Mark Carney cranks up immigration again, while pretending not to.

not here in Canada
We had a decade of Liberal incompetence, ideological driven mismanagement, gutting of the public purse, economic decline and non stop government corruption / scandals
Yet the Liberals were re-elected

this is comprehensive and unconditional validation for the Liberals
They know they will not be held accountable

Bringing up Merkel's Germany will disturb Liberal supporters here.
We had plenty of members singing her praises simply because she kept winning and putting coalitions together.

However issues were festering beneath the surface in Germany.
I have been saying for a couple years that democracies need some political competition.

I also don't think Carney has the long leash that some here think.
Your expected 2029 elections will not have the specter of Trump to create the outside antagonist.
 
Quoting the movie Patton: "All glory is fleeting."

Electoral victories are fleeting. Political parties often misinterpret them as comprehensive and unconditional validation.

Consensus needs to be durable on an issue-by-issue basis.

Of course, and all politicians have a due date. Look what happened to Trudeau, and to Trump.

But to say he isn't ascendant right now, with some polling at 60+% approval rating, coupled with the leadership of both the Conservatives and the NDP either swirling the bowl or already flushed, means you ain't paying attention.

And if this strategy of waiting out the USA with diversity of trade deals works, he will get two more terms if he wants them. Canadians may occasionally flirt with populist, but we love little grey men in suits who can run shit, and don't take shit.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Driller69
Liberal media and politicians gloss over the practical history of immigration.
Large scale immigration typically accompanied economic booms.
Industrial expansion in North America required a larger workforce.
The Great Depression and then World War 2 basically stopped North American immigration.

One of the challenges that North America and Europe and South Korea and Japan are going to face over the next decade is…….where will the growth come from?

there are no prospects for economic expansion, the largest economy in the ‘western world’ has stated their future growth is tied to AI…….AI is efficient because it reduces workforces.
 
Bringing up Merkel's Germany will disturb Liberal supporters here.
We had plenty of members singing her praises simply because she kept winning and putting coalitions together.

However issues were festering beneath the surface in Germany.
I have been saying for a couple years that democracies need some political competition.

I also don't think Carney has the long leash that some here think.
Your expected 2029 elections will not have the specter of Trump to create the outside antagonist.

The spector won't be needed imo. Competency matters up here. Its why Harper got his majority in the end. And Chretien. Add in the leadership problems with the other two majors. Much like 2024 the competition matters. And 2016 for that matter.

As long as there are no major fuck ups, he will win.

And as always the economy generally sets the mood of the nation. But if the Conservatives for some reason start to poll well under PP, there will be plenty of vote switches from the NDP.
 
The birthrate has to increase beyond replacement levels which will increase the population. Which wont keep population at stable numbers.
You keep contradicting yourself. First you say we have a declining birth rate, which will cause a population collapse. Then you say the birth rate must increase, which will increase the population. Which is it?
 
You keep contradicting yourself. First you say we have a declining birth rate, which will cause a population collapse. Then you say the birth rate must increase, which will increase the population. Which is it?
Yes, so where is the contradiction?
I think you're confusing demographic sustainability with population size.
With fertility below replacement, the population ages and the ratio of retirees to workers keeps deteriorating.
Immigration can address that, but you cannot indefinitely rejuvenate an ageing population through immigration while expecting the total population to remain static.
Example: Younger immigrants have children too. Those children add to the population, even if they won't enter the workforce for another 20 years. They may also bring spouses and dependent children through family reunification.
Therefore, if you address the underlying demographic imbalance with immigration it is inevitably going to increase the population.
 
Last edited:
One of the challenges that North America and Europe and South Korea and Japan are going to face over the next decade is…….where will the growth come from?

there are no prospects for economic expansion, the largest economy in the ‘western world’ has stated their future growth is tied to AI…….AI is efficient because it reduces workforces.

AI will likely lead to an expanded government role at least initially. I am not a fan of Universal Basic Income and prefer expanding the Earned Income Tax Credit in some manner. It's possible more people will be employed in elderly care as the baby boom ages.

It will be interesting to see how AI impacts export-heavy countries like China, South Korea and Germany progress in an AI world.
 
Therefore, if you address the underlying demographic imbalance with immigration it is inevitably going to increase the population.
Dead wrong. It depends on how many immigrants you bring in. For example, what if you brought just one couple, and they have four children here? You're saying six people will inevitably lead to an increase in the population?
 
Dead wrong. It depends on how many immigrants you bring in. For example, what if you brought just one couple, and they have four children here? You're saying six people will inevitably lead to an increase in the population?
Lets say 10,000 people retire and you issue 10,000 approvals for immigrants to replace them in the workforce.
You'd have an entry of say 20,000 to 30,000 new immigrants, as they will bring their spouses, and/or dependent children.
Those who come here single will marry and have kids. Those kids wont be part of the workforce.
So as you can see, your population will inevitably increase.
 
Lets say 10,000 people retire and you issue 10,000 approvals for immigrants to replace them in the workforce.
You'd have an entry of say 20,000 to 30,000 new immigrants, as they will bring their spouses, and/or dependent children.
Those who come here single will marry and have kids. Those kids wont be part of the workforce.
So as you can see, your population will inevitably increase.
You mistakenly think that every retiree must be replaced by an immigrant, as if there are no people here. A declining population does not mean there are no young people. Just fewer young people.

Lets say 10,000 people retire and 7,000 locals replace them. The shortfall is only 3,000 jobs. So you issue only 3,000 approvals for immigrants.
 
Lets say 10,000 people retire and 7,000 locals replace them. The shortfall is only 3,000 jobs. So you issue only 3,000 approvals for immigrants.
Currently, 7,000 locals aren't available to replace them, don't want to replace them, or aren't skilled enough to do so. Hence the labour shortages.
Also, even using your figure of 3,000 immigration approvals, that's potentially 6,000 - 9000 new immigrants once spouses and dependants are included.
So instead of the 20,000 - 30,000 in my original example, you're still looking at a population increase of 6k to 9k.
The numbers are smaller, but the population still increases, which was my original point.
 
You mistakenly think that every retiree must be replaced by an immigrant, as if there are no people here. A declining population does not mean there are no young people. Just fewer young people.

Lets say 10,000 people retire and 7,000 locals replace them. The shortfall is only 3,000 jobs. So you issue only 3,000 approvals for immigrants.

high level one for one reeplacement math is flawed

immigration have to focus on fulfilling the skills required, not just replacing warm bodies
 
Stable means the population remains unchanged, with current birthrates. Which means a smaller younger population supporting an increasingly aging population.
That is demographic collapse.
As someone born here, I hope I was able to educate you.

So the economy must function like cancer with infinite growth or it dies?
Capitalism has a serious flaw.
 
Currently, 7,000 locals aren't available to replace them, don't want to replace them, or aren't skilled enough to do so. Hence the labour shortages.
Also, even using your figure of 3,000 immigration approvals, that's potentially 6,000 - 9000 new immigrants once spouses and dependants are included.
So instead of the 20,000 - 30,000 in my original example, you're still looking at a population increase of 6k to 9k.
The numbers are smaller, but the population still increases, which was my original point.

The only other option would be to choose policies that allow families to afford to have more kids.
But that would require way more money in wages and immigrants are cheaper.
 
The only other option would be to choose policies that allow families to afford to have more kids.
But that would require way more money in wages and immigrants are cheaper.
There is cultural change too regarding wanting to have kids.
A lot of people choose to stay single couples as well as a lifestyle choice.
 
problem with this, to me anyway, is that when they say they want to crank up immigration what they actually mean is they want corporations to be able to bring in outside temporary workers so they don't have to pay a normal human wage so they can keep raking in profits for slave labour
 
If you want innovation and progress, you need to have capital investment and growth.
If someone is investing, they'd want profits. Aka capitalism.

Innovation doesn't need growth, you can do change without adding more people.
The only people who want those massive profits are the psychopaths who are billionaires.
We need a new way to get rid of them and put that money back into the system for good change.