War with Iran

I find it interesting how absolute you are in your beliefs that I am wrong yet admit you also don't know and won't check.


Not sure why you are posting something that agrees with me.
 
Bro, I don’t really get the “illegal war” terminology.
What makes a war “legal” vs “illegal”?

jus ad bellum

There is international law on the subject and there are usually internal laws in a given country about the proper procedure to declare war or initiate military action.
 
No, he is not.
He is a credentialed professor on this topic and his predictions regarding the Russia-Ukraine war, as much as you may not like it, have essentially turned out to be true.

Which predictions were those?
I'm not a huge fan of Mearshimer and his offensive realism, and I see in the video you posted he's with Stephen Walt (with whom he has collaborated before). Walt, of course, was very clear eyed about Trump.

1775167107916.png

That said, I don't think Mearshimer is a paid russian shill.
I thought he mostly did academic analysis, which makes me a bit surprised to hear he has made specific predictions about the war that came true, but that doesn't mean it didn't happen.
 
Which predictions were those?
I'm not a huge fan of Mearshimer and his offensive realism, and I see in the video you posted he's with Stephen Walt (with whom he has collaborated before). Walt, of course, was very clear eyed about Trump.
That said, I don't think Mearshimer is a paid russian shill.
He said that this will not be a victory for Ukraine, and that it will be a long gruelling frozen war and that American money will run out at some point.
Which more or less is true in my opinion.
I am no expert on political science but while I agree with some aspects of his offensive realism theory, it also seems to ignore institutions, economic interdependence, domestic politics etc.,
Similarly his analysis on why Russia decided to attack Ukraine, while reasonable to an extent, also fails to consider Putin's other motivations, world events etc.,
However I do agree with him on Iran and Israel.
My point to Mandrill however was to not call him a "Russian disinformant" just because he says Ukraine won't win. Which he is not.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
Just saw they are doubling the number of A-10's in the area......
 
  • Wow
Reactions: crocket
jus ad bellum

There is international law on the subject and there are usually internal laws in a given country about the proper procedure to declare war or initiate military action.
Ok I get it. So to the degree the UN Charter constitutes a legal jurisdiction or otherwise is actually binding, a war is illegal unless it was approved by the UN.
One practical issue that it makes it more difficult to have an element of surprise when you need it.

Another, the UN has become corrupt and has long discredited itself. It should be dissolved or reformed, imho.
 
Ok I get it. So to the degree the UN Charter constitutes a legal jurisdiction or otherwise is actually binding, a war is illegal unless it was approved by the UN.
One practical issue that it makes it more difficult to have an element of surprise when you need it.

Another, the UN has become corrupt and has long discredited itself. It should be dissolved or reformed, imho.

The theory you are not supposed to start them without a damn good reason. And a damn good plan.
 
He said that this will not be a victory for Ukraine, and that it will be a long gruelling frozen war and that American money will run out at some point.
Which more or less is true in my opinion.

OK, that's more in line with what I would expect.
Not specific predictions about specific things.
That didn't seem right.

My point to Mandrill however was to not call him a "Russian disinformant" just because he says Ukraine won't win. Which he is not.