Shooting At McDonalds

You will use any argument to justify a right to bear arms it seems.

So we should let the citizenry carry, just like we license cars, for the sake of self-defense? Against whom? Your neighbour who has a gun too? Terrorists? Pirates? Insurgents? Drug gangs a la Mexico?

Sounds like a powder keg to me. Good night.

And it's clear you'll use any argument against it, no matter how flawed or hypocritical it is. Let the citizens decide for themselves. Let's replace the word "gun" with "fire extinguisher" or "home insurance". People who haven't had house fires will still tend to have one or both, why? Just in case. If you don't like guns, there already exists an easy fix, which doesn't require forcing your opinions or beliefs on others; don't buy a gun.
 
It's an argument in the context of lax or more liberal short gun laws like in the U.S., as some of the posters are implying.

The deterrent argument is silly. (Somebody who's trained, etc. is bound to abuse the privilege). Why the fuck do you need a gun in the first place? This isn't the wild west. We have a police force.

If you want to engage in sport shooting or hunting, fine. But the right to bear arms like in the U.S. seems like an anachronistic concept.

Another uninformed strawman. Gun laws in such states as Illinois, Connecticut, New Jersey and New York State are actually as, if not more restrictive than in Canada. The only difference is the authority to carry concealed, and those states don't give out permits like out of a cereal box.

The deterrence effect in the US is not theory nor illusion. It is based on statistical fact. You deny the effect of deterrence, yet that is precisely the main reason why police officers carry firearms, albeit openly: not to kill people, but to deter through the show of force.


Anybody authorized with a privilege has the potential to abuse it. But the overwhelming majority don't for the most part because they are responsible, and for those less responsible, because of the penalites incurred for breaking the law. You seem to base your objection on the impossibility of achieving 100% total compliance and safety just because you don't approve. But you don't apply that objection to any other regulatory regime: we don't ban cars just because there will always be car accidents and some irresponsible drivers. We don't ban parachute jumping because the odd parachutist makes a hole in the ground. Any regulatory system cannot achieve perfect compliance yet you seem to be applying it in this case, arbitrarily. In any regulatory system, there is residual risk that can never be eliminated.

As far as having a police force, the police cannot be at every doorstep to protect each citizen. That's why the Criminal Code of Canada allows self defence, up to lethal force when justified. Dialing 911 is not in the Criminal Code of Canada. It is not the main job of police to protect citizens, except through deterrence through the judicial system. They cannot be everywhere at the same time.
 
GameBoy27 hit every nail on the head in regards to HeyHey's comments. Bravo!

I do think that we'd get more problems by having guns than without them.
 
BTW, it is illegal to carry bear spray in Canada unless you can justify having it with you, such as on a hiking trail. You could be arrested otherwise for carrying a concealed and prohibited weapon. That is a weapons charge, the same as carrying a handgun without authorization and a license.

http://www.vancouversun.com/news/Va...s+carrying+bear+spray+city/8048471/story.html

Your news example is of a robbery were bear repellent was used, yes, that is illegal. Think postal workers carry dog repellent. If stopped by police, can say you deliver flyers and are worried about dogs, something like that. You can also wear a bullet proof vest. But you don't, you want a gun. So, have to wonder if you are really worried about protection, or if you just think it would make you feel somehow superior to carry a gun.

I would rather not have the general public carrying guns because the number of accidents would go up. The number of disputes that would normally be settled with a shouting match, being settled with a gun would go up. If the crime rate was higher here, and there were many incidents where someone could have saved their life if they were carrying a gun, I would have no issues with people carrying guns. However, in the Toronto area, there are few if any incidents were someone could have saved their life if they were carrying a gun.

There are over 230 handgun clubs in Ontario, and many of their members shoot hundreds of rounds each week-end, far more than the usual minimum 50 rounds a year for most municipal police officers (except police officers who are also sports shooters) .

Most people join a gun club to get their gun license, never to be seen again. It would be a lower percentage of members who show up and practice every weekend.
 
Your news example is of a robbery were bear repellent was used, yes, that is illegal. Think postal workers carry dog repellent. If stopped by police, can say you deliver flyers and are worried about dogs, something like that. You can also wear a bullet proof vest. But you don't, you want a gun. So, have to wonder if you are really worried about protection, or if you just think it would make you feel somehow superior to carry a gun.

I would rather not have the general public carrying guns because the number of accidents would go up. The number of disputes that would normally be settled with a shouting match, being settled with a gun would go up. If the crime rate was higher here, and there were many incidents where someone could have saved their life if they were carrying a gun, I would have no issues with people carrying guns. However, in the Toronto area, there are few if any incidents were someone could have saved their life if they were carrying a gun.



Most people join a gun club to get their gun license, never to be seen again. It would be a lower percentage of members who show up and practice every weekend.

Who would pay for a license, membership fees, att and then never show up again?
Kinda like buying a car, getting it insured just to never drive it again.
 
The gun club I've been to was full and since I was not a member I had to come back another day to use the gun range. The only way to reserve any shooting time is to become a member. They are SO BUSY that they've temporarily shut down to do renovations and to expand the number of shooting bay available to their clients.
 
The gun club I've been to was full and since I was not a member I had to come back another day to use the gun range. The only way to reserve any shooting time is to become a member. They are SO BUSY that they've temporarily shut down to do renovations and to expand the number of shooting bay available to their clients.

Yup, I wish more gun owners would stay at home so I wouldn't have to wait for a stall at the club. I also wish most of them wouldn't register and show up for IPSC, SR, CQB, precision match etc events so there wouldn't be a frigging standby list.
 
I would rather not have the general public carrying guns because the number of accidents would go up. The number of disputes that would normally be settled with a shouting match, being settled with a gun would go up. If the crime rate was higher here, and there were many incidents where someone could have saved their life if they were carrying a gun, I would have no issues with people carrying guns. However, in the Toronto area, there are few if any incidents were someone could have saved their life if they were carrying a gun.

Your fears have already been unfounded. 5% of the US population now actively and legally carry concealed and there has not been any notable increase in irresponsible use, including settling disputes with a gun, contrary to those who feared the worst before concealed carry became federal law in the US 12 years ago. That's because they don't issue licenses to irresponsible persons and because it's still illegal to use a firearm in such a manner. A single felony in the US is enough for a person to earn a lifetime firearms ban.

The issue of whether there would be real benefit to concealed carry in Canada is a different matter. The matter at hand here is whether the hysteria about the perils of concealed carry are justified. They are not.
 
Most people join a gun club to get their gun license, never to be seen again. It would be a lower percentage of members who show up and practice every weekend.

You don't need to join a club to get a firearms license. You just have to take a course given by an approved firearms instructor and pass the written and practical test, then wait 40 days for the RCMP to issue the license, assuming that you pass the background checks.

Then, to be able to own a handgun, you have to first join a club, but joining isn't so easy as many have waiting lists, and then yearly membership fees are now typically over $300 a year, and sometimes $500. Once you join a club, only then will the OPP allow the transfer of a handgun to you. But you can't shoot it yet because you have to undergo the club's training course, accompanied by shooting under supervision using a club or instructor's handgun for typically 6 sessions. Then, the club applies to the OPP for an Authorization to Transport for you, and it is valid only as long as you are a member of the club. Sounds like a lot of trouble to just have a handgun locked up in a safe in a basement.

Legal handgun ownership in Canada has nothing to do with the general public. Concealed Carry would be even more stringent. Far from being a free-for-all.
 
I know someone who knew one of the guys and he attended his funeral yesterday. As much as I believe the guard was in the right, it is still sad that two lives were lost.
 
Who would pay for a license, membership fees, att and then never show up again?
Kinda like buying a car, getting it insured just to never drive it again.

Would be similar to gym memberships, the clubs expect that a low percentage of the members will actually show up to use the facility. A gun club might have a hand gun use course for 20 people at a time, few would be weekly shooters 3-4 months after the course. If all the members did show up, the club would be flooded with people.

The issue of whether there would be real benefit to concealed carry in Canada is a different matter. The matter at hand here is whether the hysteria about the perils of concealed carry are justified. They are not.

Guess that is the question. I hear of few if any local situations in the news where someone could have save their or other lives if only they had a gun. However, if there are more ready guns floating around, there is a real risk of accidents, kids getting the guns and shooting themselves or a friend, drunk guys showing off their guns and shooting a buddy, etc. Happens all the time.
 
Except the "happens all the time" inference isn't actually supported by statistical data.

Don't know what statistics you want. There are risks of accidents when there are ready guns floating around, and in our local area, there are no potential rewards of having people's lives saved by having ready guns in people's hands.

http://www.nydailynews.com/life-sty...7-000-u-s-kids-yearly-study-article-1.1592703

Can you post a local article that gives examples of all the lives that would be saved if only people were carrying loaded handguns?
 
I mean exactly what I say, show us evidence of it happening "all the time", because saying it over and over again without any evidence doesn't make it anymore true.

7,000 in a population of 300 million? That's like 0.0023% hardly "all the time".
 
I mean exactly what I say, show us evidence of it happening "all the time", because saying it over and over again without any evidence doesn't make it anymore true.

7,000 in a population of 300 million? That's like 0.0023% hardly "all the time".


Did you read the article? Another 3,000 kids did not make it to the ER. 10,000 kids per year are injured or killed. This does not include adults who are accidently injured or killed with guns. Ok, I will substitute "all the time" with "daily". This is the risk side, waiting for you to post some local info that shows there is some reward side to allowing people to carry guns in public. Btw, I have no issues if you want to carry your gun around in your home, just incase there is a home invasion.
 
Compare that to 2.5 million defensive gun uses.

https://www.saf.org/wp-content/uploads/journals/JFPP11.pdf

That is an US stat. If I lived in the US, I might also carry a gun.

In Canada we have about 500 murders per year, with the bulk if it is anything like the GTA, being gang related. With the odd bystander caught in the crossfire, and the odd lady killed as a victim of domestic violence. Maybe ladies should be able to take a course and carry guns.

You want to introduce the availability of loaded ready to use guns in Canada, increasing the risk of accidental shootings, when there is little if any reward side.
 
Again this unfound assumption that risk just magically goes up by some arbitrary percentage, without any evidence to back it up does nothing to support your argument. Canada has mandatory safety courses to obtain a firearms license, people have to be trained to be licensed, they also must not have criminal records. How does increasing the percentage of the most law abiding citizens, who don't pose a threat to public safety in the first place, increase risk?