Advice Needed - Pregnant GF

actually, methinks the gf is an sp/mpa........and for Incredible, child=less hobbying $$ :)
 
CapitalGuy said:
But I guess you don't care about whether it works out for the kid??

Questor said:
And don't listen to the hot heads that are shouting at you here. They are just projecting all kinds of shit from their own lives onto you.
You can guess and suppose all you want. That's the advantage of posting anonymously. :rolleyes:
 
Armagettin said:
Really? etc. You just make this shit up to support what you want to believe. PS... I am an atheist and I already have much happiness in my life. I wish you a little more common sense in your life.[/QUOTE

Well, I must say you are the only person I have ever encountered who argues that a person is better off being raised by someone other than his two natural parents, in any combination. Are there exceptions? Of course. Many blended families are loving and successful. Many single mothers are super-women who raise happy, successful, well-balanced children.

But of course that is not the norm. Single mothers will be, on the whole, poorer and less well-educated than married mothers. That hurts the kid. Throw race into the equation, and the numbers are staggering. The unluckiest kid in America is the child of an unmarried Black woman. There aren't too many studies or policy makers or social workers who would say that a kid is better off apart from his birth parents.

Here is simply one of (many) studies that spell this out. This one, from Princeton, concludes that even kids in two-parent but blended families are worse off than children raised by their natural parents.

And seriously, check the anger. If you are trying to sumbit yourself as a poster child for a successfully-raised child of a blended family, you should probably try and hide your rage issues.

Again, God Bless you, even if you don't believe in him, and I hope you have a pleasant day.

Science & Technology
The Cinderella syndrome
Oct 26th 2000
From The Economist print edition

HALF a century ago, most American children grew up in the home of their two biological parents. Now, more than half will live apart from at least one parent before reaching the age of 18, and more than half of these will live with a step-parent or a foster parent. Disturbingly, three new studies, by Anne Case, an economist at Princeton University, and her colleagues, suggest that these children will do worse in terms of food, education and health care than other youngsters.

One of these studies, published in the October issue of the Economic Journal, finds that households in the United States where a child is raised by a non-biological mother spend less on food than those where the relationship is biological. Whether the child is raised by a step-, adoptive or foster mother, the reduction is the same. Evidence from South Africa tells a similar tale: where a child does not live with its birth-mother (as is the case for 20% of under-19-year-olds), the household spends less on milk, fruit and vegetables, and more on alcohol and tobacco.

Dr Case’s other two studies find that children not raised by their birth-mothers suffer in other ways. One discovered that 61% of children over a year old and living with both biological parents had had a medical check-up in the past year; but only 46% of those living with a stepmother had had one. The other looked at education: a mother’s own children receive, on average, one more year of schooling than do step-, foster or adopted children.

The children who do worst seem to be those living in “blended” families, sharing the mother with her birth-children. For instance, adopted children on average get an extra year of schooling if the mother who raises them has no children of her own. Some other academic work suggests that children raised by single mothers do much better, in terms of education and eventual occupation, than children raised by single fathers, or by a step-mother and their birth-father.

What is the explanation? Some differences between birth-children and others might be caused by, say, the trauma of living through a parental divorce. But the overwhelming impression is that genes are a selfish lot, and mothers invest more in the children they bear, and who thus bear their genes, than in somebody else’s children who happen to live in their home.
 
Questor said:
You can guess and suppose all you want. That's the advantage of posting anonymously. :rolleyes:

So,,,,, you don't care about the kid though, right? Just trying to confirm.
 
Either way you will be making payment for the foreseeable future. It is worth your while to get know the child and be involved in his/her life.
 
For clarity, you posted.
CapitalGuy said:
The kid is better off with 2 parents. Don't try that "its not good for the kid to be in a situation where the mother and father don't get along. <snip> the poor little fucker YOU made, is better off with you and his mom both in his life, as a couple.
The ensuing discussion has been about whether a child is better off being raised by two parents who are in a dysfunctional relationship (as you vehemently claim) or with one of those people as a single parent.(my claim)

To support the notion that kids are better off with a single parent versus a dysfunctional couple, I found and presented research, conducted by behavioural psychologists specializing in child psychology, that demonstrate there is no appreciable difference in the outcome on a child's psychological well being and their subsequent behaviour when comparing single parent vs two parent households in general. It follows that if you then compare these family units against a ‘dysfunctional’ couple’s parenting the difference will be noticeable..

Your response was a little odd…

CapitalGuy said:
Well, I must say you are the only person I have ever encountered who argues that a person is better off being raised by someone other than his two natural parents, in any combination.

Just to bring this back into focus, the questions is… “IS A CHILD BETTER OFF WITH TWO PARENTS IN A DYSFUNCTIONAL RELATIONSHIP OR WITH A SINGLE PARENT?”

You then tried to refute the studies I cited with your ‘opinion’. Making things up.
CapitalGuy said:
There aren't too many studies or policy makers or social workers who would say that a kid is better off apart from his birth parents.
This is simply not true assuming we are talking abut ‘dysfunctional’ couples. This is your ‘opinion’.

There are many, many, many, many….many studies done by professionals specializing in child development. Many, many, many. The vast, vast majority of those many studies corroborate the study I indicated. You cite three studies. Three studies by an economist. Studies that are primarily focused on the comparison of devotion a child gets from a biological mother versus a step or adoptive mother. If nothing else, your research is creative, but brings nothing to support your view.

As an aside, most single parent families in Canada are composed of a single, biological mother. . 83 percent according to the Vanier Institute in a study from 2000.

New topic: Your first post to the OP was laced with anger and bullying….
CapitalGuy said:
You want financial advice on how to scive off from being a father? On how to NOT pay for your baby? Fuck you. The kid is better off with 2 parents. Don't try that "its not good for the kid to be in a situation where the mother and father don't get along." Fucking get along. Man up. Let her move in. Get to like her. Get to love her. Give YOUR child a fighting chance to make it in this world, instead of him being another victim of selfish parents who cared more about their own comfort than in the life they created. Even though you are an immature, selfish piece of shit, the poor little fucker YOU made, is better off with you and his mom both in his life, as a couple.

And again, just so we're clear....fuck you.
Your advice to me...
CapitalGuy said:
And seriously, check the anger. If you are trying to sumbit yourself as a poster child for a successfully-raised child of a blended family, you should probably try and hide your rage issues.
Nice. (I’m not, btw)

Then, for a bit of humour, you go all tongue-in-cheek Christian on me.
CapitalGuy said:
Again, God Bless you, even if you don't believe in him, and I hope you have a pleasant day.
After your first post to the OP, it is clear that you are not actually a practicing Christian. However, you have been quite obtuse so I am reluctant to assume anything you believe. Just to be sure that you know… being a Christian means ‘living like Christ.’ I am quite familiar with both the Old Testament and New (St. James version). For the life of me I can’t find any of Christ’s teachings that include, ‘You are a selfish, immature piece of shit.” or ‘fuck you”.

Some more studies for anyone interested,
1.
“14 years ago, University of Western Ontario scientist William Avison designed a study that looked at the mental health of children raised in single mother families in Canada. His team found that even if the mothers were stressed, most of the children were not. Avison is now following up on those same families to see how the children are faring as adults. In a phone interview he said that the preliminary analysis, fourteen years later, looks equally good.

"The majority of single mothers manage to do this and do not suffer the consequences," he said. "While the mothers bear the burden of single parenthood, my sense is that their children are reasonably well-protected from that stress. Deciding or ending up as a single parent does not mean that the child is going to be emotionally stressed," he added.”

He has since completed the follow up study and findings are the same.

2.
Single mothers who have never been married are just as happy as married women with children according to a study published in January by Dr. John Cairney of the CAMH (Centre for Addiction and Mental Health) in Toronto. The study compared never-married single mothers, divorced single mothers and married mothers. Mothers who have experienced divorce were less happy than the other two groups, the study found.
<snip>
"Although this particular study was not designed to look at marital transitions "typically the problems [for divorced women] are adjustment issues," he said.
<snip>
Both Dr. Cairney and University of Western Ontario sociologist Dr. William Avison agree on the value of doing a study that looks at the effects of stigmatization on the well being of Canadian single mothers. "It has not been done but it would be a good thing to do," said Cairney. Indeed, he said, "there is stuff that gets lost," for instance, "when you talk in terms of absolutes, there are far more married women who are depressed than single mothers. If you want to look at the burden of mental health problems, they are with married spouses," he added.
 
Moraff said:
Wrong... as soon as she moves in and the child is born they are considered common-law by CRA. The presence of the child wipes out the 1-year requirement.
I'm just curious, but if they lived in the same house, but didn't share a bed or have sex after she moved in, would they still be considered common law? Technically, wouldn't they just be room mates at that point? I have no idea, so I'm just asking. But I have to agree with everyone, taking care of the child is the first priority, regardless of other considerations.
 
From personal experience, it was much better when my dad left and my siblings and I were raised by one parent. I'm sure two parents would have been great but life was pretty bad when he was around. I am only speaking solely from my experience.

We really don't know the whole story. The only thing is is that you have to pay for child support and be there as much as you can for the child. Make sure you have proper visitation rights because you do not want to miss out on your child growing up. Good luck.
 
chica69 said:
let me see if i got this straight. you are about to bring a child in this world, and are worried about your 'stuff'??? WTF dude??? what you should be worried about is that the mother can carry the child full term and be healthy so the child gets off on the right foot. As for your stuff--fuck it. Its only stuff.
From experience, I have been married 2x, divorced 2x, rich, well off and poor and still able to raise my child and make all support payments and all my friends, my ex's friends and child and her friends all say the same thing...i'm a great dad.
And you know why??
Cuz STUFF does not matter when you are raising a child!!!!!

Slow down. The guy just wants to know what will be best for him. I don't blame him one bit. His stuff is important to him so let it be. It's obvious he does not have a clear picture of what's going on but as long as he does the right thing and supports the child, then that's what's important.
 
neverwas said:
Don't listen to legal advice on this board unless it comes from Fuji or me.
If you don't let her move in the limit of your liability limit will be child support. Let her move in and you will likely be liable to support her.

Well your first eight words were correct.....after that it goes downhill fast :)
 
The Options Menu said:
1. See a lawyer.

2. Get the paternity test. If she flips out tough titty, you're just being careful.

2. Don't let her in the door until you do #1 and #2 AND ARE DAMN SURE YOU WANT HER THERE.

3. If you let her in the door get a contract drawn up, outlining things with respect to her, preferably by the lawyer from #1 before she gets in the door. Preferably outlining that this is for child rearing purposes and that she forgoes any claims of spousal support. If she flips out, once again you're just being careful and it can always be changed, or discarded in case of marriage.

4. Man up and pay your fair share of support on time an in full.

5. Be a good dad and discretely sock away $50 a month in an RESP. You might not want to tell her about that... But it's one of the best things you could do for the kid.

6. If the kid is yours do your best to be a good father no matter what happens with the woman.

Mr I ,the above is the only post in the three pages of this thread that you really need to read.
 
Not so "Incredible" I guess....

Be a man, not a Dead Beat! Your responsibility (if the child is in fact yours) is to the child!

Now be a MAN about it and not a Deadbeat! :mad:
 
train said:
Mr I ,the above is the only post in the three pages of this thread that you really need to read.

Agreed. I missed that post and now I will make some coffee. ;)
 
train said:
Mr I ,the above is the only post in the three pages of this thread that you really need to read.
Well #33 does add a point that I believed to be a "given" but #21 does stress the same things. :)
 
333conan said:
I'm just curious, but if they lived in the same house, but didn't share a bed or have sex after she moved in, would they still be considered common law? Technically, wouldn't they just be room mates at that point? I have no idea, so I'm just asking. But I have to agree with everyone, taking care of the child is the first priority, regardless of other considerations.

Without the child I'm not 100% sure of the answer... but I do know that when a man and a women are living at the same address CRA's computers will automatically flag their returns if they are filed as anything other than married/common-law. Upon investigation to (hopefully) rule out things like mother w/adult son, father w/ adult daughter, student renting a room, etc. if the agent feels there is cause to believe a common-law/married relationship is in effect will send out questionnaires to both parties to have them confirm (with proof) of the reality of the situation.

Once a child is entered into the equation CRA will automatically assume that a common-law relationship is in place and assess things like GST and CCTB accordingly as the assumption is made that the two people will both be contributing to the raising of the child.

If you're going to disprove that you'd better have rent receipts (and declare the income from them <grin>) saying that she and her child are your tenants.

And all that aside... if she moves in and has a separate room and doesn't sleep with him.... how's he going to prove that a year later when she takes him to court for half his stuff? "Yes your honour I do have a separate bedroom from him because I can't get a good night's sleep with someone else in the bed."
 
MrIncredible said:
I got my GF pregnant, however I was going to break up with her and she sprung this on me. I have indicated that I am not happy with the situation as we started this in a LD relationship. She feels strongly about keeping the child and moving in (she is 5 weeks in), she has indicated that she is fine if we move on afterwards and don't stay together. However she lives 1 1/2 hr away, we have never lived together before, or spent more then 4 or 5 days with each other. Now I have stated that I don't want the child to come into this situation where I wasn't sure about us. (we have been together for ~6 months). I guess what I advice I am looking for is how to protect myself in this situation, financially. She is just changing jobs has no benefits or anything like that.

Thx.


I haven't read all the comments, so I am sure that some have been positive and some have been negative. Here is my advice:

First, you have to accept that she is the woman who will carry this child if she so chooses and there is nothing you can do about that.

Second, you need to decide exactly what type of role you want to play in your child's life.

Third, you need to be honest with her and tell exactly what you are prepared to do and soon so she can make the choice to be a single mother if that is the option you leave her with.

If you choose to be a father in action, then you plan now. You go to all the doctors visits, you are there for the birth, you talk to a lawyer about your rights and custody be it joint, full etc. You pay for HALF of anything related to the child until child support can properly be order and you offer that reasonable child support to her.

If you choose to be a weekend father, then you prepare for that as well. You will still pay child support of course and you will need to speak to a lawyer as well to make sure that you get your weekend visitation.

If you choose not to be a father at all, then you sign away all rights and follow the guidelines of child support. You pay to her via mailed monthly cheques or child support payment services and you live your life a little less in your wallet with no reward for it.

You have just as much of a choice as she does. The only difference is because it is her body she is the one who chooses whether this child is born or not. All the rest is in your hands.

These are your honest options. Some have rewards and some have consequences. No one can tell you want road to take. This is related to the child, not to your ethic, values and morals. Those are what make up individual people in individual ways and you have to live with what type of person you are. However, I will say always be honest. Don't make a choice that will have more consequences in the end just to save face in front of society. A innocent child deserves honesty right away from their parents from day one.

Good luck.
 
Kya_Jean said:
If you choose to be a father in action, then you plan now. You go to all the doctors visits, you are there for the birth, you talk to a lawyer about your rights and custody be it joint, full etc. You pay for HALF of anything related to the child until child support can properly be order and you offer that reasonable child support to her.

and get and keep the receipts