Mark Carney cranks up immigration again, while pretending not to.

Not wanting to see people from the Indian subcontinent is automatically xenophobia which you've already pointed to earlier. So what could one possibly debate there?
Nazis do what Nazis do.
It's silly responses like this that give rise to the remigration crowd. This is no different than calling people antisemites if they say anything about Israel.

Read what he wrote: "many people do not like to see so many people from the Indian subcontinent suddenly in Canada."

Do you understand the difference between a slow and rapid rate of change? The rapid change is what's unsettling for so many people.

This is what should be debated in a calm, dispassionate manner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: WyattEarp
It's silly responses like this that give rise to the remigration crowd. This is no different than calling people antisemites if they say anything about Israel.

Read what he wrote: "many people do not like to see so many people from the Indian subcontinent suddenly in Canada."

Do you understand the difference between a slow and rapid rate of change? The rapid change is what's unsettling for so many people.

This is what should be debated in a calm, dispassionate manner.
No, it isn't just the rapid change because these people existed even when immigration was at a level you propose.
Someone concerned only with numbers of immigrants to Canada will have the exact same problem if a similar number of Europeans immigrated to Canada.
However this is not the case.
The statement explicitly notes that "many people do not like to see so many people from the Indian subcontinent suddenly in Canada."
So the issue is with the kind of people immigrating and not just their numbers.
Hence why, opposition to immigration from these circles, as I said in my very first post, is just xenophobia cloaked in phony displays of economic concern or patriotism or what have you.
It is also often conflated with general Canadian concerns that there is "too much immigration" which most agree with and know.
So my position is, LET the remigration crowd get loud. Let them whine and cry and protest. So what?
While a reduced rate of immigration that you are proposing may have other economic justifications, one should not aim to keep people of colour as invisible as possible just to not rile up these dregs of society.
We cannot, should not and do not placate or appease Nazis.
We liberals will beat them where it matters - in elections, in the parliament and in the marketplace. Just as we did last year with Carney's win.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Driller69
It's silly responses like this that give rise to the remigration crowd. This is no different than calling people antisemites if they say anything about Israel.

Read what he wrote: "many people do not like to see so many people from the Indian subcontinent suddenly in Canada."

Do you understand the difference between a slow and rapid rate of change? The rapid change is what's unsettling for so many people.

This is what should be debated in a calm, dispassionate manner.
If you are looking for an honest discussion from the liberal base, you'll never find it.

All they do is Straw man arguments.

The goal isn't to do what is right, it's to get their way.

Never vote Liberal. It's nothing but dishonesty and corruption on their side.
 
So my position is, LET the remigration crowd get loud. Let them whine and cry and protest. So what?
A very foolish position. The same kind that got Trump elected, twice.
 
He can't even house the homeless yet hes housing immigrants.
Its time we admit that a lot of the homeless are on the streets because they chose that path.
We should not waste tax dollars on their housing.
 
If you are looking for an honest discussion from the liberal base, you'll never find it.

All they do is Straw man arguments.

The goal isn't to do what is right, it's to get their way.

Never vote Liberal. It's nothing but dishonesty and corruption on their side.

They also fail to comprehend that "what is right" in a democracy is first and foremost a durable consensus.

You can just watch how Western Europe is pulling itself apart at the seams because there was no consensus over mass immigration.
 
Last edited:
They also fail to comprehend that "what is right" in a democracy is first and foremos a durable consensus.

You can just watch how Western Europe is pulling itself apart at the seams because there was no consensus over mass immigration.
Western Europe is not an accurate comparison. They took in a bunch of refugees and were flooded with illegals from the middle east and africa who statistically commit more crime, are on welfare, and refuse to integrate because they are islamists.
 
Western Europe is not an accurate comparison. They took in a bunch of refugees and were flooded with illegals from the middle east and africa who statistically commit more crime, are on welfare, and refuse to integrate because they are islamists.

My main point is consensus building in a democracy is the overarching goal.

Of course, the type of migration in Canada differs from Western Europe.
Just like U.S. immigration differs with a high proportion of migration from Latin America.
 
They also fail to comprehend that "what is right" in a democracy is first and foremos a durable consensus.
No. "What is right" in a democracy is first and foremost representation, not simply the will of the majority.
What you are describing is majoritarianism. And majoritarianism, when unchecked, can legitimise the tyranny of the majority, allowing the rights and interests of minorities to be trampled simply because they lack the numbers to resist it.
Democracy is not merely about who has the most votes. It's also about protecting those who don't.