Does Fuji speak for you?

Does Fuji speak for you?

  • Fuji Speaks for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%
  • Fuji does not speak for me

    Votes: 16 50.0%

  • Total voters
    32
  • Poll closed .
Because despite the conflicts Gaza is still part of Palestine and the PA is still the legal authority.

No, Israel is the occupying power and the one fully responsible for the wellbeing of all they occupy.
Geneva convention, remember?
 
No, Israel is the occupying power and the one fully responsible for the wellbeing of all they occupy.
Geneva convention, remember?

Which Israel has done by creating the Palestinian Authority and delegating certain responsibilities it. The Palestinian Authority then buys electricity and water from Israel.

But if the Palestinian Authority ceases to follow instruction from Israel then either the occupation is over and the PA is in control, or the PA is illegally defying the lawful occupier. Either way, no reason why Israel should give it money.
 
Which Israel has done by creating the Palestinian Authority and delegating certain responsibilities it. The Palestinian Authority then buys electricity and water from Israel.

But if the Palestinian Authority ceases to follow instruction from Israel then either the occupation is over and the PA is in control, or the PA is illegally defying the lawful occupier. Either way, no reason why Israel should give it money.

Israel created the Palestinian Authority? That's hysterical. Do you know even the most basic facts about this conflict?
 
Then by all means show us the source that confirms that Israel created it.

http://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/15AF20B2F7F41905852560A7004AB2D5

"Israel shall transfer authority as specified in this Agreement from the Israeli military government and its Civil Administration to the Palestinian Authority, hereby established, in accordance with Article V of this Agreement, except for the authority that Israel shall continue to exercise as specified in this Agreement."

The PA was established when the Knesset ratified that agreement. The PA has no other legal basis than this act of the Knesset.
 
http://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/15AF20B2F7F41905852560A7004AB2D5

"Israel shall transfer authority as specified in this Agreement from the Israeli military government and its Civil Administration to the Palestinian Authority, hereby established, in accordance with Article V of this Agreement, except for the authority that Israel shall continue to exercise as specified in this Agreement."

The PA was established when the Knesset ratified that agreement. The PA has no other legal basis than this act of the Knesset.

You really need to learn the basic facts about the Middle East. The Palestinian Authority was created in Tunis on October 10 and 11, 1993.

"Following the signing of the Declaration of Principles, the Palestine Central Council, acting on behalf of the PNC, convened in Tunis on 10-11 October 1993. In that meeting, the Council endorsed the Oslo Agreement and resolved to establish the Palestinian Authority ('PA'), nominated Yasser Arafat to be the president of the PA and authorized him to select its members. The PA was made accountable to the PL0 Executive Committee."

Page 48
http://www.icj-cij.org/docket/files/131/1555.pdf

Sorry to do this to you again, but you are used to being slow on the uptake.
 
No one in Tunis had any power or authority to invest in the PA. Israel, as the lawful occupier, was the one that actually gave it legitimacy and power.

Whether or not you like it.
 
No one in Tunis had any power or authority to invest in the PA. Israel, as the lawful occupier, was the one that actually gave it legitimacy and power.

Whether or not you like it.

Unfortunately the historical record confirms that the PA was created in Tunis by the Palestinian Central Council. This is independent of you and I.
 
It wasn't.. The Oslo Accords were signed on 13 September 1993 between the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) and Israel. The Gaza–Jericho Agreement was signed on 4 May 1994 and detailed the creation of the Palestinian Authority.[26] This was an interim organization created to administer a limited form of Palestinian self-governance in the Palestinian territories for a period of five years during which final-status negotiations would take place. The first meeting was held there, but that does not mean it was created there.
 
Unfortunately the historical record confirms that the PA was created in Tunis by the Palestinian Central Council. This is independent of you and I.

Your own quote says that Tunis meeting was in response to the Oslo agreement you blithering twit.

Israel, as the occupying power, is the ultimate authority in Gaza and the West Bank for the time being. Any power exercised there is ultimately delegated by the Knesset.
 
Your own quote says that Tunis meeting was in response to the Oslo agreement you blithering twit.

Israel, as the occupying power, is the ultimate authority in Gaza and the West Bank for the time being. Any power exercised there is ultimately delegated by the Knesset.

Unfortunately the historical record confirms that the PA was created in Tunis by the Palestinian Central Council. Not in the Knesset. Not by Israel. By the Palestinians.
 
Here's some historical record for you, since you seem to not know of what you speak. The Palestinian Authority was formed in 1994, pursuant to the Oslo Accords between the Palestine Liberation Organization (PLO) and the government of Israel, as a five-year interim body. Further negotiations were then meant to take place between the two parties regarding its final status. As of 2013, more than eighteen years following the formulation of the Authority, this status has yet to be reached.
 
...as a five-year interim body. Further negotiations were then meant to take place between the two parties regarding its final status. As of 2013, more than eighteen years following the formulation of the Authority, this status has yet to be reached.

If a 5 year interim body is in its 20th year, I guess it makes sense that Abbas is in the 10th year of a 4 year term.
 
Unfortunately the historical record confirms that the PA was created in Tunis by the Palestinian Central Council. Not in the Knesset. Not by Israel. By the Palestinians.

Anyone reading this thread has seen that it was created by the Oslo process. You are just performing your stupid circus clown acts now because you don't know how to admit you were wrong.
 
The PA was established when the Knesset ratified that agreement. The PA has no other legal basis than this act of the Knesset.

I see that you are arguing that the PA is an Israeli creation.
Sounds like you think it already is a one state, just too bad that would make it very clearly apartheid.
 
I see that you are arguing that the PA is an Israeli creation.
Sounds like you think it already is a one state, just too bad that would make it very clearly apartheid.

Unless you want to claim that Israel is not the occupier, then the PA is an administrative unit of the Israeli occupation, legally speaking.

That does not mean the territory is part of Israel so don't start that idiotic nonsense again, but Israel is the lawful occupier and legally speaking the PA is one of the ways it governs the occupied territory.

As the occupier, Israel could also disband the PA and try something different. Replace it with some new directly elected administration that is not aded fucked as the PLO perhaps.
 
Anyone reading this thread has seen that it was created by the Oslo process. You are just performing your stupid circus clown acts now because you don't know how to admit you were wrong.

This is hysterical. First you claimed it was created by Israel. Then you said it was established by the Knesset. Now you have scurried back about 100 miles and now say it was just part of the Oslo Process. Let's review your capitulation:

Which Israel has done by creating the Palestinian Authority and delegating certain responsibilities it. The Palestinian Authority then buys electricity and water from Israel.

But if the Palestinian Authority ceases to follow instruction from Israel then either the occupation is over and the PA is in control, or the PA is illegally defying the lawful occupier. Either way, no reason why Israel should give it money.

Then you said this:

http://unispal.un.org/UNISPAL.NSF/0/15AF20B2F7F41905852560A7004AB2D5

"Israel shall transfer authority as specified in this Agreement from the Israeli military government and its Civil Administration to the Palestinian Authority, hereby established, in accordance with Article V of this Agreement, except for the authority that Israel shall continue to exercise as specified in this Agreement."

The PA was established when the Knesset ratified that agreement. The PA has no other legal basis than this act of the Knesset.

Now you are saying this:

Anyone reading this thread has seen that it was created by the Oslo process. You are just performing your stupid circus clown acts now because you don't know how to admit you were wrong.

As usual, you folded when challenged.

The PA was created in Tunis on Oct 11, 1993 by the Palestine Central Council.
 
Ratification of Oslo being the act of the Knesset that created the PA, yes.

Unfortunately, the the ICJ document confirms that the PA was created by the Palestine Central Council on Oct 11, 1993 in Tunis. It did not exist before the Palestinians created it.