Mark Carney cranks up immigration again, while pretending not to.

Many Canadians are still holding on to this idea he is some type of economic wizard or business guru, even when it is obvious he is a crook with a foreign agenda.
Those are not mutually exclusive. His globalist agenda benefits big business. Depress wages and increase customers. Costs stay down, revenues go up.

GDP per capita may fall, but what do the corporations care, as long as their profits increase?
 
You're argument is this is risky to Canada, Their argument is how do my 20 cousins get to come hear and suck the country dry.
Perhaps, but hey are not the majority, and their 20 cousins aren't all here yet.

There's more going on. Canada has an aging population wirh socialized medicine and OAS. Combine that with low birth rates, below replacement level. The population would decline without immigration.

They need new taxpayers to pay for the older ones. I'm not pushing for this, I'm explaining it.
 
Check the research polls. Carney could mustard gas eastern Canada and still win the next election. Many Canadians are still holding on to this idea he is some type of economic wizard or business guru, even when it is obvious he is a crook with a foreign agenda.
Why are you saying it's obvious and why is he a crook
 
Perhaps, but hey are not the majority, and their 20 cousins aren't all here yet.

There's more going on. Canada has an aging population wirh socialized medicine and OAS. Combine that with low birth rates, below replacement level. The population would decline without immigration.

They need new taxpayers to pay for the older ones. I'm not pushing for this, I'm explaining it.
Here’s the thing, why do you guys approach population growth like a closing window?

Yes you’ve listed reasons why we need immigration but it doesn’t justify the number. Our taxes dollars don’t go to seniors, that ship has sunk my friend. it goes to debt payments.

Even after we’ve experience the after effects of high immigration, we walked right back into it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
More O&G customers.....???

Profits!!!!!

 
Serious question. If a majority of Canadians, including immigrants who arrived decades ago, want new immigration reduced, then why is Carney doing this? What does he gain by pissing off the electorate?
Because Carney knows wont lose support over it. Where will those voters go anyways? It's not like Pierre "I'm a simple goy from the prairies" Poilievre will do anything different. He along with Danielle Smith were begging for increases to immigration a few years ago.
 
Last edited:
Are you a Carney supporter? Yes or No.
Are you a Carney supporter? Yes or No.
I'm actually a conservative but I do like the direction Carney is taking the country. Also PP is a blustering idiot and I wouldn't vote for him if I was getting paid. I'd still like to see proof that Carney is a crook.
 
I'm actually a conservative but I do like the direction Carney is taking the country. Also PP is a blustering idiot and I wouldn't vote for him if I was getting paid. I'd still like to see proof that Carney is a crook.
So that’s a yes. Also I never asked you about Poilievre or what you consider yourself.

Seeing as no matter what I tell you, it will be pushed back I will say look at Carney’s history, investments, interests, appointees and his global alignments, I don’t see how it can be overlooked him being a crook.

Even on a policy and government level, he’s been crooked. Even in this thread he ran on the belief of lowered immigration and has now flipped.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
So there is no confusion or misinformation spread, this is what Trudeau last said:

The new plan will reduce the number of permanent residents arriving in Canada from 500,000 to 395,000 in 2025 and 500,000 to 380,000 in 2026. The government has set a target of 365,000 permanent residents for 2027. The prime minister faces questions from reporters on the reported discord within the Liberal party following yesterday’s caucus meeting. (no interpretation) (no interpretation)

 
  • Like
Reactions: Orcas
Per the article it is 662K immigrants.
Trudeau's was 1M+.
662K < 1M+.
That is lowered immigration
There was no flipping. It's basic math.


unbelievable
your standard is Trudeau ????


look
Trudeau intentionally let immigration run wild driving a housing crisis, overwhelming health care and infrastructure
unintended consequences for Justin, but then he is a moron who never thought about the aftermath of his actions

the analogy is ballooning up to 400 lbs in weight and reducing that to 350 lbs and saying all is good, when your heart needs you to be @ 170 lbs

after creating problems in housing, health care and infrastructure, immigration should be well below 2014 levels
in 2014, Canada welcomed 260,411 new permanent residents
address the capacity issues in housing, health care and infrastructure and then revisit higher immigration
and invite only those who will be a net benefit to Canada via skills / investment/ job creation

we do not need more new Canadians qualified for only Tim Hortons - Justin delivered an excess of those
 
unbelievable
your standard is Trudeau ????
Yes, he was the previous prime minister.
And don't forget the two most important points here:
a) The 200K additional Permanent Residents DesRicardo is whining about are current residents of Canada already, so even though you could count them in the PR group, they aren't new arrivals and aren't increasing headcount.
b) You should stop talking about what immigration numbers should be, or about any topic in general, because you don't know anything about anything.
 
Combine that with low birth rates, below replacement level. The population would decline without immigration.
I also want to add that the government lied to you about population decline.

Canada's population saw a slight bump in 2025, Statistics Canada says, revising a previous estimate that showed the population decreased for the first time in the country's history.

The statistics agency released new numbers last week that suggest the population grew slightly, by 280,810 people, in all of 2025.

The new estimate is a revision from data released in March that indicated the country had seen an annual net decline in residents for the first time since Confederation.


The truth is they have no clue what's going on, nor do they have any answers. They don't even know who's here and who isn't.

Which leads to another major concern, the government doesn't have the throughput for high-levels of immigration. The Immigration department has been horribly run for years and continues to not demonstrated they can manage these numbers.

We are literally making the same mistakes over again.
 
Yes you’ve listed reasons why we need immigration but it doesn’t justify the number. Our taxes dollars don’t go to seniors, that ship has sunk my friend. it goes to debt payments.
I don't support mass immigration, because of all the problems it causes. But you can't have both a negative birth rate and generous subsidies for seniors.

Our taxes don't go to seniors? Of course they do. Healthcare expenditure per capita is much higher for seniors versus young people.
 
Why wouldn't you push for it if you are able to explain it? It is the solution after all.
Regardless, that is why we have immigration and the backlash as I said before in a since deleted thread, is culture war.
Immigration may be the solution, but mass immigration is not. It creates the culture war that you're referring to.

A slow and steady rate would not have created such a backlash. Gradual change gives people time to adapt. Rapid change shocks them.

Now that Trudeau has already shocked them, it's time.to give them a breather. Not shock them again.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MaverickPunter
I don't support mass immigration, because of all the problems it causes. But you can't have both a negative birth rate and generous subsidies for seniors.

Our taxes don't go to seniors? Of course they do. Healthcare expenditure per capita is much higher for seniors versus young people.
Who said you can't? Liberals and their stupid parroting supporters? The paid for think-tanks?

Open your mind. You're telling me taxes pay for senior care, while I'm telling you we have a $60 billion dollar deficit on the federal level. That ship you're talking about has sunk.

We need to get back to balanced budgets.
 
Last edited: