[
Perhaps I can provide a Canadian example to give you some perspective on the delicate balance of immigration and the economy. Canada has been absorbing more immigrants the past several years. Over the years, economists and financial experts noticed that Canada was in a slow growth cycle while immigration increased. The result was productivity growth was stalling. That's not to say the immigrants were directly causing low productivity. However, one could surmise Canada's immigration exceeded its need for new workers.
Let me switch to a very simple example on immigration and productivity. Let's say you are an affluent guy and you buy a bigger house with a bigger yard. You hire a cleaning lady and a landscaper who don't have their papers. Does this add to my country's productivity? Productivity has likely decreased because productivity is measured by the value of output divided by workers. Productivity is a key metric of national wealth.
Well anticipating your counter, you might say someone cleaning my house and cutting my lawn frees me up to be more productive. The answer is yes and no. Economists wrestle with these exact issues. Clearly at some point, Americans are relying on migrants to do and more things for them. There is also the problem of able-bodied Americans (and Canadians) not working at all. That's a net deficit to productivity.
Now what happens if I tell my son he has to cut the lawn. You know like the good old days when kids did chores. Such a conservative notion, I know. Notice how this little switch is a better outcome for the nation's productivity. You can accomplish the same result by hiring the neighbor's son or an underemployed American.
Yes, there are a few million undocumented people in the US. How many, who can say. The Pew Research group believes that number was around 14 million in 2023. But, it is impossible to really say. But that doesn't really change the overall argument. The reality is the US economy is greased by the undocumented. Saying otherwise is a lie. If you were to deport all of them, it would have a catastrophic impact on the US economy. We're actually seeing some of that damage right now.
Look, as I said, I do not have the answers here. I understand and believe that fair immigration is important, and undocumented people can be a problem. But, for the most part, they are expanding the US economy, not weighing it down. And, I acknowledge that there are no easy answers. Deporting tears families apart, and the Trump administration is sending refugees back to places where they face persecution, torture and death. But, also giving undocumented a pathway to citizenship also would increase the numbers crossing the border. There is no simple solution, but what ever gets done will hurt both sides (left v right) in one way or the other.
Perhaps I can provide a Canadian example to give you some perspective on the delicate balance of immigration and the economy. Canada has been absorbing more immigrants the past several years. Over the years, economists and financial experts noticed that Canada was in a slow growth cycle while immigration increased. The result was productivity growth was stalling. That's not to say the immigrants were directly causing low productivity. However, one could surmise Canada's immigration exceeded its need for new workers.
Let me switch to a very simple example on immigration and productivity. Let's say you are an affluent guy and you buy a bigger house with a bigger yard. You hire a cleaning lady and a landscaper who don't have their papers. Does this add to my country's productivity? Productivity has likely decreased because productivity is measured by the value of output divided by workers. Productivity is a key metric of national wealth.
Well anticipating your counter, you might say someone cleaning my house and cutting my lawn frees me up to be more productive. The answer is yes and no. Economists wrestle with these exact issues. Clearly at some point, Americans are relying on migrants to do and more things for them. There is also the problem of able-bodied Americans (and Canadians) not working at all. That's a net deficit to productivity.
Now what happens if I tell my son he has to cut the lawn. You know like the good old days when kids did chores. Such a conservative notion, I know. Notice how this little switch is a better outcome for the nation's productivity. You can accomplish the same result by hiring the neighbor's son or an underemployed American.


