How would NATO and major allies likely respond diplomatically and economically to a U.S. attack on Canada?

No way nuclear, because of radioactive contamination, at the very least. If you think the Manitoba wildfires were a problem for the mid-west states, how bad would nuclear fall-out be?

But I do not put non-nuclear attacks of various kinds past Trump and Hegseth.

Look what Trump is trying to do to us economically? Who would have ever predicted that, based on our hundreds of years of peaceful history?

Yet here we are...

I wasn't being serious when I suggested nuclear attack :)

seems to me that US has Canada under complete control economically for decades

there must be a reason why for so long we are not developing our natural recourse

to benefit us, and why all our pipe lines are going south instead of west or east

but also I don't think that changing a name of a lake is the same as declaration of war

look at Mexico and how they reacted to changing Golf of Mexico name

and yet they seem to be getting some kind of a deal with Trump

I think we have to start putting the blame on our government for terribly mismanaging this file

I don't think they are taking it seriously

Carney is all talk, and after a couple of televised replies of "matching tariffs dollar for dollar"

which makes a really nice sound bite specially for the simple minded people

because it will only hurt them the most

for once I would like to hear politicians offer their sacrifice, like taking a pay cut

do you think that will ever happen?

and now Carney is getting ready to go to Europe again

instead of staying home where he is really needed

also our Premier of Ontario who is on summer vacation till November

instead of cutting his vacation short and coming back to work in this so called crises

he comes on TV and tell the President of USA to kiss his ass

and the plebs rejoices, it appeals to the lowest common denominator of complete dim wits

so like I said, I don't think the government is taking this situation seriously

why should we?
 
Last edited:
It would be really REALLY hard for Trump to sell a war against Canada to the American public.
What could possibly be their justification for an invasion??
Canada is a terrorist State?? Canada has weapons of mass destruction????

LOL.....I dont think most Americans would go for it, except maybe a small fringe of southern rednecks.
Of course those rednecks would have to find Canada on the map first :D

trump would be more likely to declare that he needs to 'rescue' Alberta and its oil from Canada.
 
I wasn't being serious when I suggested nuclear attack :)

seems to me that US has Canada under complete control economically for decades

there must be a reason why for so long we are not developing our natural recourse

to benefit us, and why all our pipe lines are going south instead of west or east

but also I don't think that changing a name of a lake is the same as declaration of war

look at Mexico and how they reacted to changing Golf of Mexico name

and yet they seem to be getting some kind of a deal with Trump

I think we have to start putting the blame on our government for terribly mismanaging this file

I don't think they are taking it seriously

Carney is all talk, and after a couple of televised replies of "matching tariffs dollar for dollar"

which makes a really nice sound bite specially for the simple minded people

because it will only hurt them the most

for once I would like to hear politicians offer their sacrifice, like taking a pay cut

do you think that will ever happen?

and now Carney is getting ready to go to Europe again

instead of staying home where he is really needed

also our Premier of Ontario who is on summer vacation till November

instead of cutting his vacation short and coming back to work in this so called crises

he comes on TV and tell the President of USA to kiss his ass

and the plebs rejoices, it appeals to the lowest common denominator of complete dim wits

so like I said, I don't think the government is taking this situation seriously

why should we?

The government is taking it seriously, what they aren't doing is making it all public and antagonizing the senile pedo to the south.

Ford will never cancel any of the shit ton of american contracts he signed, though.

 
I wasn't being serious when I suggested nuclear attack :)

seems to me that US has Canada under complete control economically for decades

there must be a reason why for so long we are not developing our natural recourse

to benefit us, and why all our pipe lines are going south instead of west or east

but also I don't think that changing a name of a lake is the same as declaration of war

look at Mexico and how they reacted to changing Golf of Mexico name

and yet they seem to be getting some kind of a deal with Trump

I think we have to start putting the blame on our government for terribly mismanaging this file

I don't think they are taking it seriously

Carney is all talk, and after a couple of televised replies of "matching tariffs dollar for dollar"

which makes a really nice sound bite specially for the simple minded people

because it will only hurt them the most

for once I would like to hear politicians offer their sacrifice, like taking a pay cut

do you think that will ever happen?

and now Carney is getting ready to go to Europe again

instead of staying home where he is really needed

also our Premier of Ontario who is on summer vacation till November

instead of cutting his vacation short and coming back to work in this so called crises

he comes on TV and tell the President of USA to kiss his ass

and the plebs rejoices, it appeals to the lowest common denominator of complete dim wits

so like I said, I don't think the government is taking this situation seriously

why should we?

I'm, like 80% of the population, perfectly fine with walking away from the negotiations, allowing for a cooling off period, and wait for the USA to stop fucking around, and take things seriously.

Simple fact is, we have stuff they need. Don't believe the Venezuela hype. Their actual reserves are about 1/3 of what they claimed. Its actually dirtier than ours, and it would take hundreds of billions in infrastructure investment over a decade to get it up to snuff. That's why the oil companies refuse to come in on Trump's plan.

While all the infrastructure is in place with us now, stable government, etc. They will come back. It will take a bit. But they will
 
  • Like
Reactions: Phil C. McNasty
I wouldn't count on it. If there's one thing the Yanks absolutely suck at it's occupying the countries they invade.

It's the natural outcome of a military stocked with poor, inbred rednecks and people from ghettos
Canada would be very difficult to occupy.
We have crazy forest terrain in Ontario, Quebec, and British Columbia.
I would say it's even worse than Vietnam or Afghanistan.
Then of course we also have the cold weather.

The only problem that I mentioned before is that we would eventually run out of weapons, and would be very hard to resupply our rebel forces because of our geographical location.

I've actually given this some thought and Mexican drug cartels might be our best bet to supplies us with AK-47's 😃
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Unstopp@bull
Canada would be very difficult to occupy.
We have crazy forest terrain in Ontario, Quebec, and British Columbia.
I would say it's even worse than Vietnam or Afghanistan.
Then of course we also have the cold weather.

The only problem that I mentioned before is that we would eventually run out of weapons, and would be very hard to resupply our rebel forces because of our geographical location.

I've actually given this some thought and Mexican drug cartels might be our best bet to supplies us with AK-47's 😃

You nailed it. One big factor in Canada's favour is how spread thin the US military is globally -- occupying Canada effectively would take massive manpower.

Controlling the Greater Golden Horseshoe is one thing, but Canada's real value lies in natural resources buried out in far-flung regions. Securing thousands of miles of remote pipelines, railway corridors and northern mines against sabotage would be an absolute nightmare without an infinite number of boots on the ground.
 
  • Like
Reactions: xmontrealer
Question to all you Lefties, how stupid do you now feel about Justin Trudeau's assault rifle ban??


Would you really feel comfortable with an American invasion when you're not allowed to have an AK-47???!!! 😃

I swear to God, Liberals got to be some of the dumbest people on the planet 🫩

I can see it now, Phil with his AK47 keeping the Marines at bay!

Marine- angry, pale Canadian firing at us from his fish hut on frozen Lake America, yelling something about Terb and Lake Ontario

Headquarters- Get his handle and take him out, Corporal.

Marine- Roger that, I have dibs on his 2-4 of Bud Light.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Phil C. McNasty
I can see it now, Phil with his AK47 keeping the Marines at bay!

Marine- angry, pale Canadian firing at us from his fish hut on frozen Lake America, yelling something about Terb and Lake Ontario

Headquarters- Get his handle and take him out, Corporal.

Marine- Roger that, I have dibs on his 2-4 of Bud Light.
And @squeezer would be hiding behinds his mom's couch with his mask on begging the US soldier for a covid vaccine
 
You nailed it. One big factor in Canada's favour is how spread thin the US military is globally -- occupying Canada effectively would take massive manpower.

Controlling the Greater Golden Horseshoe is one thing, but Canada's real value lies in natural resources buried out in far-flung regions. Securing thousands of miles of remote pipelines, railway corridors and northern mines against sabotage would be an absolute nightmare without an infinite number of boots on the ground
I ran it through AI:

Q. In case of a US military invasion into Canada, how many US soldiers would it take to occupy the entire country of Canada??

A.
To successfully occupy Canada, the United States would likely need between 800,000 and 1 million active-duty soldiers. [1]
While the U.S. military could overwhelm Canada's conventional defenses in a matter of days, subduing and occupying the entire country presents an entirely different, nearly impossible logistical challenge. [1, 2] Military historians and defense analysts calculate occupation troop requirements based on the Troop-to-Population Ratio and the complexity of Canada's vast geography.

1. The Troop-to-Population Formula: ~800,000 Troops
In modern military doctrine, a standard benchmark for stabilizing a hostile population during a counter-insurgency is 20 soldiers per 1,000 civilians (or a 1:50 ratio). With Canada’s population hovering around 41 million people, applying this formula means the U.S. would require a minimum of 820,000 occupying troops strictly dedicated to policing streets, securing cities, and guarding critical infrastructure. [1, 2]

2. The Geographic Multiplier: Over 1 Million Troops
Canada is the second-largest country by landmass, spanning nearly 10 million square kilometers. Controlling its major urban centers—which are strung across a 5,000-kilometer border—is mathematically possible, but securing the vast, rugged wilderness of the Canadian Shield, the Rockies, and the Arctic would require hundreds of thousands of additional troops.

Because the U.S. active-duty Army and Marine Corps combined only comprise about 650,000 to 700,000 personnel, the U.S. does not currently possess enough ground forces to simultaneously invade, hold, and police the entirety of Canada without massive, forced domestic conscription.


What an Occupation Would Actually Look Like

Recent Canadian military models and defense experts emphasize that an invasion would trigger a decades-long asymmetric conflict. [1, 2]
  • The Insurgency Threat: Defense experts note that if even 1% of Canadians resisted, it would form a 400,000-person insurgency. This is roughly 10 times the size of the Taliban force that fighting the U.S. in Afghanistan. [1, 2]
  • The "Citizens' Army" Strategy: The Canadian military has modeled defensive frameworks prioritizing decentralized, guerrilla-style tactics. This includes hit-and-run ambushes, drone strikes, and sabotaging infrastructure, leveraging Canada's harsh winters and wilderness. Canada's military leadership has also laid out frameworks to mobilize a volunteer civil-defense reserve of up to 300,000 to 400,000 citizens to actively disrupt occupying forces.
Domestic Blowback: Because the U.S. and Canada share tightly integrated infrastructure (grids, pipelines, and supply lines), a Canadian insurgency would have immediate, destructive access to American critical infrastructure right across the border
 
I ran it through AI:

Q. In case of a US military invasion into Canada, how many US soldiers would it take to occupy the entire country of Canada??

A.
To successfully occupy Canada, the United States would likely need between 800,000 and 1 million active-duty soldiers. [1]
While the U.S. military could overwhelm Canada's conventional defenses in a matter of days, subduing and occupying the entire country presents an entirely different, nearly impossible logistical challenge. [1, 2] Military historians and defense analysts calculate occupation troop requirements based on the Troop-to-Population Ratio and the complexity of Canada's vast geography.

1. The Troop-to-Population Formula: ~800,000 Troops
In modern military doctrine, a standard benchmark for stabilizing a hostile population during a counter-insurgency is 20 soldiers per 1,000 civilians (or a 1:50 ratio). With Canada’s population hovering around 41 million people, applying this formula means the U.S. would require a minimum of 820,000 occupying troops strictly dedicated to policing streets, securing cities, and guarding critical infrastructure. [1, 2]

2. The Geographic Multiplier: Over 1 Million Troops
Canada is the second-largest country by landmass, spanning nearly 10 million square kilometers. Controlling its major urban centers—which are strung across a 5,000-kilometer border—is mathematically possible, but securing the vast, rugged wilderness of the Canadian Shield, the Rockies, and the Arctic would require hundreds of thousands of additional troops.

Because the U.S. active-duty Army and Marine Corps combined only comprise about 650,000 to 700,000 personnel, the U.S. does not currently possess enough ground forces to simultaneously invade, hold, and police the entirety of Canada without massive, forced domestic conscription.


What an Occupation Would Actually Look Like

Recent Canadian military models and defense experts emphasize that an invasion would trigger a decades-long asymmetric conflict. [1, 2]
  • The Insurgency Threat: Defense experts note that if even 1% of Canadians resisted, it would form a 400,000-person insurgency. This is roughly 10 times the size of the Taliban force that fighting the U.S. in Afghanistan. [1, 2]
  • The "Citizens' Army" Strategy: The Canadian military has modeled defensive frameworks prioritizing decentralized, guerrilla-style tactics. This includes hit-and-run ambushes, drone strikes, and sabotaging infrastructure, leveraging Canada's harsh winters and wilderness. Canada's military leadership has also laid out frameworks to mobilize a volunteer civil-defense reserve of up to 300,000 to 400,000 citizens to actively disrupt occupying forces.
Domestic Blowback: Because the U.S. and Canada share tightly integrated infrastructure (grids, pipelines, and supply lines), a Canadian insurgency would have immediate, destructive access to American critical infrastructure right across the border

Thanks for sharing -- wow, I knew it would be tough, but I didn't realize how tough that would be.

At any rate, I'll be sleeping easy tonight, lol.
 
Thanks for sharing -- wow, I knew it would be tough, but I didn't realize how tough that would be.

At any rate, I'll be sleeping easy tonight, lol.
Our 2 biggest challenges would be:

1. How motivated would Canadians be to fight the US (obviously we can rule out most Liberals, including @squeezer).
2. Like I mentioned before, getting a steady supply of weapons.

I ran that through AI as well:

Q. How would foreign allies smuggle weapons past a U.S. naval blockade


To smuggle weapons past a U.S. naval blockade, foreign allies would exploit Canada's most indomitable defense: its geography. Canada has the longest coastline in the world, spanning over 243,000 kilometres across three oceans.
Because the United States Navy—even as the world's premier maritime power—does not possess enough surface combatants to continuously patrol millions of square kilometres of jagged, frozen, and labyrinthine coastal waters, foreign allies would rely on a mix of asymmetric maritime tactics, environmental exploitation, and deep-submergence logistics.


1. The Arctic Archipelago Strategy (The Deep Freeze Corridor)
The most viable entry point for heavy foreign military aid would be the Canadian Arctic Archipelago.
  • The Geography: This region comprises over 36,000 islands and thousands of narrow, treacherous channels.
  • The Tactic: Adversaries or allies with advanced polar capabilities (such as Russia or northern European nations) would use nuclear-powered icebreakers or specialized ice-strengthened cargo vessels to navigate frozen corridors during winter.
  • The Counter-Blockade Advantage: Thick sea ice makes it impossible for standard U.S. Navy surface combatants (like Arleigh Burke-class destroyers or Ticonderoga-class cruisers) to pursue or patrol without risking structural disaster. Weapons would be offloaded at remote northern outposts like Resolute or Iqaluit and transported south via snowmobiles, rugged cargo planes, or local dog-sled logistics networks.

2. Sub-Surface Maritime Pipelines (The Stealth Delivery)
To bypass U.S. satellite tracking and radar picket lines in the Atlantic and Pacific, allies would abandon surface shipping entirely in favour of underwater supply chains.
  • Foreign Attack Submarines: Advanced naval allies (like the UK or France) or adversaries could utilize nuclear-powered attack submarines (SSNs) or ultra-quiet diesel-electric submarines with Air-Independent Propulsion (AIP).
  • The Tactic: These submarines would slip beneath the U.S. acoustic hydrophone networks, entering deep fjords along the coast of British Columbia or the rugged bays of Newfoundland and Labrador.
  • Undersea Caching: Instead of surfacing, submarines could deploy specialized underwater cargo containers or uncrewed underwater vehicles (UUVs) packed with anti-tank missiles, man-portable air-defense systems (MANPADS), and ammunition into designated coastal caches for Canadian divers to retrieve.

3. "Little Green Boats" and the Archipelago Screen
On the Pacific coast, the Inside Passage—a coastal route weaving through thousands of islands between Washington State and Alaska—provides perfect cover for maritime guerrilla tactics.
  • The Tactic: Foreign supply ships would drop anchor in international waters or deep within Alaskan/Russian maritime borders. Cargo would then be broken down into hundreds of civilian fishing trawlers, tugboats, and pleasure crafts.
  • Radar Clutter: These small, wooden, or fiberglass boats have incredibly low radar cross-sections. Amid the thousands of legitimate vessels operating in the Pacific Northwest, a U.S. blockade would suffer from severe "target saturation." Interdicting every single fishing boat along the BC coast would drain U.S. naval resources and inevitably allow thousands of weapons to slip through to the mainland.

4. Commercial Aero-Smuggling & Deep-Woods Air Drops
While a naval blockade usually pairs with a No-Fly Zone, Canada’s sheer airspace volume makes total sealing impossible.
  • Low-Altitude Terrain Masking: Cargo planes flying from Europe or Asia could utilize Greenlandic airspace or cross the North Pole, dropping down to ultra-low altitudes (below 50 metres) over the vast Canadian boreal forest to blind U.S. AWACS radar.
  • The Canadian Shield Drop: Weapons crates fitted with GPS-guided parachutes would be dropped over remote, uninhabited stretches of Northern Ontario, Quebec, or Manitoba. Indigenous rangers and local insurgent cells, intimately familiar with the bush, would recover the caches before U.S. satellite reconnaissance could identify the drop zones.