Discussion: Is the Housing & Rental Bubble Finally Losing Air?

Endurance2024

Well-known member
Oct 23, 2024
563
1,052
93
I've been noticing a few things lately that have me wondering if we're finally seeing supply and demand start to work in buyers' and renters' favour.

Observation #1 – Local housing prices
A house in my neighbourhood caught my attention about six years ago. During the pandemic frenzy it sold for $865,000 in a bidding war with multiple offers and no conditions.
It recently sold again for $735,000, this time with financing and home inspection conditions.
That's a pretty significant change. Obviously it's only one example, but it suggests demand isn't what it was during the COVID buying frenzy. Higher interest rates and the Canada-U.S. trade uncertainty may also be playing a role.

Observation #2 – Hotel prices
On a recent trip I paid around $300-$330/night for hotels in smaller East Coast communities.
Back home in Mississauga/Toronto West, similar hotel rooms can often be found for around $180/night.
My guess is that the smaller markets have limited room supply during tourist season, while the GTA has far more competition among hotels.
Again... supply and demand.

Observation #3 – New condo construction
There are cranes everywhere in my area. Thousands of condo units are either under construction or nearing completion.
If those units actually reach the market, housing supply should gradually improve.

Observation #4 – Population growth
Immigration and international student growth has slowed compared with the last few years. If population growth eases while housing supply increases, that should reduce some of the pressure on both home prices and rents.

My conclusion

Housing is still expensive, and rents are still painfully high.

But I'm starting to wonder if the market has already peaked and we're now entering a period where prices either continue drifting lower or move sideways while wages gradually catch up.

To me, the basic economics of supply and demand seem to be reasserting themselves.

What do you think?
  • Are we watching the housing bubble slowly deflate?
  • Will prices continue to fall?
  • Or are we simply entering a long period of flat prices before the next run-up?
Interested to hear opinions, especially from anyone working in real estate, construction, banking, or property management.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xix
I've been noticing a few things lately that have me wondering if we're finally seeing supply and demand start to work in buyers' and renters' favour.

Observation #1 – Local housing prices
A house in my neighbourhood caught my attention about six years ago. During the pandemic frenzy it sold for $865,000 in a bidding war with multiple offers and no conditions.
It recently sold again for $735,000, this time with financing and home inspection conditions.
That's a pretty significant change. Obviously it's only one example, but it suggests demand isn't what it was during the COVID buying frenzy. Higher interest rates and the Canada-U.S. trade uncertainty may also be playing a role.

Observation #2 – Hotel prices
On a recent trip I paid around $300-$330/night for hotels in smaller East Coast communities.
Back home in Mississauga/Toronto West, similar hotel rooms can often be found for around $180/night.
My guess is that the smaller markets have limited room supply during tourist season, while the GTA has far more competition among hotels.
Again... supply and demand.

Observation #3 – New condo construction
There are cranes everywhere in my area. Thousands of condo units are either under construction or nearing completion.
If those units actually reach the market, housing supply should gradually improve.

Observation #4 – Population growth
Immigration and international student growth has slowed compared with the last few years. If population growth eases while housing supply increases, that should reduce some of the pressure on both home prices and rents.

My conclusion

Housing is still expensive, and rents are still painfully high.

But I'm starting to wonder if the market has already peaked and we're now entering a period where prices either continue drifting lower or move sideways while wages gradually catch up.

To me, the basic economics of supply and demand seem to be reasserting themselves.

What do you think?
  • Are we watching the housing bubble slowly deflate?
  • Will prices continue to fall?
  • Or are we simply entering a long period of flat prices before the next run-up?
Interested to hear opinions, especially from anyone working in real estate, construction, banking, or property management.
Difficult to see a huge correction in houses in Toronto with the greenbelt/NIMBY thing.
Condos may continue to go down. But who knows?
 
I don't work in any of these industries, but closely follow Ron Butler from Angry Mortgage and John Pasalis from Move Smartly on YouTube.

Both of them more or less agree with the idea that there is some movement down still to come, with the warning of course that calling exact market tops and bottoms is only "reserved" for those selling real estate :)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Endurance2024
I feel like this was the case 3-4 years ago. The housing market hit a huge wall in 2022 in many areas. Inflation coming out of COVID stimulus and economic uncertainty with the Russia-Ukraine War. We were steadily moving towards getting ready to sell our house and seeing the market in early 2022 when houses were selling in a day with multiple offers, I was tempted to just throw up a FSBO sign and do no advance prep to the house just to see what would happen. My wife wasn't ready to go yet though. So we waited a few months and gradually cleaned out our stuff and did some fixing up, painted some rooms, got the grass looking good, got the house all nicely staged. Put it on the market in fall of 2022 and it languished. Our agent said if we had listed in Jan 22 we could have expected multiple offers and probably sold for a million or a bit more (this was in the Byron neighbourhood of London for anyone familiar). We ended up trying to capitalize on any market life by listing at 850k, then dropped it to 800k a few weeks later when we had barely any sniffs. Sat on it through Christmas. Had someone come through and they offered 700k, went back and forth and finally settled at 760k. We had found a house that had been on the market for a bit and put a conditional full price offer on it. Fortunately they had recently done another of a few price drops before we saw it. They accepted and we had 90 days. Our 90 expired as ours hadn't sold by that point. When ours finally sold we went back to the house we had offered on but we also had found another one that wasn't quite what we wanted but it was suitable. We played a bit of hardball with the first house and put in a lower offer, saying the market had dropped in the almost 4 months since we originally put the offer in. The agent was pissed, we didn't care, take it or we are putting in a firm offer on house B. We said "You had 90 days with our conditional offer to force our hand and another almost month since that offer expired and you still haven't had any serious interest, so here we are and we are willing to pay this price" which was about 30k less than our conditional offer. We got the house.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Endurance2024
It's been losing air, but it's kind of artificial. House pricing is only one part of the equation.

I was looking at new build semi-detached that would normally go for $1.1 million but are now in the $850K to $950K range. The government also removes the sales tax and the agent said they could work with the developer to possibly get a better price. That's pretty ok for this era of home buying, but the financing is a killer. You'll still need $100K down and like $3K monthly.

I personally don't believe there will be much more big dips, but it's as much political as it is economical. So who really knows?
 
Last edited:
I do think it's losing a little air but not enough like these people claiming it's going to burst soon, it's going to be a long slow gradual decline and probably never be as low as it should be
 
It's been losing air, but it's kind of artificial. House pricing is only one part of the equation.

I was looking at new build semi-detached that would normally go for $1.1 million but are now in the mid $850K to mid $950K. The government also removes the sales tax and the agent said they could work with the developer to possibly get a better price. That's pretty ok for this era of home buying, but the financing is a killer. You'll still need $100K down and like $3K monthly.

I personally don't believe there will be much more big dips, but it's as much political as it is economical. So who really knows?
I see 3 items here in you observations.

1.1 million to 900k drop in price that's 18%

Government removes the GST on new build 5% on 900k is 45k now final price is 855k

You may negotiate further discount with the builder but there is an artificial reduction with the GST is helping ease the price already. Which both the builder and the buyer is happy with and it happened already without negotiating. But yes if there aren't many buyers lined up then there may be incentive for the buyer to get your purchase.

Prices are still high with 100k down and 3k per month as you mentioned. Again reducing the buyer pool to a lower number. Your not alone in this thinking.

During the frenzy in the pandemic buyers were in a panic and put bids in at the max they could afford and all while at stupidly low interest rates. And very discouraged when their bid lost again. Prices on houses went up in my neighborhood not quite double, I'd say 80% from 2018 to 2022. That was crazy.

This is very different now. There is no frenzy. Interest rates are higher. Some are selling 5 years later cause the new monthly payment is not manageable. And they have to sell at a loss. These will be the first ones to exit. The next ones will be those who get layed off and maybe out of work for a few months.
Then there is the usual partner falling outs that always happen.

There will be the ones that hang in there and are able to renew their mortgages and some how find a way to make this payments.

But we could see further price drops likely gradual over time. My prediction another 28% from here if the current climate stays the same. Why? Because of the crazy 4 years incredibly inflated the housing prices.
Watch out if this CUSMA unravels and or Trump carries on with his agendas. Or if the wars/conflicts spreads even more.

Another observation. The housing bubble of 1989 is different than today you will hear from a lot of smart people. It did happen. The average house price in Toronto increased 150% over a 4 year period and declined in price for 7 years losing back an average of 30% Higher drops elsewhere across Canada. Not only that but it took another 6.5 years for the housing prices to recover to the point the those who bought at the peak are breaking even. That was 13.5 years. So are we facing another 3 years of decline and another 6 years of getting back to the peak? I think it's a buyer's market for quite a while now.

And as you mentioned. The average buyer still can't afford the downpayment and monthly at these current prices.
 
  • Like
Reactions: OntGuy2010
If you were on a variable rate .. Did anyone lock in to a fixed rate this time around. Bank of Canada Rate went up .25 with possible increases next quarter.
 
Housing prices have always been a rollercoaster pricing issue for years, some worse than others. Most recently when prices and interest rates were lower, there was a rush to buy, often larger homes that were beyond the usual person's affordability. And within this buying bubble prices surged for years until prices were beyond the true value of homes. Then add in Covid the Russian/Ukraine war and the inflation all of this caused and then the housing market "dies".

And with the spike in interest rates some of those larger homes bought by people who shouldn't have purchased them, they defaulted on their payments, were repossessed or sold for a fraction of their buying price to pay off their debt. Economically, once things in the world settled down and many things became "more normal", the housing prices started to normalize, often reducing from their overinflated prices to what's considered more normal even if still overpriced for most people including first time home buyers.

Condos seem to be the unknown IMO. Many are available but few seem to be buying them probably because of their cost but usually because of the outrageous monthly condo fees that are as bad or worse than some mortgage payments. As for renters, that too is improving but how much to make it affordable for the average person with rents roughly about 2k or more per month. And who can afford that unless you live with 2 or 3 people to reduce everyone's cost, IF possible.

Will things improve? Hopefully yes, as long as prices fall into a range affordable for many. And that part is the unknown particularly regarding interest rates. IMO although things are (very) slowly improving it's unlikely to improve to the way it used to be, even though that would be best compared to the way it is now.

LTO_3
 
  • Like
Reactions: Endurance2024
housing prices falling this much, is enough for govt intervention. We could see immigration and student visas going back up to bolster the economy, it would be a tough sell with the unemployment rate right now but there's gonna be a lot of pressure from industries like real estate and even banks with mortgages that are gonna be renewed with much lower home values relative to covid peaks. Seems to happen a lot, people around here have so much tied up in their house equity, they won't be happy with carny if the prices drop.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Endurance2024
housing prices falling this much, is enough for govt intervention. We could see immigration and student visas going back up to bolster the economy, it would be a tough sell with the unemployment rate right now but there's gonna be a lot of pressure from industries like real estate and even banks with mortgages that are gonna be renewed with much lower home values relative to covid peaks. Seems to happen a lot, people around here have so much tied up in their house equity, they won't be happy with carny if the prices drop.
Well I lived through the 1990's with a house with a market value 30% below my purchase price. Any equity we had in it was erased and if we were forced to sell at our renewal date we would have owed the bank after we sold. Fortunately we didn't have to requalify for the renewal and as long as we didn't have any late or missing mortgage payments there wasn't an issue with the renewal. I later learned that it could have been a policy back then by the banks as there were plenty of people in the same situation as us and it may have been bad for the banks bottom line to take on all those peroanl bankrupcies caused by rejecting renewals based on the mortgage value exceding the current market value of the property.

But it took 10 to 12 years before the housing market recovered to the point of our original purchase amount. We were pretty much forced to stay put. Not a problem as it was a home for us and we slowly paid the mortgage down which allowed us leverage the equity built over time.

I would not agree with going back to the policy allowing over imigration and student visa's. Moderation is best and I can't believe they let it get out of hand like it did, causing a short squeeze on not only housing but everything else including healthcare.
 
Housing prices have always been a rollercoaster pricing issue for years, some worse than others. Most recently when prices and interest rates were lower, there was a rush to buy, often larger homes that were beyond the usual person's affordability. And within this buying bubble prices surged for years until prices were beyond the true value of homes. Then add in Covid the Russian/Ukraine war and the inflation all of this caused and then the housing market "dies".

And with the spike in interest rates some of those larger homes bought by people who shouldn't have purchased them, they defaulted on their payments, were repossessed or sold for a fraction of their buying price to pay off their debt. Economically, once things in the world settled down and many things became "more normal", the housing prices started to normalize, often reducing from their overinflated prices to what's considered more normal even if still overpriced for most people including first time home buyers.

Condos seem to be the unknown IMO. Many are available but few seem to be buying them probably because of their cost but usually because of the outrageous monthly condo fees that are as bad or worse than some mortgage payments. As for renters, that too is improving but how much to make it affordable for the average person with rents roughly about 2k or more per month. And who can afford that unless you live with 2 or 3 people to reduce everyone's cost, IF possible.

Will things improve? Hopefully yes, as long as prices fall into a range affordable for many. And that part is the unknown particularly regarding interest rates. IMO although things are (very) slowly improving it's unlikely to improve to the way it used to be, even though that would be best compared to the way it is now.

LTO_3
Seeing how the housing prices sky rocketed 2021-23 I truely thought the housing prices would come down with most people unable to work. But for various reasons as we found out the opposite happened. Fueled by a variable mortgage rate of 1% and over imigration spiking the demand. No one seem to care about how much it cost and everyone seem to focus on the monthly payment. How much could they afford monthly and what ever that translated into a purchase price well that was acceptable. Another thing is 4% mortgage rates is still historically low. Don't be fooled into thinking it can't go higher. The only tool in the box the Bank of Canada has that is most effective to control inflation is higher interest rates.And back through the 80's and 90's the Bank of Canada didn't seem to care about home owners being able to afford 13% - 18%. It certainly wiped out the speculators looking to flip for a profit. And I would think there were plenty this time around who got burnt buying a condo or two from plans for a quick buck.
 
If you were on a variable rate .. Did anyone lock in to a fixed rate this time around. Bank of Canada Rate went up .25 with possible increases next quarter.

We've been on a variable rate (prime minus 1) since I think 2018. We stayed on the variable in 2023 when we renewed but we also had bought a new house with a few months left in that 2018 mortgage. It was a downsize so we were on a good spot and our mortgage was also fairly low after 14 years of being in a house we bought for under 3 and sold for over 7. Did have the thought at the bottom rate in covid times of locking it in, but I doubt it would have made any difference in our overall picture at the point either. I mean, obviously if we had timed it right at the last week of the lowest rate and locked in at whatever the rate was we would have been able to lock in, we probably would have saved a little bit but you just never know what will happen the next week or few months later. If rates had come back down, I would have been pissed off. Doesn't matter though, our final payment is Dec 31 unless I decide to pay it off sooner. Although there isn't any reason other than psychological to pay it off now rather than 8 weeks from now. Once we got settled into this house and did the reno work we wanted to do, we put a large lump sum down on the mortgage and started doubling up our weekly payment which will have knocked off about 4 years. Could have done better by investing that money but the feeling of getting mortgage free was a stronger draw to me.