Mark Carney cranks up immigration again, while pretending not to.

you really do not understand what has happened
No we do. You don't. As usual.
That move to reduce points to 50, was the right thing to do.
The goal of permanent immigration to Canada is demographic adjustment towards a lower median age and high skilled workers who have the potential to secure jobs.
They wanted to eliminate the golden ticket effect where someone of an older age, lower education and lower language scores could still make it through the invitation process as opposed to a 25 year old a few years out of college.
The former defeats the purpose of permanent immigration to Canada.
The other points you are failing to mention is that you constantly whine about immigrants having jobs as well.
If temp workers come here and take up lower paying jobs that Canadians won't do - you have a problem with that.
If bright high skilled workers come here and are working on securing jobs - you have a problem with that.
So keep whining.
 
Nobody with a seat.
Right. It's disingenuous to say zero immigration because it's not a real thing.

I just think that Liberals/NDP/The Left (whatever they are) will never allow an honest discussion about immigration.

We need to start from a place that acknowledges there are deceitful people on both sides. Denial of this prevents the seeking of truth and remedy.


I'll tell you the #1 reason why higher immigration should be a non-starter. There are too many holes in the process and it is done deliberately.

This Liberal government has done nothing about moving out of the grey area needed immigration. It's why you can raise immigration number but next year they will still cry "We need more nursed. construction workers, etc". It's a very dishonest game, horribly managed.
 
Right. It's disingenuous to say zero immigration because it's not a real thing.

I just think that Liberals/NDP/The Left (whatever they are) will never allow an honest discussion about immigration.

We need to start from a place that acknowledges there are deceitful people on both sides. Denial of this prevents the seeking of truth and remedy.


I'll tell you the #1 reason why higher immigration should be a non-starter. There are too many holes in the process and it is done deliberately.

This Liberal government has done nothing about moving out of the grey area needed immigration. It's why you can raise immigration number but next year they will still cry "We need more nursed. construction workers, etc". It's a very dishonest game, horribly managed.
There are so many vested interests that it is unlikely to change. Especially since we do not live in a direct democracy.
How much of this is really about getting more nurses and construction workers compared to say more phone plans for Telus and Bell, mortgages for the banks ,customers for the airlines, more customers for developers, etc. Joe Lunch Bucket does not have a lobby group.
 
There are so many vested interests that it is unlikely to change. Especially since we do not live in a direct democracy.
How much of this is really about getting more nurses and construction workers compared to say more phone plans for Telus and Bell, mortgages for the banks ,customers for the airlines, more customers for developers, etc. Joe Lunch Bucket does not have a lobby group.
If Joe Lunch Bucket speaks out, he’s quickly labeled a xenophobe. No matter facts based his argument is.
 
you really do not understand what has happened
Ahmed Hussen—who served as Canada's Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship from 2017 to 2019

During Hussen's tenure as Immigration Minister, the Comprehensive Ranking System (CRS) cutoff scores required for candidates to receive an Invitation to Apply (ITA) through Canada's Express Entry system dropped significantly: [1, 2]

Prior to Hessens changes, an applicant who had a Canaidan Job Offer was awarded 800 points for his / her CRS score
Hussen changed that to 50 points


The liberal agenda was not to match immigration to Canadas skill needs / gap , rather it was to admit anyone with a pulse

the globalist agenda

AI Overview
The Century Initiative is a national, non-partisan registered charity and advocacy movement founded in 2014 that aims to grow Canada's population to 100 million people by the year 2100. [1, 2, 3]

Agreed, I said before that immigration is a complex topic and I don’t fully understand it.

I just have concerns about how the liberal government has handled this very important aspect of governence. I think it’s very sloppy and they are doing a disservice to those coming into the country and those who already live here.

But that is just my opinion and honestly in democracies in North America and Europe, opinions of the people don’t go very far.
 
It’s the conservative government in Ontario too..

The exploitation tied to immigration and temporary students in the province of Ontario is wild. That is not the fault of those immigrating or getting educated……it’s a lack of structure from federal and provincial leadership IMO.
 
what part of "quietly sticking to his globalist agenda" is confusing you ?

by the time the electorate figures out Carney does not act in their best interest
1. he can report "Canada Century mission accomplished to the WEF" (100 million by the year 2100)
2. he will have become a Billionaire

the loonie left supporting a investment banker who will become obscenely rich by holding a public office
oh the irony
I am not a Carney fan but you need to also be realistic or else no one will take you seriously. His investment in Brookfield was estimated to be $6.2m when he became PM. It is now $6.8m. He has a long way to go to accomplish being a billionaire. If that is what he wants to do then doing it through Brookfield is a poor move 🤣
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
The Carney - Brookfield topic is another spicy meatball.

I view Carney as a long term thinker, so to me a $6.8m stake in that company doesn’t mean much. What I’m seeing is a prime minister with a country that has a lot of problem areas. Heading a political party that has been in charge for a decade, who got into office on the idea ‘I’m the one that will stand up to Trump and get results”

What I’m also seeing is someone who spends a huge amount of time in other countries making ‘understandings’ about trade, not formal trade agreements.

So if you’re good at planning for the future, and you have a large stake in a global infrastructure company (Brookfield). And you’re striking large trade agreements with global leaders who make the decisions on infrastructure spending……you’re playing the long game and letting the Canadian citizens to fend for themselves……perhaps.
 
Side note, we all fend for ourselves of course. I just feel Carney, similar to a lot of global leaders, make sure the the future is bright for themselves and I’m not seeing as much action within Canada as I would like.

But I’m only one vote
 
If temp workers come here and take up lower paying jobs that Canadians won't do - you have a problem with that.
If bright high skilled workers come here and are working on securing jobs - you have a problem with that.
You're right. A small (but not insignificant) minority do not like immigrants, no matter what. Especially when they are visibly different. Trudeau's surge gave them a cause to rally around. Had he not done so, they would still be on the fringes.
 
In 2025, 126,000 skilled Canadian tradespeople were left unemployed - while the federal government issued 125,000 Temporary Foreign Worker permits to migrants for skilled trades.


Don't let them lie to you that they can't find Canadian workers or Canadians don't want to work.

Canada will continue to struggle due to too many people refusing to clean house. They want bad policies so they can exploit it.
 
Southpaw, that quote in your signature line from ‘morningwoodglory22’…….what’s the context?
Someone was running for mayor of Mississauga. She criticized Israel.
 
In 2025, 126,000 skilled Canadian tradespeople were left unemployed - while the federal government issued 125,000 Temporary Foreign Worker permits to migrants for skilled trades.


Don't let them lie to you that they can't find Canadian workers or Canadians don't want to work.

Canada will continue to struggle due to too many people refusing to clean house. They want bad policies so they can exploit it.
What percentage of those Canadian tradespeople that were unemployed refused jobs resulting in vacancies filled by the TFW across Canada ? Why did these “ skilled” trades people refuse those jobs and who supported them during this unemployment phase ? I am sure that the percentage is quite significant. Again immigrants and TFW do job that Canadians either cannot or will not do, right across the spectrum from unskilled to skilled. And I appreciate that employer may pay TFWs less and there exists exploitation but still Canada needs immigration and TFWs . Without immigration the existing Canadian workforce, skilled and unskilled simply does not “ have the cards” to satisfy the requirements of many industries from coast to coast. And presently, there are more skilled trades people retiring than there are Canadians able and willing to replace them, so that immigration is the back stop.
Canada still suffers from a negative birth rate which is offset by immigration.
 
Without bringing in as many immigrants as Trudeau did we could
still “ have the cards” . People are questioning Liberals' immigration
policies not because they want no immigration.

Without immigration the existing Canadian workforce, skilled and unskilled simply does not “ have the cards” to satisfy the requirements of many industries from coast to coast.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DesRicardo
Without bringing in as many immigrants as Trudeau did we could
still “ have the cards” . People are questioning Liberals' immigration
policies not because they want no immigration.
Primarily, many people do not like to see so many people from the Indian subcontinent suddenly in Canada which is a good part of what the angst is about and is the elephant in the room. However Canada doesn’t have much choice at this stage and reality check or not, more Indians will necessarily be brought in.
If Indians decided not to come to Canada over the past 15 years then significant sectors of the Canadian economy would be fucked !