Mark Carney cranks up immigration again, while pretending not to.

Who said you can't? Liberals and their stupid parroting supporters? The paid for think-tanks?

Open your mind. You're telling me taxes pay for senior care, while I'm telling you we have a $60 billion dollar deficit on the federal level. That ship you're talking about has sunk.

We need to get back to balanced budgets.

Conservatives don't balance budgets either.
Have you checked Ford and Ontario's budget?
 
Who said you can't?
Arithmetic. A low birh rate implies relatively more seniors at the top, and relatively less young people at the bottom. Like an inverted pyramid. You can't sustain socialized healthcare with this.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
Arithmetic. A low birh rate implies relatively more seniors at the top, and relatively less young people at the bottom. Like an inverted pyramid. You can't sustain socialized healthcare with this.
Well lets talk arithmetic. It's already not sustainable.

I told you, You're telling me taxes pay for senior care, I'm telling you we have a $60 billion dollar deficit on the federal level.

Just throwing more people in the pot doesn't make it work.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
Just throwing more people in the pot doesn't make it work.
I agree. But this is the conventional wisdom. If you want to change it, prepare to make drastic cuts.

France has a similar problem. Big fat pensions that they can't sustain. Who do you think collects those pensions?
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
Immigration may be the solution, but mass immigration is not. It creates the culture war that you're referring to.

A slow and steady rate would not have created such a backlash. Gradual change gives people time to adapt. Rapid change shocks them.

Bernier talked about sustainable immigration...When pressed for a number he said about 250k...That sounds about right to me.
 
What gets lost in the immigration debates is that thousands of Canadians emigrate, so the number of immigrants coming in does not equal an increase in our population by that amount.

We need to address the brain drain of Canadians as well.
 
What gets lost in the immigration debates is that thousands of Canadians emigrate, so the number of immigrants coming in does not equal an increase in our population by that amount.

We need to address the brain drain of Canadians as well.
Whats the ratio of immigrants to emigrants?
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
I agree. But this is the conventional wisdom. If you want to change it, prepare to make drastic cuts.

France has a similar problem. Big fat pensions that they can't sustain. Who do you think collects those pensions?
I don't even agree with that. Cuts are needed, but I don't think they need to be drastic. It's bad budgeting to keep the current party in power.

12 years ago we could work down a budget. Only one thing in our way. Starts an L, end with a iberals.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
I don't support mass immigration, because of all the problems it causes. But you can't have both a negative birth rate and generous subsidies for seniors.

Our taxes don't go to seniors? Of course they do. Healthcare expenditure per capita is much higher for seniors versus young people.

those seniors have paid high taxes all their lives and cannot start over
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
Arithmetic. A low birh rate implies relatively more seniors at the top, and relatively less young people at the bottom. Like an inverted pyramid. You can't sustain socialized healthcare with this.

Canadas health care system was doomed the minute Justin Trudeau was elected
An aging population drives higher utilization rates
health care inflation runs @ 2X CPI
federal, Provincial and Municipal debt burdens are astronomical
the interest payments on the Federal debt will exceed the transfer payments to the provinces

of course the healthcare is unsustainable
The loonie left govts have spent/ borrowed all the money

And now they are going to borrow more for ... a sovereign wealth fund and a rail system in ont/ quebec, net zero insanity and to ensure Carney has enough caviar on his flights ????

Had there been responsible governance like in 2014 , the healthcare system might have been sustained for your generation.... too bad

dont get sick
 
Canadas health care system was doomed the minute Justin Trudeau was elected
An aging population drives higher utilization rates
health care inflation runs @ 2X CPI
federal, Provincial and Municipal debt burdens are astronomical
the interest payments on the Federal debt will exceed the transfer payments to the provinces

of course the healthcare is unsustainable
The loonie left govts have spent/ borrowed all the money

And now they are going to borrow more for ... a sovereign wealth fund and a rail system in ont/ quebec, net zero insanity and to ensure Carney has enough caviar on his flights ????

Had there been responsible governance like in 2014 , the healthcare system might have been sustained for your generation.... too bad

dont get sick

Health care is provincial.
 
So that’s a yes. Also I never asked you about Poilievre or what you consider yourself.

Seeing as no matter what I tell you, it will be pushed back I will say look at Carney’s history, investments, interests, appointees and his global alignments, I don’t see how it can be overlooked him being a crook.

Even on a policy and government level, he’s been crooked. Even in this thread he ran on the belief of lowered immigration and has now flipped.
I mentioned PP because the conservative party has given no viable alternative to Carney. As for his history, investments, and interests go I have yet to see where he's a crook, all I've seen is a highly intelligent man who has a great understanding of world finance and politics.
On a government level flipping on a policy doesn't make him a crook as there is no personal or financial gain.
 
I mentioned PP because the conservative party has given no viable alternative to Carney. As for his history, investments, and interests go I have yet to see where he's a crook, all I've seen is a highly intelligent man who has a great understanding of world finance and politics.
On a government level flipping on a policy doesn't make him a crook as there is no personal or financial gain.
Now you are just trolling.

His whole crowning achievement is The Brookfield Global Transition Fund. The term "hidden in plain sight" comes to mind.

Crooks are very intelligent people. They need to be to deceive everyone.
 
Health care is provincial, it wasn't the jurisdiction of Trudeau.
This is one of those things I hear parroted all the time when they constantly try to blame the Federal government for healthcare. It's your Premier's fault that they're not allocating the healthcare funding properly and actively cutting it on the Provincial side so that it ends up being worse... Doug Ford is doing the same thing here with our healthcare
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter