Anti-NATO protests in Europe

Not about what it would look like now and certainly not rolling out the two other obvious counterfactuals:

1. NATO doesn't expand at all in 1997/99.
2. NATO is disbanded soon after 1991.

The idea that none of the countries involved there would have tried to make other security arrangements is silly, but somehow the "NATO shouldn't exist/NATO shouldn't have expanded" crew never want to talk about that.
I think it would have been healthier for both Europe and USA, if Europe had made its own defensive security alliance.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Valcazar
There are only 2 countries Russia has attacked since 91. Georgia and Ukraine, both for NATO reasons. If NATO was disbanded and countries were truly independent without being meddled with, we would have peace in the region. Certainly Russia would have more influence, but that is not a bad thing as long as there is peace and as long as countries are truly making their own decisions.

Afghanistan
Georgia
Chechyna
Syria
South Ossetia
Abkhazia
Tajikistan
Dagestan
 
So basically you dont have a problem with Ukraine being a puppet state as long as it is a puppet of the west. If they are a puppet of the west, they are "making their own decisions" and are an "independent state". If not, they are a puppet of Russia.

Your inability to understand agency isn't my problem.

Nothing, there are no alliances necessary. There are only 2 countries Russia has attacked since 91. Georgia and Ukraine, both for NATO reasons. If NATO was disbanded and countries were truly independent without being meddled with, we would have peace in the region. Certainly Russia would have more influence, but that is not a bad thing as long as there is peace and as long as countries are truly making their own decisions.

That's a ridiculously naïve view of the world.
Do you honestly think no countries would make any alliances?
Have you no concept of world history or international relationships at all?
 
I think it would have been healthier for both Europe and USA, if Europe had made its own defensive security alliance.

Very possibly.

That the US didn't want to give up its position as a major player there was definitely a factor in NATO continuing.

How the US would have backed out and under what conditions is hard to figure. It could easily have turned into some kind of EU-US two equals alliance instead of dozens of countries all with a veto.

What happens to central europe and the ex-Warsaw pact in that situation? Those countries were desperate to get out from under Russia and get some kind of protection. That NATO was so reluctant to accept them was a source of major tension, but if NATO had disbanded completely would they have gone crawling back or would they have pushed for a new pan-Europe alliance or even made their own Central Europe defensive alliance? Would that have resulted in even more tension across the region? Would Russia have tried to use more force to keep them in line with no NATO?

None of that is obvious.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SchlongConery
Your inability to understand agency isn't my problem.



That's a ridiculously naïve view of the world.
Do you honestly think no countries would make any alliances?
Have you no concept of world history or international relationships at all?

Your hypocrisy in defining agency is the problem. When a country "aligns with the west" aka becomes a western puppet state (with strong evidence of western meddling), it is making an "independent decision". If a country is aligned to Russia on the other hand, then they are a banana republic.

Countries can form alliances sure. But an adversarial military alliance aimed at one state eventually leads to war. So I ask the question back to you - have you no understanding of world history at all?
 
Afghanistan
Georgia
Chechyna
Syria
South Ossetia
Abkhazia
Tajikistan
Dagestan

Afghanistan - Since 91? When?
Georgia - Yes
Chechyna - Civil war, not valid.
Syria - Civil war, requested by govt, not valid.
South Ossetia - Civil war, not valid.
Abkhazia - Civil war, not valid
Tajikistan - Civil war, not valid
Dagestan - Civil war, not valid.

Try again.
 
Your hypocrisy in defining agency is the problem. When a country "aligns with the west" aka becomes a western puppet state (with strong evidence of western meddling), it is making an "independent decision". If a country is aligned to Russia on the other hand, then they are a banana republic.

Countries can form alliances sure. But an adversarial military alliance aimed at one state eventually leads to war. So I ask the question back to you - have you no understanding of world history at all?

It sounds like your definition of puppet state is any state that aligns with the US.
 
It sounds like your definition of puppet state is any state that aligns with the US.

Not really. Canada is not a puppet state. Ukraine is. It depends on how that alignment was achieved.
 
Your hypocrisy in defining agency is the problem. When a country "aligns with the west" aka becomes a western puppet state (with strong evidence of western meddling), it is making an "independent decision". If a country is aligned to Russia on the other hand, then they are a banana republic.

Countries can form alliances sure. But an adversarial military alliance aimed at one state eventually leads to war. So I ask the question back to you - have you no understanding of world history at all?

Clearly more than you.

I'm not the one denying the agency of countries.
I'm not the one with a binary "everything leads to war" view of the world.
I'm not the one who said every country who aligns with Russia is a banana republic.
 
Not really. Canada is not a puppet state. Ukraine is. It depends on how that alignment was achieved.

Not for a moment accepting your ludicrous assertion of Ukraine being a puppet state of the US but for the purpose of discussion...

Ask Belarussians and Ukrainians whose hand they would CHOOSE to have up their skirt?

And ask them both what would happen if either country told their Puppet Masters to FUCK OFF.

I think the Belorussians would be brutally liberated by Russia.

I think the Ukrainians would also then be brutally liberated by Russia!
 
  • Like
Reactions: squeezer
Clearly more than you.

I'm not the one denying the agency of countries.
I'm not the one with a binary "everything leads to war" view of the world.
I'm not the one who said every country who aligns with Russia is a banana republic.

It is absolutely you that defines agency in a hypocritical manner. I call Ukraine a banana republic because that is what they are - they were formerly a Russian puppet and now they are a western puppet. It is you that is applying double standards here.

It is you that is playing conveniently dumb in your view of what leads to war and what doesn't.

And if you even applied even a minimal amount of introspection and learning to lessons from history, you'd see that the very same rhetoric has been used by the west multiple times in the past, against, Russia.

In short its not me that is not paying attention to history.
 
Not for a moment accepting your ludicrous assertion of Ukraine being a puppet state of the US but for the purpose of discussion...

Ask Belarussians and Ukrainians whose hand they would CHOOSE to have up their skirt?

And ask them both what would happen if either country told their Puppet Masters to FUCK OFF.

I think the Belorussians would be brutally liberated by Russia.

I think the Ukrainians would also then be brutally liberated by Russia!

Belarus is pro-Russia. Ukraine is divided. That is the truth.

It is also true that Belarus is a Russian puppet. Ukraine is a western puppet. Both are essentially banana republics.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Valcazar

 
Belarus is pro-Russia. Ukraine is divided. That is the truth.

It is also true that Belarus is a Russian puppet. Ukraine is a western puppet. Both are essentially banana republics.


You didn't answer my questions. You just did what Russian propaganda is known to do best, try to claim division, sow or impute discord out of proportion to reality.

I didn't ask about Belarus or Ukraine.

I asked about the people. Belarussians and Ukrainians. Who would the people of those countries choose to be their Banana Republic puppet masters to live their lives under?
 
I asked about the people. Belarussians and Ukrainians. Who would the people of those countries choose to be their Banana Republic puppet masters to live their lives under?

Belarussians will be pro-Russia and Ukrainians will be divided with Donbas and Crimea being pro-Russian and the rest being pro-EU.
 
Belarussians will be pro-Russia and Ukrainians will be divided with Donbas and Crimea being pro-Russian and the rest being pro-EU.

I know from the intelligence you have amply demonstrated in other threads, you are not having problems with comprehension.

You are just trying to weasel out of answering the question. I am not asking who (you think) are pro-who and within imagined gerrymandered borders.

Would BELARUSSIAN people prefer to live as a US PUPPET BANANA REPUBLIC with the associated freedom, quality of life etc that is permitted in a western democracy?

Or live under the rule of Russian Vice-Dictator Lukashenka under the protection of Russia?

Same question for the people within the legal entity of Ukraine 1991 or even the borders agreed to by Russia and SIGNED BY PUTIN HIMSELF in 2003.
 
I know from the intelligence you have amply demonstrated in other threads, you are not having problems with comprehension.

You are just trying to weasel out of answering the question. I am not asking who (you think) are pro-who and within imagined gerrymandered borders.

Would BELARUSSIAN people prefer to live as a US PUPPET BANANA REPUBLIC with the associated freedom, quality of life etc that is permitted in a western democracy?

Or live under the rule of Russian Vice-Dictator Lukashenka under the protection of Russia?

Same question for the people within the legal entity of Ukraine 1991 or even the borders agreed to by Russia and SIGNED BY PUTIN HIMSELF in 2003.

Oh I see what you are asking.

That is a leading question and calls for speculation and therefore doesn't deserve answer.

Yes the west has better living standards, but is becoming a puppet to the west worth it in order to achieve said living standards? I would say no. Those things come at a heavy price, which is not worth paying.

In this case, I can only presume that Belarussians and Ukrainians will be divided. People dont make a decision to side with one country or the other solely based on promises of quality of life. In short, you would be wrong to assume you can "buy" people.
 
I know from the intelligence you have amply demonstrated in other threads, you are not having problems with comprehension.

You are just trying to weasel out of answering the question. I am not asking who (you think) are pro-who and within imagined gerrymandered borders.

Would BELARUSSIAN people prefer to live as a US PUPPET BANANA REPUBLIC with the associated freedom, quality of life etc that is permitted in a western democracy?

Or live under the rule of Russian Vice-Dictator Lukashenka under the protection of Russia?

Same question for the people within the legal entity of Ukraine 1991 or even the borders agreed to by Russia and SIGNED BY PUTIN HIMSELF in 2003.
unfortunately, you may be overly optimistic about Byelorussian and other Russian-speaking people IQ