Why is Ireland one of the most antisemitic countries in Europe?

Yellowhornet

Member
Sep 30, 2026
59
25
8
There was always a divide in Catholic Ireland between the county priests, endemically antisemitic, and the urban academic Catholics, who were in the past much more understanding and sympathetic

by Jeremy Rosen
Opinion

Demonstrators hold Israeli and British flags outside the Law Courts, during a march against antisemitism, after an increase in the UK, during a temporary truce between the Palestinian Islamist terrorists Hamas and Israel, in London, Britain November 26, 2023. Photos: REUTERS/Susannah Ireland
Why is Ireland one of the most antisemitic countries in Europe?
The answer lies in its history. In Ulysses, by James Joyce, the antisemitic character Deasy says that the reason there was no antisemitism in Ireland was because they never let the Jews in, in the first place.
That’s not true of course, because there were significant Jewish communities both in Dublin and Cork. Indeed, my paternal grandparents were buried in Dublin. And in Ulysses itself, Joyce, who understood the Jewish problem in Europe, constantly makes references to Jewish and Zionist themes. There was always a divide in Catholic Ireland between the county priests, endemically antisemitic, and the urban academic Catholics, who were in the past much more understanding and sympathetic. But Irish history is a complex and controversial one.
“The Irish problem” was a subject that I was taught at school as part of the British history curriculum. It started when William the Conqueror came over from France and moved into Ireland, which up to that point had been a purely Gaelic country and culture.
The Irish fought back, but in 1650, Oliver Cromwell brutally suppressed the Gaelic resistance and sent in English settlers to keep the country controlled. English suppression only made matters worse. The Irish kept on fighting the English. And to this day the battle of the Boyne in 1690 is still either celebrated or mourned as the victory of the Protestant King William over the Catholic James.
The great potato famine of 1845, exacerbated by English neglect, caused the deaths of a million, and the emigration of a million more. The battle for Irish home rule dominated parliamentary life throughout the 19th century. The Irish Parliamentary Party tried to solve the Irish problem through negotiation, but failed. Resistance in Ireland grew, spearheaded by the Irish Republican Army and its socialist political party the Sinn Fein.
The British Parliament conceded the right of Ireland to have home rule in 1914, although this still meant it would be under the control of Britain, which was unacceptable to the Republican opposition. Famous Irish poet (and politician) W.B. Yeats wrote his Easter 1916 poem to commemorate the Easter Rising, when the center of Dublin was occupied by several hundred Republicans. After five days they were brutally overcome by British forces and 16 of the leaders were court-martialed and executed. The harsh British reaction helped to win wider support for independence.
During the First World War, many in Ireland supported Germany and refused to serve in the British Army. Ireland was divided not just between Catholics and Protestants, but between those Irishmen who were willing to accept home rule under British authority and those who opposed it and opposed it violently.


Hatred of England was such that in the Second World War, Ireland refused to join the fight against the Nazis. In the North, the battle between Catholics (led by the Provisional IRA) and Protestants continued violently on both sides of the Irish Sea until John Major signed a peace treaty within Northern Ireland in 1994. Meanwhile, the political divisions in Ireland continued between the IRA’s political wing, Fianna Fail, and Fianna Gael, the more right-wing until relatively recently.

The impossibility of finding a peaceful solution to the division of Ireland still challenges. And the Catholics still dream of getting it all back. No comparisons are ever absolute. And as long as the Palestinians dream of ruling from the river to the sea, and Israel hopes the problem will go away, there is, sadly, not a cat’s chance in hell of peace. But that’s politics for you.
 
Thanks for bringing the topic up.

I think that there is an increasingly performative aspect to British politics which is echoed even more strongly in Ireland.

There is now a never-ending parade of 1-issue parties that promise a "quick fix" to Britain's alleged problems. The classic example is Brexit, which put forward a nonsensical proposition, unbacked by any real research that Britain would benefit from hastily leaving the Single Market EU. Total horseshit that made the careers of several Tory politicians and achieved no real benefit whatsoever to 99.99999% of the population.

That has been followed by other 1-issue horseshit - Reform promising that expelling non-whites would make Britain great again. The regionalist parties like the SNP and Plaid Cymru ranting about how the English "oppress" the Scots and Welsh respectively and how these people have to "resist" - by voting for the politicians selling these brands of snake oil. It's all total horseshit.

I can only think that the current Irish government is big on ranting about Ireland's oppressed past and how nasty the English were and putting forward similarities between Ireland and Palestine - i.e. a culturally distinct settler group displacing the indigenous population, ongoing struggle against colonization, and divided territories and the fight to re unite them.

It legitimizes the current government and distracts the plebs from any real problems that the country might be facing and instead focuses the common herd on a fake, performative battle that can never be won and can be safely waged on the internet and in press releases.

I didn't realize that there was a past undercurrent of anti semitism in Ireland, but I guess I shouldn't be surprised either. This is a country that fought a 5-year civil war between Catholic factions about who hated Proddies more in the early 1920's.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yellowhornet
Ireland was occupied by England.
They sympathize with Palestinians living under Israeli occupation, apartheid and genocide.

that's it
You know something the band U2 used to be my favorite band. One day I was listening to the song Sunday Bloody Sunday and for the first time I heard Bono whisper in the song Jesus won.From that day forward I couldn't listen to that band anymore.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter
The Irish hate everybody that doesn't eat potatoes for every meal and talk with a strange accent it's not just the Jews they are equal opportunity haters
 
yea pretty much it really is that simple
Add in that both liberation struggles involved murdering random women and children of the occupying ethnic group, I guess.

When I lived in the UK in the 70's, the IRA was randomly bombing pubs throughout England, killing innocent people totally uninvolved with the sectarian struggle in Ulster. I am guessing that the current Dublin government glorifies that shit and kinda likes stuff like October 7, which operates on the same level.
 
There was always a divide in Catholic Ireland between the county priests, endemically antisemitic, and the urban academic Catholics, who were in the past much more understanding and sympathetic

by Jeremy Rosen
Opinion

Demonstrators hold Israeli and British flags outside the Law Courts, during a march against antisemitism, after an increase in the UK, during a temporary truce between the Palestinian Islamist terrorists Hamas and Israel, in London, Britain November 26, 2023. Photos: REUTERS/Susannah Ireland
Why is Ireland one of the most antisemitic countries in Europe?
The answer lies in its history. In Ulysses, by James Joyce, the antisemitic character Deasy says that the reason there was no antisemitism in Ireland was because they never let the Jews in, in the first place.
That’s not true of course, because there were significant Jewish communities both in Dublin and Cork. Indeed, my paternal grandparents were buried in Dublin. And in Ulysses itself, Joyce, who understood the Jewish problem in Europe, constantly makes references to Jewish and Zionist themes. There was always a divide in Catholic Ireland between the county priests, endemically antisemitic, and the urban academic Catholics, who were in the past much more understanding and sympathetic. But Irish history is a complex and controversial one.
“The Irish problem” was a subject that I was taught at school as part of the British history curriculum. It started when William the Conqueror came over from France and moved into Ireland, which up to that point had been a purely Gaelic country and culture.
The Irish fought back, but in 1650, Oliver Cromwell brutally suppressed the Gaelic resistance and sent in English settlers to keep the country controlled. English suppression only made matters worse. The Irish kept on fighting the English. And to this day the battle of the Boyne in 1690 is still either celebrated or mourned as the victory of the Protestant King William over the Catholic James.
The great potato famine of 1845, exacerbated by English neglect, caused the deaths of a million, and the emigration of a million more. The battle for Irish home rule dominated parliamentary life throughout the 19th century. The Irish Parliamentary Party tried to solve the Irish problem through negotiation, but failed. Resistance in Ireland grew, spearheaded by the Irish Republican Army and its socialist political party the Sinn Fein.
The British Parliament conceded the right of Ireland to have home rule in 1914, although this still meant it would be under the control of Britain, which was unacceptable to the Republican opposition. Famous Irish poet (and politician) W.B. Yeats wrote his Easter 1916 poem to commemorate the Easter Rising, when the center of Dublin was occupied by several hundred Republicans. After five days they were brutally overcome by British forces and 16 of the leaders were court-martialed and executed. The harsh British reaction helped to win wider support for independence.
During the First World War, many in Ireland supported Germany and refused to serve in the British Army. Ireland was divided not just between Catholics and Protestants, but between those Irishmen who were willing to accept home rule under British authority and those who opposed it and opposed it violently.


Hatred of England was such that in the Second World War, Ireland refused to join the fight against the Nazis. In the North, the battle between Catholics (led by the Provisional IRA) and Protestants continued violently on both sides of the Irish Sea until John Major signed a peace treaty within Northern Ireland in 1994. Meanwhile, the political divisions in Ireland continued between the IRA’s political wing, Fianna Fail, and Fianna Gael, the more right-wing until relatively recently.

The impossibility of finding a peaceful solution to the division of Ireland still challenges. And the Catholics still dream of getting it all back. No comparisons are ever absolute. And as long as the Palestinians dream of ruling from the river to the sea, and Israel hopes the problem will go away, there is, sadly, not a cat’s chance in hell of peace. But that’s politics for you.
You do realize ireland is 2 countries right ?
 
It seems like when you occupy someone else's country, it creates blowback for you. Weird.
What's your solution?

What are you going to do with the 10 million Jews living in Israel, in a democratic parliamentary democracy which gives full citizenship rights to Arabs?

Kill them like HAMAS wants to do?

Deport them and have them live in Toronto?

We occupy first nations land in Toronto. Should the First Nations kill us? Or force us to return to our home countries? Your choice.

As soon as you stop swallowing the shit you hear on the internet and actually think through the problem, it becomes less easy to be a blabber-wabber. :D
 
What's your solution?
So glad you asked. The situation is simple. Leave them to their own devices, and let them sort it out.

As you said, we occupy First Nations land. No one is bankrolling us. Our initial conquest was bankrolled by the British Empire, because we were part of it. Now we're an independent country.

If the First Nations decided to kill us, we'd have to defend ourselves. Britain is not going to save us. The US will not save us, unless we become their vassal.

Israel is an independent state. Its about time they start acting like it.
 
So glad you asked. The situation is simple. Leave them to their own devices, and let them sort it out.

As you said, we occupy First Nations land. No one is bankrolling us. Our initial conquest was bankrolled by the British Empire, because we were part of it. Now we're an independent country.

If the First Nations decided to kill us, we'd have to defend ourselves. Britain is not going to save us. The US will not save us, unless we become their vassal.

Israel is an independent state. Its about time they start acting like it.
Your initial post - let me remind you - is that occupying another country's land creates blowback. I asked you what you intend to do about it and you immediately deflected by changing the topic to something totally different.

Please try and answer my post directly and honestly.

And here's another thing that you overlooked in your post: - When the IRA bombed British pubs in the 1970's, IRELAND WAS ALREADY FUCKING FREE!!!!!!!!!

The IRA wanted to annex Protestant Northern Ireland and add it to the southern Catholic Republic of Ireland. The pub bombings were essentially part of an aggressive war of annexation. Basically, the IRA wanted to "River to the Sea" the protestant Irish in the North.

SMH.
 
What's your solution?

What are you going to do with the 10 million Jews living in Israel, in a democratic parliamentary democracy which gives full citizenship rights to Arabs?

Kill them like HAMAS wants to do?

Deport them and have them live in Toronto?

We occupy first nations land in Toronto. Should the First Nations kill us? Or force us to return to our home countries? Your choice.

As soon as you stop swallowing the shit you hear on the internet and actually think through the problem, it becomes less easy to be a blabber-wabber. :D

We know the solution you back.
Killing Palestinians if you can't force them to leave.


 
The IRA wanted to annex Protestant Northern Ireland and add it to the southern Catholic Republic of Ireland. The pub bombings were essentially part of an aggressive war of annexation. Basically, the IRA wanted to "River to the Sea" the protestant Irish in the North.

SMH.

Does that mean you want the Irish solution?
Give every Palestinian full human rights, end apartheid and give them all the vote.
Every Palestinian under Israeli rule, including Gaza.
And that means the right of return.

That would be democracy.
And zionists can't take democracy.

 
Your initial post - let me remind you - is that occupying another country's land creates blowback. I asked you what you intend to do about it
Do you not understand English? I said leave them to their own devices, and let them sort it out.

Which is the same thing I'd say about Britain and Ireland.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Frankfooter