The Court of Appeal decision
almost restores my faith in the ability of the legal system to get something right. Almost. There's still that vexing problem that the lower courts are so biased and unreliable that you need the extraordinary resources of a large corporation or a government to litigate up to a level of court that is capable of getting it right. Notwithstanding that the courts ultimately got this one right, we're a long way from a system that consistently produces just results for ordinary citizens in a cost effective manner.
I've read many of the posts in this thread, particularly the ones talking about the traffic benefits of bike lanes and the hardship to cyclists in removing them. The problem with all those arguments is that they are based on complete fantasy. Anyone who actually drives much in the city along roads which have bike lanes KNOWS these things:
- Bike lanes are woefully UNDERUTILIZED portions of the roads. I have never (and that means for as long as there have been bike lanes) seen any stretch of bike lane where the passenger volume per distance and per hour comes anywhere close to the throughput of cars over the same section of road.
- Bike lane use declines PRECIPITOUSLY frrom November to March every year, where car lane use does not.
- Bike lanes cause dangerous right of way and procedural confusion when it comes to cars turning right or bicycles turning left.
- Bike lanes are themselves unsafe because there is no clear protocol for bikes overtaking other bikes or maintaining single file order.
- There are no clear rules regarding the operation of part-time motorized bikes, low speed motorized bikes or mobility vehicles in bike lanes.
- The first thing that's always lost in order to build a bike lane is parking, and that's bad for retail business.
- Toronto is a particularly poor candidate for bike lanes given our apparent inability to remove snow from the roads in the winter.
For those who enjoy cycling for exercise, there are off-road bike paths in many parts of the city. For those who enjoy it as a lifestyle choice, have at it, but don't expect the rest of the citizenry to subsidize you or accommodate you. For those who ride a bike because they can't afford a car, or lost their driver's license, life is tough so make better choices.