew exemptions, and airlines are allowed a limited number in case of unplanned delays. Maybe a cargo carrier, but can't see why they wouldn't be gone before 2300.

Also, it's unlikely that an airline would have an airplane take off from the same runway every single day, as there would be days when the wind favours another runway....so you wouldn't hear it in that case, especially if it won't be flying overhead your house and thus loud enough to rattle your windows.

Well maybe it is not every night, but it is always 1:00AM. And it does not take off towards and over me, but away from me. I hear it rev up for take off.

Unless you experience exactly what these people are complaining about, it is not really fair to pass judgement and dismiss their claims.
Sure, some are just fed up and complain all the time, and others just like to complain, but it can be a real issue.

I know a guy who found out about the runway expansion several years ago, and sold his house just in time, as the prices dropped significantly when the planes started overhead.
Others were not so lucky.

When they take off east towards Toronto from the south runway, I rarely notice them passing overhead. But I bet when they take off going west there are a lot of Mississauga complaints.
Housing is much denser and closer to the airport.
But they knew that when they bought their house out there, so unless there has been a significant increase in late night flights, they have no case.
 
Apparently, some of the noise could be from planes landing/taking off from Downsview.

They only fly Q400 turboprops out of Downsview, the ones they build there and flight test. There is almost no other activity otherwise.
 
Well maybe it is not every night, but it is always 1:00AM. And it does not take off towards and over me, but away from me. I hear it rev up for take off.

Unless you experience exactly what these people are complaining about, it is not really fair to pass judgement and dismiss their claims.
Sure, some are just fed up and complain all the time, and others just like to complain, but it can be a real issue.

I know a guy who found out about the runway expansion several years ago, and sold his house just in time, as the prices dropped significantly when the planes started overhead.
Others were not so lucky.

When they take off east towards Toronto from the south runway, I rarely notice them passing overhead. But I bet when they take off going west there are a lot of Mississauga complaints.
Housing is much denser and closer to the airport.
But they knew that when they bought their house out there, so unless there has been a significant increase in late night flights, they have no case.

Not to dismiss anybody's claims but to try to figure out what exactly this noise is.

The most often used runways are 23 and 24R, since the prevailing winds are from the west. So if indeed you heard it almost every night, then they should be flying over you. There is also runway 33R, and that is used for airplanes that are really heavy because it's the longest runway; But that one is almost 2 km to the east of Derry road (the airport boundary), so that could be a little too far for your windows to rattle.

Maybe a cargo carrier on a regularly scheduled run?

Each carrier is allowed a small number of take-offs and landings after curfew before they are fined, in case of operational circumstances. It may be one that has to take-off at that time for operational reasons, such as to arrive at the other end after airport end-of-curfew?
 
But they knew that when they bought their house out there, so unless there has been a significant increase in late night flights, they have no case.

They will always have a case, as long as they can complain to politicians who are too stupid to understand how airplanes and airports work.

David Collenette was one of them, and he was minister of transport.