10 Minute Breathlyzer

see how everybody here is mad at the judge whose job was to decide if 10 minutes of your life wasted is enough to draw the line but nobody so far came up with a solid number of minutes they would happily sacrifice. So you'd feel it's ok for you to sit in the car and waist say 30 minutes?

Easy pal, have a drink and calm your nerves.

I don't hear of anybody who hasn't been drinking suing their local police force for being held up, when they haven't been drinking, to do a breathalyzer test. Not a one. Nor have I heard of any complaints for such.

I've waited 20+ minutes to get through a Ride Check and I hadn't had a drop of alcohol in me....I admit, a little frustrating, but it's something that's been around a long time and is for the good of all.

The issue I see is that the judge isn't applying common sense here, but instead looks at this as a black and white issue. The judge doesn't see it for what it is, an inconvenience yes, but not an infringement on their rights, as the police got it right and got an impaired driver off the roads.
 
It's WASTE, not WAIST people!!
You must be used to looking up SP's stats.
 
an inconvenience yes, but not an infringement on their rights, as the police got it right and got an impaired driver off the roads.

Um you cannot justify the means with the ends. Otherwise you give the police carte blanche to search everyone on the street and charge whoever is found to have drugs or other contraband. Nazi Germany probably was a better state than that.

While the judge is looking at the roadside charter breach (which is done via a "trial within a trial" procedure called voir dire) he is giving zero consideration to what is found later. And this compartmentalization is the only proper way to do it.
 
Um you cannot justify the means with the ends. Otherwise you give the police carte blanche to search everyone on the street and charge whoever is found to have drugs or other contraband. Nazi Germany probably was a better state than that.

While the judge is looking at the roadside charter breach (which is done via a "trial within a trial" procedure called voir dire) he is giving zero consideration to what is found later. And this compartmentalization is the only proper way to do it.

But there was no illegal search. Just a delay in administering the only one (the breathalyzer test). That delay didn't seem to be an arbitrary one but an honest error in judgement or procedure by the cop who probably had to check the situation out. The accused was tested after 10 minutes of the cop notifying him that he would screen him and failed that test. Then the accused was tested again at the police station with a blood alcohol level of 0.10 TWO hours later!!!!

While I acknowledge that 10 minutes may not mean "forthwith" in the ordinary sense of the word, THIS was not a case of a R.I.D.E. stop but the scene of a traffic accident. So the cop probably had to assess the accident scene to figure things out.

I think the judge weighed heavily in favour of the accused because he didn't believe the cop's inquiry into domestic violence as an excuse for the delay, and maybe thought the cop was lying to him. So he focused on that as if he was dealing with a rogue cop who broke the law and trampled on someone's rights.

In the context of this situation or circumstances, I think the judge made an mistake such that "Forthwith" could sometimes mean "ASAP" (in my humble opinion of course).
 
I think the judge weighed heavily in favour of the accused because he didn't believe the cop's inquiry into domestic violence as an excuse for the delay, and maybe thought the cop was lying to him. So he focused on that as if he was dealing with a rogue cop who broke the law and trampled on someone's rights

you've got it; here's a quote:

[34] Crown counsel endeavours to explain the delay by suggesting that the officer abruptly found himself “riding two horses” when he was suddenly presented with a domestic assault investigation, raising public safety concerns of elevated priority. It might, of course, have helped the Crown’s case had Saib himself couched his purported dilemma in this fashion, but he did not. Further, and as I assess the evidence, there was simply no objective foundation for any concern respecting a domestic assault. The defendant had volunteered that he and his girlfriend had had an “argument” – not a “fight”. The girlfriend, Ruiz, did not raise any alarm and showed no signs of injury. Nor was there any indication of struggle or any demeanour evidence suggestive of fear, distress or even concern. Nor, it appears, did Saib make even the briefest of inquiries of Ruiz. The officer, in short, was off on his own unfounded frolic. He may have believed he was “doing the right thing” but his belief had no basis in shared reality. Further, he continued to make inessential inquiries of the defendant during this 10-minute interval. In my view, Saib’s delay in making the demand was not so much a product of divided investigative loyalties as it was his own indifference to his statutory and constitutional obligations.
https://www.canlii.org/en/on/oncj/d...AAAAAQAMbWVsdnluIGdyZWVuAAAAAAE&resultIndex=1
 
in Ontario you blow between 51 and 99 mg% and you automatically lose your license for 90 days without meaningful right of appeal. You have no clue whether the damn thing even has been calibrated ever.
Should again mention (as mentioned in #4) you do have to test after arrest on a large calibrated BAC testing machine typically at the regional jail.
 
you've got it; here's a quote:

[34] Crown counsel endeavours to explain the delay by suggesting that the officer abruptly found himself “riding two horses” when he was suddenly presented with a domestic assault investigation, raising public safety concerns of elevated priority. It might, of course, have helped the Crown’s case had Saib himself couched his purported dilemma in this fashion, but he did not. Further, and as I assess the evidence, there was simply no objective foundation for any concern respecting a domestic assault. The defendant had volunteered that he and his girlfriend had had an “argument” – not a “fight”. The girlfriend, Ruiz, did not raise any alarm and showed no signs of injury. Nor was there any indication of struggle or any demeanour evidence suggestive of fear, distress or even concern. Nor, it appears, did Saib make even the briefest of inquiries of Ruiz. The officer, in short, was off on his own unfounded frolic. He may have believed he was “doing the right thing” but his belief had no basis in shared reality. Further, he continued to make inessential inquiries of the defendant during this 10-minute interval. In my view, Saib’s delay in making the demand was not so much a product of divided investigative loyalties as it was his own indifference to his statutory and constitutional obligations.
https://www.canlii.org/en/on/oncj/d...AAAAAQAMbWVsdnluIGdyZWVuAAAAAAE&resultIndex=1

Thank you for the citation.

It does put some context to the judge's decision, and he's not stupid, but the decision still troubles me.
 
Should again mention (as mentioned in #4) you do have to test after arrest on a large calibrated BAC testing machine typically at the regional jail.

That's right! (Which is why they tested our friend in this case at the station 2 hours later - now that seemed like a long time he he).
 
Another factor which the average person doesn't take into account, is how crooked the legal system is. If you retain a lawyer who knows the right judge, these guys kick favours to each other all the time. Half of these guys went law school together, or worked with each in some capacity, so there's tons of behind the scenes stuff.

To this day, nobody can explain how Rick Vaive got off when it should have been an open and closed case. What we do know is he retained Calvin Barry as his legal counsel, who has a reputation for shadiness and knows tons of people different judicial jurisdictions. So the problem is, you can never fully tell how a judge arrives at his/her decision.
 
That's right! (Which is why they tested our friend in this case at the station 2 hours later - now that seemed like a long time he he).
And I don't believe there is a North American jurisdiction where that wouldn't go well for the defendant. In my neck of the woods, I'd place significant money on it going goodbye (same result as this case but different reason).
 
Another factor which the average person doesn't take into account, is how crooked the legal system is. If you retain a lawyer who knows the right judge, these guys kick favours to each other all the time. Half of these guys went law school together, or worked with each in some capacity, so there's tons of behind the scenes stuff.
Ontario may be the cesspool of corruption you believe it to be, although I doubt it in the extreme.

But I can certainly tell you in my jurisdiction I've never heard or seen such a thing. Attempting such would be a fantastic way of being disbarred so fast that your head would spin, also possible criminal charges as well.
 
Attempting such would be a fantastic way of being disbarred so fast that your head would spin, also possible criminal charges as well.

That's why they only do it with people they know. They don't walk over to a judge or a crown attorney they don't know and say "hey, can you do me a favor?"

I'm not saying it's a "cesspool" but I'm telling you that deals are made behind the scenes. All you have to do is call up some of the big lawyers that specialize in impaired driving like Calvin Berry or Fred Fedorsen, tell them you've been charged and set up a consultation. During that consultation, they will ask what court your being tried at, and once you tell them, they will say something like "I know half the people in that court" and if they only know a few, they will still say " I know a few people in that court".

Depending on the lawyer, you have to be careful, because someone like Calvin Berry will tell you he knows tons of people in every jurisdiction, when in reality knows a lot some and non it others, not to mention he has just as many enemies in those jurisdictions. Calvin Berry will also tell you everything you want to hear, and unless your a high profile client, once he gets your money, you get put on the back burner and he might even send one of his lackey's to represent you. Fred Fedorsen on the other hand is known as a straight shooter. If he tells you he knows a bunch of people at that court, he knows a bunch of people at that court. Some courts he'll tell you not even to bother fighting it and to go plead guilty. Go a head a give them a call if you don't believe me. If you think side deals aren't being between some of these guys your being extremely naïve.
 
Last edited: