Oct 7th was legal under International Law

Such NONSENSE AND BULLSHIT spouted by Mearsheimer and posted by Comrade Notti.


V. Legal Analysis
  1. In relation to the Commission’s investigation into the attack of 7 October in Israel, the Commission found that members of Hamas military wing, members of the military wings of other Palestinian armed groups and Palestinian civilians committed war crimes, as well as violations and abuses of IHL and IHRL.
  2. The Commission found that the war crimes of intentionally directing attacks against civilians and murder or wilful killing were committed by shooting and killing residents of kibbutzim and other civilian locations, including women, children and older persons, and by indiscriminately firing projectiles towards populated areas in Israel. The Commission also found that the war crimes of torture, inhuman or cruel treatment and of destroying or seizing the property of an adversary were committed.
  3. The Commission found that the war crime of cruel treatment was committed in several locations, as well as the war crime of inhumane treatment and torture. The Commission found that the war crime of outrages upon personal dignity was committed in the desecration of corpses by burning, mutilation and decapitation. The Commission also found the sexualized desecration of both male and female corpses, including the exhibition of undressed bodies.
  4. The Commission found that the war crime of taking hostages was committed, in most cases together with outrages on personal dignity and inhumane treatment, including SGBV, such as assault, harassment and intimidation against women while abducted in Israel and taken to Gaza.
  5. The Commission found that acts of sexual violence were committed on 7 October in Israel, including at the Nova festival, on road 232, at Nahal Oz military base and kibbutzim Re’im, Nir Oz and Kfar Aza.
  6. The Commission found that members of the military wings of Hamas and PIJ violated the principle of distinction when they attacked, killed and injured the civilian population and intentionally launched rockets and mortars from Gaza into Israel.
  7. The Commission found that ISF soldiers violated the principles of distinction, precaution and proportionality when they fired shells at a house occupied by Israeli civilian hostages in Be’eri and directed helicopter fire at a civilian hostage from Nir Oz.
  8. In relation to the Commission’s investigation into Israel’s attacks and operations in Gaza and OPT, the Commission found that Israeli authorities and members of the ISF committed war crimes, crimes against humanity, and violations of IHL and IHRL.
  9. The Commission found that the war crimes of starvation as a method of warfare; murder or wilful killing; intentionally directing attacks against civilians and civilian objects; forcible transfer; sexual violence; outrages upon personal dignity; and SGBV amounting to torture or inhuman and cruel treatment were committed.
  10. The Commission found that through several actions including siege, Israel inflicted collective punishment on the Palestinian population in Gaza, in direct violation of IHL.
  11. The Commission found it foreseeable that civilians would be present in the areas targeted by the ISF; nonetheless, the ISF intentionally proceeded to direct its attacks against the civilian population and civilian objects, including places of worship, with such knowledge, in direct violation of the IHL principles of adequate precautions, distinction, proportionality, and special protections for children and women.
  12. The Commission found that the chapeau elements of crimes against humanity have been fulfilled, namely a widespread or systematic attack directed against the civilian population in Gaza. The Commission found that the crimes against humanity of extermination; murder; gender persecution targeting Palestinian men and boys; forcible transfer; and torture and inhuman and cruel treatment were committed.
  13. The Commission found that the siege and forcible transfer, compounded with widespread destruction caused by attacks and military operations, resulted in the IHRL violations of the rights to family life, adequate food, housing, education, health, social security, and water and sanitation, particularly impacting children and persons in vulnerable situations. The age and gender specific harms resulted in violations of the CRC and rights to non-discrimination in the CEDAW.
VI. Conclusions
 
They do have the right to defend themself, BUT they started the fight.

Once again who was the "aggressor" that started this all? Arabs and more. So Israel defended themself.

Israel can proclaim what they want. Hell, they can go on TV and say they own Canada. But if Canada physically attacks then Canada is the "aggressor".

Yeah, I agree with your aggressor analogy. It's kind of like what Russia did to Ukraine eh?? Hmmmm..... 🤔
 
Such NONSENSE AND BULLSHIT spouted by Mearsheimer and posted by Comrade Notti.


V. Legal Analysis

  1. The Commission found that ISF soldiers violated the principles of distinction, precaution and proportionality when they fired shells at a house occupied by Israeli civilian hostages in Be’eri and directed helicopter fire at a civilian hostage from Nir Oz.
  2. In relation to the Commission’s investigation into Israel’s attacks and operations in Gaza and OPT, the Commission found that Israeli authorities and members of the ISF committed war crimes, crimes against humanity, and violations of IHL and IHRL.
  3. The Commission found that the war crimes of starvation as a method of warfare; murder or wilful killing; intentionally directing attacks against civilians and civilian objects; forcible transfer; sexual violence; outrages upon personal dignity; and SGBV amounting to torture or inhuman and cruel treatment were committed.
  4. The Commission found that through several actions including siege, Israel inflicted collective punishment on the Palestinian population in Gaza, in direct violation of IHL.
  5. The Commission found it foreseeable that civilians would be present in the areas targeted by the ISF; nonetheless, the ISF intentionally proceeded to direct its attacks against the civilian population and civilian objects, including places of worship, with such knowledge, in direct violation of the IHL principles of adequate precautions, distinction, proportionality, and special protections for children and women.
  6. The Commission found that the chapeau elements of crimes against humanity have been fulfilled, namely a widespread or systematic attack directed against the civilian population in Gaza. The Commission found that the crimes against humanity of extermination; murder; gender persecution targeting Palestinian men and boys; forcible transfer; and torture and inhuman and cruel treatment were committed.
  7. The Commission found that the siege and forcible transfer, compounded with widespread destruction caused by attacks and military operations, resulted in the IHRL violations of the rights to family life, adequate food, housing, education, health, social security, and water and sanitation, particularly impacting children and persons in vulnerable situations. The age and gender specific harms resulted in violations of the CRC and rights to non-discrimination in the CEDAW.
VI. Conclusions

Thanks for posting a link that also lists some of the Israeli war crimes, showing that you accept and back war crimes committed by Jewish people but think when Muslims do similar war crimes they deserve genocide. That list says both sides committed war crimes, but you think only Palestinian ones count.

What your report doesn't note is that Palestinians have the legal right to use violent resistance against the illegal occupation of Palestine.
The UN just accused Hamas of targeting civilians and taking hostages, crimes which you fully support when Jewish people do it to Palestinians.

And now that you back the UN reports you have no excuse not to read this one and explain why still back genocide, other than declaring it was because Hamas didn't wear uniforms.

 
Thanks for posting a link that also lists some of the Israeli war crimes, showing that you accept and back war crimes committed by Jewish people but think when Muslims do similar war crimes they deserve . That list says both sides committed war crimes, but you think only Palestinian ones count.

What your report doesn't note is that Palestinians have the legal right to use violent resistance against the illegal occupation of Palestine.
The UN just accused Hamas of targeting civilians and taking hostages, crimes which you fully support when Jewish people do it to Palestinians.

And now that you back the UN reports you have no excuse not to read this one and explain why, other than declaring it was because Hamas didn't wear uniforms.

You must be great at playing Twister.

Fighting in civilian clothes to throw off the enemy and causing the death of civilians is illegal.
 
Last edited:
I've read all 3 holy books. Bible, Quran and Torah. All 3 holy books says Jews = Israel and were there centuries ago too.

Palestinians just got upset after 1947 because the Jews finally fulfilled the prophecy.

If Palestinians were nice they'd sit back and have a beer and cheer. But noooooooooooo.

What?

You are a religious wacko who takes those books literally?
Not surprising.
 
The wrath of God is not pleased Franky!!!

Your sins are making the Torah, the Quran and the Bible cry.

The Real Ezekiel 25:17 (King James Version): "And I will execute great vengeance upon them with furious rebukes; and they shall know that I am the Lord, when I shall lay my vengeance upon them."

Frank...even God clapping you up now...:eek:

Let me know when to expect the lightning strike.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Klatuu
Notti needs to realize what's happening between Israel and Palestine isn't considered Holocaust 2.0. Genocide, yes.

Genocide no...Pretendocide yes...

Now write this out 100 times on the chalkboard before leaving class.
 
The occupation of Palestine is illegal.
Apartheid is illegal.
Genocide is illegal.

There is no Palestine...There is no apartheid....There is no Genocide.

Still hitless this season and far below the Mendoza line.

I see AAA your near future.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: MaverickPunter