Acer: US PC makers will disappear

danmand

Well-known member
Nov 28, 2003
46,971
5,606
113
Acer founder Stan Shih: US-based PC makers will lose market dominance in two decades
Submitted by Justin Sorkin on Wed, 01/20/2010 - 08:11 Technology SectorGadgetsFeaturedTNMAcer

Forecasting a change in the computer market scenario in the next two decades, Stan Shih, the founder of Taiwan’s top computer-maker Acer, told the Taipei-based Commercial Times that the ‘differential response’ that the US-based personal computer makers faced amid recession is an indication that these companies will lose their dominance over the PC market.

Shih’s opinion is essentially based on the plunging sales that US-based PC makers, like Hewlett-Packard (HP) and Dell, witnessed during the downturn; while Taiwanese OEMs ASUSTek and Acer showed impressive growth, thanks to their increasing sales of low-priced netbooks.

However, Shih refrained from commenting about the US-based Apple which, despite having a pricey range of computers, is growing and gaining substantial market share.

Noting that US-based PC makers will face difficult times in the coming years, Shih said: “The trend for low-priced computers will last for the coming years. But US computer makers just don't know how to put such products on the market... US computer brands may disappear over the next 20 years, just like what happened to US television brands.”

The seemingly boastful viewpoint of the Acer founder is largely based on Acer’s extraordinary performance in 2009 - the company surpassed Dell to become the second-ranking computer maker in the world; and, according to Digitimes, Acer appears to be on its way to beat HP to bag the top slot in 2011.
 
2 decades??? I think it may happen sooner....

Cheers!
 
BS..I don't believe it.. it was gonna to happen, it should have happened already..I heard that 3/4 of all PC comoponents were made in Taiwan/Asian 10 years ago! Even all the Mac/iphone are made in china now...if the US brand is gonna go away, it should have happened already...There's always a place for nationalist/buy local and royal customer.. what I m saying is never under-estimate the power of marketing
 
I don't believe it either. Maybe I'm missing something here but all this Acer guy is saying is that people bought more low-priced Taiwanese netbooks during a recession while they avoided the more expensive US brands. Big deal. Those same people shopped at WalMart more often during the same recession. Recessions make people pull in their horns so they make sacrifices and buy the cheap stuff even though they'd rather buy the prestige brand. That doesn't mean everyone will stay with the cheapo brands forever. When things return to normal, people will buy trusted brands with the best ratings, best performance, best perceived value and there is no reason why those will always be Taiwanese.
 
Could very well happen. The trend is moving towards smaller and smaller PCs that keep getting more and more powerful and cheaper. USA can't compete against third world countries on price.
 
I don't believe it either. Maybe I'm missing something here but all this Acer guy is saying is that people bought more low-priced Taiwanese netbooks during a recession while they avoided the more expensive US brands. Big deal. Those same people shopped at WalMart more often during the same recession. Recessions make people pull in their horns so they make sacrifices and buy the cheap stuff even though they'd rather buy the prestige brand. That doesn't mean everyone will stay with the cheapo brands forever. When things return to normal, people will buy trusted brands with the best ratings, best performance, best perceived value and there is no reason why those will always be Taiwanese.

I think you are missing the point. When all PC's are manufactured in Asia, there is no
rationale anymore for paying extra for a machine marketed by an american company.
Happened with TV's, and all other consumer goods.
Innovations will also slowly but surely go to the manufacturing base.
 
Probably.
With PC price wars, PC makers are pricing themselves out of the market.
Eg. The mark up on netbooks is next to nothing.
 
PC's are a commodity. They stopped being a unique item years ago.

One key to this argument will be shipping costs and the supply chain. It may be cheaper to have the components made in Asia and assembled here. A packaged PC in a cardboard box takes up a lot of space for shipping.

That is the current defacto status.

Another, and far greater factor, is what will be the nature of computing in 20 years. Does small palm sized computing take over, will there be something new?

As a general rule I put a five year limit on predictions. Politicians and sooth-sayers can say anything for what will happen in 20 years because they do not have to do it.

It is only when someone makes a commitment to do something specific within 24 or 26 months that I take them seriously.
 
Maybe

HP and Dell use all Chinese components. The most successful companies follow the Nike example. They don't own any factories, they contract out everything except design and marketing.

I think Dell and HP will continue to exist and thrive.

Acer is crap. Ask any repair technician about their laptops and the problems with the internal display connectors that are glued to the boards. After so many openings and closings, the connector craps out and the mainboard is toast.

I would place Asus far above Acer. They built their reputation on quality stuff, I hope they don't cheap out like Acer.

Acer's lack of quality will eventually bite them. The hubris shown by their CEO is typical.
 
Maybe, but who would have thought IBM would exit the PC business?

They didn't exit, IBM just moved to RED China....
sad1.gif
 
They didn't exit, IBM just moved to RED China....
sad1.gif
You talking about selling their retail pc division? IBM has been constantly dropping low margin areas, and lenovo was already china based. Keep in mind most of the manufacturing under US brands was already over there. Having dell assemble pc's in texas isn't really "manufacturing".
 
In the future ll computers will be one big silicon chip with a screen abd keyboard attached to it. The will all be made in China because the USA can not compete in labour cost.
 
HP and Dell use all Chinese components. The most successful companies follow the Nike example. They don't own any factories, they contract out everything except design and marketing.

I think Dell and HP will continue to exist and thrive.

Acer is crap. Ask any repair technician about their laptops and the problems with the internal display connectors that are glued to the boards. After so many openings and closings, the connector craps out and the mainboard is toast.

I would place Asus far above Acer. They built their reputation on quality stuff, I hope they don't cheap out like Acer.

Acer's lack of quality will eventually bite them. The hubris shown by their CEO is typical.

Agree 100% Acer is crap compared to Asus or Dell. Acer is selling so much because they are cheap, thats the only reason.
 
Asus laptops were rated best right now. They look and feel solid.
 
The PC business is a commodity business - not much value add - except the processors.

Apple is the exception.

OTB
 
There is a huge difference between being second ranked computer maker in the world and being profitable. HP and Dell will be ahead of Acer for a long time.
 
The PC business is a commodity business - not much value add - except the processors.

Apple is the exception.

OTB

Not really! Apple ranks about equal to Dell quality-wise...
rm_frog.gif