Leafs 2026-2027 Season

With all the criticism Treliving has received I thought I'd throw him a few crumbs for a good move.

His best move was signing Knies with no no move clause.
His worse move was trading Knies to Montreal but the hockey gods stopped him.
 
His best move was signing Knies with no no move clause.
His worse move was trading Knies to Montreal but the hockey gods stopped him.
Worse than the Boston and Philadelphia trades???
P.S. When Knies makes his return appearence in Toronto I hope he gets a 10 minute standing ovation. A great kid who will be missed.
 
Worse than the Boston and Philadelphia trades???
P.S. When Knies makes his return appearence in Toronto I hope he gets a 10 minute standing ovation. A great kid who will be missed.

It's Montreal.
Leafs once traded Russ Courtnall to Montreal for John Kordic.
That's like trading Willy Nylander for Xhekaj. I'm sure half of Leaf Nation would love that.

Knies was practically in tears talking about his days with the Leafs being too short.
An American who didn't want to be traded out of a Canadian team.
Knies is 24. Cowan is 21 and quite frankly I think he could be better than Knies.
 
Last edited:
Worse than the Boston and Philadelphia trades???
P.S. When Knies makes his return appearence in Toronto I hope he gets a 10 minute standing ovation. A great kid who will be missed.
[/QUOTE]

Undoubtedly the Carlo for Minten trade was the worse trade in recent Leafs history. Minten has turned out to be the second line centre that the Leafs so desperately need now. Carlo is 6'5" but plays like 5'6" . As things turned out though, if we had Minten last season we most likely would have won at least a couple more games and that would impact the lottery odds dramatically. So if we fans look at the trade as Minten for McKenna, I think most of us would take it.
 
Worse than the Boston and Philadelphia trades???
P.S. When Knies makes his return appearence in Toronto I hope he gets a 10 minute standing ovation. A great kid who will be missed.

Undoubtedly the Carlo for Minten trade was the worse trade in recent Leafs history. Minten has turned out to be the second line centre that the Leafs so desperately need now. Carlo is 6'5" but plays like 5'6" . As things turned out though, if we had Minten last season we most likely would have won at least a couple more games and that would impact the lottery odds dramatically. So if we fans look at the trade as Minten for McKenna, I think most of us would take it.
[/QUOTE]
Through all that you didn't even mention the first round pick Boston gets, yet it still reads as a horrible trade.
 
  • Like
Reactions: smuddan2
Rielly has only played for one team his whole career. What does that say about him.
Unlike that piece of crap Roslovic who has played for a whopping 6 teams.
It's truly amazing how little thought you put into your arguments. Reilly was a really good player when Dubas gave him his contract. It has NMC and a salary no team now till touch which is why he is still a TML. So ya in hindsight now it doesn't look too good but that was the going rate for a player like him at the time and he wasn't a crap player when he got it. Roslovic has never been more than a 40 point player with speed who is also a defensive liability. He has not proven anything to warrant getting a big deal so far in his career which is why no team has kept him around for a long period of time. You also forget he's a bit of a malcontent in the dressing room. So far he's been pretty good. Same with Maccelli. Doesn't mean the Leafs should've signed him last season. And what if they did and got a few extra wins and their draft pick is outside of the top 5. Then they would've had to forfeit it to the Bruins.
 
  • Like
Reactions: titanium666
It's truly amazing how little thought you put into your arguments. Reilly was a really good player when Dubas gave him his contract. It has NMC and a salary no team now till touch which is why he is still a TML. So ya in hindsight now it doesn't look too good but that was the going rate for a player like him at the time and he wasn't a crap player when he got it. Roslovic has never been more than a 40 point player with speed who is also a defensive liability. He has not proven anything to warrant getting a big deal so far in his career which is why no team has kept him around for a long period of time. You also forget he's a bit of a malcontent in the dressing room. So far he's been pretty good. Same with Maccelli. Doesn't mean the Leafs should've signed him last season. And what if they did and got a few extra wins and their draft pick is outside of the top 5. Then they would've had to forfeit it to the Bruins.

Rielly must clearly be a superstar since he hasn't played for 6 different teams.
 
Undoubtedly the Carlo for Minten trade was the worse trade in recent Leafs history. Minten has turned out to be the second line centre that the Leafs so desperately need now. Carlo is 6'5" but plays like 5'6" . As things turned out though, if we had Minten last season we most likely would have won at least a couple more games and that would impact the lottery odds dramatically. So if we fans look at the trade as Minten for McKenna, I think most of us would take it.

I was being faceitous. Clearly Carlo trade was stupendouly bad. It was so obvious I didn't think needed explaining.
It was more Shanahan than Treliving. Shanahan had an expiring contract. It was do or die. He sold the future for that one last kick at the can. It was his Shanaplan after all. He hired Treliving for a reason.

Shanahan hired Dubas for his analytics then threw it out the window with Treliving when he got desperate.
No other GM was giving out only top 5 protected and no other GM will give out only top 5 protected ever again.

Plus, no one really knows what the return was for Knies from Montreal so how can one compare.
 
Last edited:
Rielly must clearly be a superstar since he hasn't played for 6 different teams.
Compare to Roslovic he is. What are you trying to prove. You have no clue what you're rambling about. You have this hard on for a player that hasn't proven anything in his 9 year career yet that no other team wants. Reilly has had many good seasons before his skills went to shit. And I already told you why he's still with the team. Read and think before you reply. You're a typical after the fact homer fan like the folks on the Leafs reddit page.
 
Leafs catch a break as Ekholm and Levi are injured. It's a matter of what Leafs will do with this.
 
Leafs catch a break as Ekholm and Levi are injured. It's a matter of what Leafs will do with this.


The Leafs had the Islanders down to 2 forwards; we know how that went.
 
Best game for McCabe going back almost two years. Very structured defensive game and a full team effort. Can't remember the last time we had a more effective 4th line.
 
Cowen blows the zone when Leafs gain possession ... twice and not a peep from the half of Leaf Nation that craps on Nylander for doing precisely that.
Edmonton has a one line team and one superstar offensive defenseman. Not much happens with their other lines but it's worked for them until this game with the Leafs.
It's clear Berube really screwed up Rielly. Under Hiller he's back to playing like the former Rielly. Less time in the defensive zone. Haven't noticed any gaffes the last 4 games. He's looking like a legit hockey player again.
 
Last edited:
Leafs need to rake in points from Calgary, Vancouver, and Seattle. The Atlantic is tight; no room to leave points.
 
Any coincidence the Leafs have been playing great since Tavares has been out of the lineup?