Canada's 4 largest airports to be opened up to private investment, Carney says

And I am agreeing it is bad.
Doesn't mean you are now suddenly arguing in good faith.
You hate Carney and will trumpet anything you think makes him look bad, regardless of your own views on the matter.
That some of those attacks are valid is largely incidental.
And another thing too. Why is it that liberal supporters can base their whole existence on bad faith arguments and you won’t call it out?
 
Why don't you want to see it happen?
Oh come on. Are you being serious?

There is virtually no justification for this. The airports are public owned operations that make money and invest in themselves. They are not a financial burden to the public like Canada Post. Even if they were, selling should be the last resort.

Selling them would mean they become profit driven. This ultimately means higher fees (we pay more) and lower expenses (job cuts).

History is the best teacher and this play of public-to-private usually, if not always. ends up bad for the people. Since Carney has lived in the UK, I'm sure he is aware of the London’s Heathrow airport failures. Why repeat this?
 
  • Like
Reactions: The Oracle
Oh come on. Are you being serious?

There is virtually no justification for this. The airports are public owned operations that make money and invest in themselves. They are not a financial burden to the public like Canada Post. Even if they were, selling should be the last resort.

Selling them would mean they become profit driven. This ultimately means higher fees (we pay more) and lower expenses (job cuts).

History is the best teacher and this play of public-to-private usually, if not always. ends up bad for the people. Since Carney has lived in the UK, I'm sure he is aware of the London’s Heathrow airport failures. Why repeat this?
You are being too kind when you stated, "There is virtually no justification for this".

There is absolutely NO JUSTIFICATION AT ALL FOR THIS. ZERO FUCK ALL JUSTICATION.
 
Oh come on. Are you being serious?

Yes.

There is virtually no justification for this. The airports are public owned operations that make money and invest in themselves. They are not a financial burden to the public like Canada Post. Even if they were, selling should be the last resort.
Selling them would mean they become profit driven. This ultimately means higher fees (we pay more) and lower expenses (job cuts).

Interesting.
So you are against privatization of these sorts of things except as a last resort, and that is what you object to about this.
Am I understanding you correctly?

History is the best teacher and this play of public-to-private usually, if not always. ends up bad for the people. Since Carney has lived in the UK, I'm sure he is aware of the London’s Heathrow airport failures. Why repeat this?

OK.
I apologize for assuming you were making a bad faith argument here.
 
Just so we are clear, Pearson doesn't lose money. It's a public-owned operation that pays for and re-invests in itself.

Carney is essentially giving profits away to his friends for no reason.
It is a captive market, a government monopoly, you can not use profits as a measure for anything. Canadapost would be profitable if it was the only option to ship shit. The TTC would be profitable if it were the only available form of transportation.
 
It is a captive market, a government monopoly, you can not use profits as a measure for anything. Canadapost would be profitable if it was the only option to ship shit. The TTC would be profitable if it were the only available form of transportation.
I can and will use any type of gains as measure.
 
No, I am proving you are.

You complaining that it's a captive market, government monopoly. But ok to give this monopoly away to the private sector?

Do yourself a favour and stop.:ROFLMAO:
I am not complaining that it is a captive market or a monopoly. I am just complaining that the metric you use is nonsense and does not account for reality.

There are other reasons to not privatise; flying could be argued as essential, security ramifications, etc...
 
I am not complaining that it is a captive market or a monopoly. I am just complaining that the metric you use is nonsense and does not account for reality.

There are other reasons to not privatise; flying could be argued as essential, security ramifications, etc...
An operation that covers it's own expenses is nonsense and not based on the most solid form of reality, math?

Ok. whatever you say chief.
 
Oh come on. Are you being serious?

There is virtually no justification for this. The airports are public owned operations that make money and invest in themselves. They are not a financial burden to the public like Canada Post. Even if they were, selling should be the last resort.

Selling them would mean they become profit driven. This ultimately means higher fees (we pay more) and lower expenses (job cuts).

History is the best teacher and this play of public-to-private usually, if not always. ends up bad for the people. Since Carney has lived in the UK, I'm sure he is aware of the London’s Heathrow airport failures. Why repeat this?
I do agree with DesRicardo here. While I do understand why the pension plans (and foreign investors) want to buy the airports, I think there is a history of this shit going sideways. And not only in the UK.

Basically, it boils down to this: Private investors want to maximize their returns. How do they do that? They either raise costs/fees or cut services. Now, if the government was smart (and lets face it, they tend to get it wrong in these cases), they would insist that prices cannot jump for passengers/airlines to within some sort of range, maybe 3% per year or something like that, to account for higher costs or what not. Would the investors agree to that? I mean, they could make more money by offering better amenities to passengers that are discretionary...

Now, is that feasible? Would these investors balk at that type of contract? Probably. But, since we don't know what type of structure the deal would be, it is hard to really argue for or against it. If the investors only ran the concessions in the airport (restaurants, shops, spas, movie theatres, gyms, etc.), then let 'em go nuts. But if they start encroaching in things like landing fees or shit like that, shit that could results in higher fares for travellers, fuck that noise.
 
It is a captive market, a government monopoly, you can not use profits as a measure for anything. Canadapost would be profitable if it was the only option to ship shit. The TTC would be profitable if it were the only available form of transportation.

But you can use it as a measure of "it is costing the government to run it".

You can't talk about it terms of competitiveness or efficiency with no competition, but "this is an expense" or not (in general terms of "it pays for itself") is valid.
 
But you can use it as a measure of "it is costing the government to run it".

You can't talk about it terms of competitiveness or efficiency with no competition, but "this is an expense" or not (in general terms of "it pays for itself") is valid.
The government sets the airport fee, the people have to pay it. The government can aim to make 50% margin and raise fees, and people will pay. The government can say they want to encourage flying more and accept a loss and lower the fees, and the people will pay.

If Canadapost was the only option to ship and the government ended up breaking even on it, would that be a data point worth considering?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter