#4

Actually howt the census defines a Metropolitan Statistical Area is quite precisely spelled out.

Be careful what you wish for, you just may get it. :(

A Stats Can CMA is very different from a so-called MSA. Chicagoland has an area of 28,120 km2 and extends to 4 states (and a lot of this is apparently rural). By comparison the GTA has a mere 7,124.15 km2.

Using Americans standards the GTA would consist of the entire Golden Horseshoe which spans 31,561.57 km2 and has a population of 8,759,312 per the last census. Chicagoland's population was 9,729,825 in 2011.
 
I was under the impression that since the GTA became the GTA that brampton missisauga and few others are all part of the city itself now and arejust subdivisions of toronto as a whole.

no. there is no entity called GTA. its just a description of an area
 
A Stats Can CMA is very different from a so-called MSA. Chicagoland has an area of 28,120 km2 and extends to 4 states (and a lot of this is apparently rural). By comparison the GTA has a mere 7,124.15 km2.

Using Americans standards the GTA would consist of the entire Golden Horseshoe which spans 31,561.57 km2 and has a population of 8,759,312 per the last census. Chicagoland's population was 9,729,825 in 2011.

urban area populations can vary widely depending on what criteria are used. My old TERB-buddy Mad Max used to call his hometown of Boston "small" compared to TO. But the latest MSA gives Boston a population of 7,000,000 and includes half of Southern New England and makes Boston larger than Detroit - which is silly. Clearly the MSA criteria refers to the entire economic catchment area of a city and does not really define the extent of urbanization accurately.

If I was to determine the economic catchment area of TO, I would draw a wiggly line from London, ON. to the Falls and around to Belleville, Peterborough and Barrie. OTOH, my same wiggly line around Chicago would probably include Milwaukee WI and Grand Rapids MI and Chicago would probably still be "bigger".
 
BTW, my own idiosyncratic definition of MSA would be as follows:

"The distance that a pooner will drive into a city to rent some pussy without bothering to stop for lunch along the way."
 
Since this stat doesn't include the GTA as a whole being number #4 is just a measure of population density within the city limits. Not sure higher density is anything to be proud of.