Global Warming. Fact or grossly exaggerated??

Whats your opinion on global warming?

  • Its too late! We're all gonne bake, frie and die in a few years

    Votes: 44 30.1%
  • Its not as bad as scientists say. We got at least 100 to 200 years before shit hits the fan

    Votes: 33 22.6%
  • Its not real at all. Its a carbon credit money making scam

    Votes: 45 30.8%
  • Its all a big conspiracy MAN!!!

    Votes: 9 6.2%
  • Its way too cold in Canada, I wish it were real. Start up the SUV's

    Votes: 15 10.3%

  • Total voters
    146
  • Poll closed .
...

I didn't say they should keep quiet. They can speak about the findings. They can pursue research to find scientific solutions (something the researchers never seem to do, for obvious reasons). Indeed, if they really think this is an issue, that is exactly what they should be doing.

But they can't be advancing arguments to governments.....

So they shouldn't have to stay quiet but they shouldn't be talking to the government about it? Yeah that makes sense. I guess the scientists who studied nuclear radiation shouldn't have push for government regulation there either.


And yes, as was posted, just over 10,000 articles on climate and global warming last year and all but two agreed that humans are causing a great impact.

Also worth noting that scientists in other fields respect that the scientists who actually study climate know more about it than those who study quantum mechanics.

The scientific community as a whole has come to the conclusion that humans are causing significant problems for our climate and I would damn well hope they would speak out about the risks and what needs to be done. You can keep burying your head in the sand and believing there is some scientific conspiracy but that won't change the consensus.
 
I find it quite easy to determine how to divide the line.

The IPCC could be one of two things:

-- It could be an organization that plays a leading role in overseeing scientific research into the theory of global warming, producing research findings on a regular basis.

-- It could be an advocacy organization that works on behalf of the U.N. to get governments to implement changes that the U.N. believes are in mankind's best interests.

Unfortunately, the IPCC has tried to do both. As a result, it isn't credible as a scientific organization.

Scientific research and political agendas don't mix. Nothing good can come from politicized research.

It seems you are no longer denying the claims of the IPCC and the wider scientific community now, merely saying they shouldn't be publicizing the dangers they've discovered. That's a step forward. But who do you suggest the advocacy role should be taken over by?
 
It seems you are no longer denying the claims of the IPCC and the wider scientific community now, merely saying they shouldn't be publicizing the dangers they've discovered.

The IPCC's most recent report confirmed that the computer model projections had been spectacularly wrong. Regardless of the bumpf in the Summary for Policy Makers, the actual evidence published by the IPCC confirms that we don't know whether man-made carbon dioxide emissions affect the climate.

At no point have I been "denying" that.

As for your ever-increasing calculations of the number of researchers that you say support the theory, it's probably worth quoting Albert Einstein once again:

“Were I wrong, one professor would have been quite enough.”
 
quote_icon.png
Originally Posted by Albert Einstein

“Were I wrong, one professor would have been quite enough.”

Whatever that means. Not even sure he said it.
 
I find it quite easy to determine how to divide the line.

The IPCC could be one of two things:

-- It could be an organization that plays a leading role in overseeing scientific research into the theory of global warming, producing research findings on a regular basis.
.


But they don't act as advocates. In fact, the only climatologist that does this is Hansen, no others act as advocates.
You won't find them protesting, writing letters, paying off politicians or doing anything other doing the research and publishing their results.
You are not just wrong on this matter, but full of shit to keep pushing it.
 
What it means is that scientific theories should be based on evidence, not phony claims about large numbers of supporters or a "consensus."

Again, you are wrong.
The reason why there is a consensus is because all the available evidence supports the theories.
You can't supply any real evidence that disputes this, nor a single credible theory that suggests alternate rationales for the changes we are experiencing today.
The consensus is precisely because of the evidence.
 
But they don't act as advocates. In fact, the only climatologist that does this is Hansen, no others act as advocates.
You won't find them protesting, writing letters, paying off politicians or doing anything other doing the research and publishing their results.
You are not just wrong on this matter, but full of shit to keep pushing it.

I won't find the chair of the IPCC calling for governments to cut carbon emissions? Actually, I have found that:

http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2014/mar/07/floods-gales-un-climate-change-extreme-weather

Again, you are wrong.
The reason why there is a consensus is because all the available evidence supports the theories.

Nonsense. The most recent reports about a "consensus" calculated the volumes of papers on global warming that were apparently supportive (although some researchers themselves have disputed how their papers were assessed).

All that shows, one you get past the mathematical flim-flam, is that most public funding (and most of the research is publicly funded) goes to research that supports the agenda. It says nothing about evidence.

Indeed, claims of a "consensus" are consistently used as a substitute for evidence.

---

Last year, CNN's chief medical correspondent Sanjay Gupta publicly apologized for his previous positions on medical marijuana and said he now supports its use.

What was interesting was that he noted that while the overwhelming majority of recent papers on the subject claim that marijuana is harmful, the picture was distorted by the biases in the research funding.

A search through the U.S. National Library of Medicine this past year pulled up nearly 2,000 more recent papers. But the majority were research into the harm of marijuana, such as "Bad trip due to anticholinergic effect of cannabis," or "Cannabis induced pancreatitits" and "Marijuana use and risk of lung cancer."

In my quick running of the numbers, I calculated about 6% of the current U.S. marijuana studies investigate the benefits of medical marijuana. The rest are designed to investigate harm. That imbalance paints a highly distorted picture.

http://www.cnn.com/2013/08/08/health/gupta-changed-mind-marijuana/

He is right. When huge amounts of public funding are directed toward a desired research outcome, that can create a "highly distorted picture."

Just one of the many reasons why claims of a "consensus" are irrelevant.

The most important reason still goes back to Einstein: It only takes one scientist with the right evidence to demonstrate that a theory has merit or is false.
 
What it means is that scientific theories should be based on evidence, not phoney claims about large numbers of supporters or a "consensus."

The most reason example that shows how much you don't understand about scientific methods is the Higgs Boson.

In 1964 the 'theory' of a HB particle was put forward by R. Brout, F. Englert, P. Higgs, G. S. Guralnik, C. R. Hagen, and T. W. B. Kibble, even though the 'proof' wasn't discovered until 2014. The basis of the 'theory' was that in order for almost all 'theories' of particle physics to stand up was the existence of the HB..

Going any deeper into its 'theory' and discovery would seem to be futile since you don't even grasp simpler concepts of climate and meteorolgy. If any members far more versed in particle theory want to try and give MF2 insight, feel free.

Another example would be the research into the discovery of 'structure' of DNA. From http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method


Question: Previous investigation of DNA had determined its chemical composition (the four nucleotides), the structure of each individual nucleotide, and other properties. It had been identified as the carrier of genetic information by the Avery–MacLeod–McCarty experiment in 1944, but the mechanism of how genetic information was stored in DNA was unclear.

Hypothesis: Francis Crick and James D. Watson hypothesized that DNA had a helical structure.

Prediction:
If DNA had a helical structure, its X-ray diffraction pattern would be X-shaped. This prediction was determined using the mathematics of the helix transform, which had been derived by Cochran, Crick and Vand (and independently by Stokes).

Experiment:
Rosalind Franklin crystallized pure DNA and performed X-ray diffraction to produce photo 51. The results showed an X-shape.
Analysis: When Watson saw the detailed diffraction pattern, he immediately recognized it as a helix. He and Crick then produced their model, using this information along with the previously known information about DNA's composition and about molecular interactions such as hydrogen bonds.

A linearized, scheme of the four points above is sometimes offered as a guideline for proceeding;

Define a question

Gather information and resources (observe)

Form an explanatory hypothesis

Test the hypothesis by performing an experiment and collecting data in a reproducible manner

Analyze the data

Interpret the data and draw conclusions that serve as a starting point for new hypothesis

Publish results

Retest (frequently done by other scientists)




It has been much the same since the time of Plato, Euclid, and Aristotle.
 
Your example of marijuana is a bad one because much of the confusion and error comes from the the fact that 'medical marijuana' and the more popular social strains of it are different. Their effects and dangers are also different.

Again with the Einstein. Was he wrong on all his theories because someone proved one aspect of his Theory of Relativity.

From;http://av3ng3r.wordpress.com/2010/02/11/einsteins-theory-of-relativity-disproved/

Sudarshan Reddy has theoretically proven the existence of a subatomic particle, which can travel at speed greater than that of light, thereby challenging one of the fundamental postulates of the “Theory of Relativity”. In his recent research paper submitted to the Institute of Advanced Physics (IAP) at Trieste (Italy), Sudarshan has proved the existence of a class of subatomic particles called “leptons”,which can travel faster than light.
The international physics community is shocked by this discovery. Dr.Massimo Martelli, President of the IAP has this to say about the paper submitted by Sudarshan. “After long, careful and critical analysis, I can confidently say that Sudarshan’s re search papers show tremendous leap in our understanding of physics. His investigation mounts up on “leptons”. His work builds substantially on the work of Einstein and others in the field of relativity.”
When physicists from Princeton University tried to measure Sudarshan’s IQ with an IQmeter (at the American Embassy in Delhi),the meter broke down. Sudarshan, incidentally, is the brother of Madhu Reddy, the Indian whiz kid who developed an operating system superior to Microsoft Windows.

From; http://news.sky.com/story/884653/amazement-as-particles-beat-light-speed

Amazement As Particles 'Beat Light Speed'

Scientists from all over the world are examining the results of an experiment that seems to disprove one of the cornerstones of modern physics.
Experts at the European Organization for Nuclear Research (Cern) in Switzerland believe they have clocked particles called neutrinos travelling faster than the speed of light.
But they cannot quite believe it themselves, they say, because according to Einstein's famous 1905 equation, E=mc2, it is simply impossible.

"The feeling that most people have is this can't be right, this can't be real," said James Gillies, a spokesman for Cern.

According to Einstein, the speed of light, 186,282 miles per second (299,792km per second) is a "cosmic constant" and nothing in the universe can travel faster, because physical objects have a mass, whereas light does not.
Cern says a neutrino beam fired from a particle accelerator near Geneva to a lab 454 miles (730km) away in Italy arrived in a time that meant it had covered the distance 60 nanoseconds faster than the speed of light.
The claim has been met with a range of responses from scientists, with some expressing amazement while others dismissed it as a mistake.
"The feeling that most people have is this can't be right, this can't be real," said James Gillies, a spokesman for Cern.
He said the readings have so astounded researchers that they are asking others to independently verify the measurements before claiming an actual discovery.

"They are inviting the broader physics community to look at what they have done and really scrutinise it in great detail," he said.

Dr David Whitehouse, a space scientist and author, said that if the experiment is proved to be true then it would be a revelation on a par with Einstein's own theories.

"It is an earthquake, a revolution in physics," he said.

"As soon as you are arrogant enough to think you understand the universe, the universe comes along and shows you are not right."

Dr Whitehouse said the findings technically meant that time travel might be possible.

"Everything is now open - because time, speed and the speed of light are all linked."

However, one physicist based in Melbourne, Australia, concluded that the claim was simply the result of an error.
Dr John P Costella said the group at Cern had made an "embarrassing gaffe" by miscalculating the experiment's statistical uncertainty.

"One must conclude that (the team) has simply made a mistake, albeit a highly embarrassing one which has gathered international media coverage," he said.

University of Maryland physics department chairman Drew Baden called it "a flying carpet", something that was too fantastic to be believable.
Scientists at the competing Fermilab in Chicago have promised to try to replicate the results.

"It is a shock," said Fermilab head theoretician Stephen Parke, who was not part of the research in Geneva.

"It is going to cause us problems, no doubt about that - if it is true."

The Chicago team had similar faster-than-light results in 2007, but those came with a giant margin of error that undercut its scientific significance.
 
Your example of marijuana is a bad one because much of the confusion and error comes from the the fact that 'medical marijuana' and the more popular social strains of it are different. Their effects and dangers are also different
You mean Sativa vs. Indica??
 
Your example of marijuana is a bad one because much of the confusion and error comes from the the fact that 'medical marijuana' and the more popular social strains of it are different. Their effects and dangers are also different.

For the purposes of this discussion, you missed the point in the highlighted quote.

Dr. Gupta's view is that most of the papers -- the "consensus", if you like -- showed marijuana to be harmful because that's what the people paying for the research wanted to hear.

That's what happens when scientific research becomes politicized, as is the case with global warming -- you get a "highly distorted picture" that has no credibility.

The IPCC preaches solely to the converted. It has jumped the shark and should be replaced with a new body that has a mandate to look at the science.
 
For the purposes of this discussion, you missed the point in the highlighted quote.

Dr. Gupta's view is that most of the papers -- the "consensus", if you like -- showed marijuana to be harmful because that's what the people paying for the research wanted to hear.

That's what happens when scientific research becomes politicized, as is the case with global warming -- you get a "highly distorted picture" that has no credibility.

The IPCC preaches solely to the converted. It has jumped the shark and should be replaced with a new body that has a mandate to look at the science.

That's what 'can' happen, but it isn't a certainty nor a prevalence.

The IPCC breaches to the converted? As shown earlier the unconverted is a reeeeeeeeeeeeeeeally small number and many of them are bought and paid for by the political right.
 
As shown earlier the unconverted is a reeeeeeeeeeeeeeeally small number and many of them are bought and paid for by the political right.

You're wrong, but I'll wait to see whether basketcase is still peddling his "conspiracy theory" foolishness before I address the point in more detail.
 
Wrong about what?

Wrong in believing that the unconverted is a small number.

While we wait to see whether this point needs to be examined in more detail, it's worth checking out this piece by Matt Gurney that appeared in the National Post a few days before the release of the IPCC's fifth assessment report. It speaks quite well to the IPCC's credibility problems.

http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com...oure-right-in-the-end-if-no-one-believes-you/

The lesson here isn’t that global warming isn’t happening or that we’re not the cause. I’m still not qualified to rule on that point. But I am qualified to offer a small piece of advice to climate change experts who sincerely believe it is happening, that we’re the cause and that it will be devastating: You need to make your case better, without the alarmism that can be so quickly proven wrong. Yes, alarmism sells, and it’s hard to get the media’s attention without it. But alarmism, once proven to be bogus, destroys credibility just as effectively as it sells papers and motivates politicians. I would not invest my money with someone who got the stock market as wrong as the IPCC has gotten Earth’s climate wrong since 2007.

It won’t do anyone — including, incidentally, humanity as a whole — any good if scientists are right about the long run but cry wolf one too many times in the near term.

I go much further than Mr. Gurney. I say it's too late to save the IPCC. It should be abolished.

If a new body is needed to coordinate the research at an international level, it should be created with a strict emphasis on science. No politicians, diplomats, environmentalists, etc. should be allowed in.
 
Wrong in believing that the unconverted is a small number.

While we wait to see whether this point needs to be examined in more detail, it's worth checking out this piece by Matt Gurney that appeared in the National Post a few days before the release of the IPCC's fifth assessment report. It speaks quite well to the IPCC's credibility problems.

http://fullcomment.nationalpost.com...oure-right-in-the-end-if-no-one-believes-you/



I go much further than Mr. Gurney. I say it's too late to save the IPCC. It should be abolished.

If a new body is needed to coordinate the research at an international level, it should be created with a strict emphasis on science. No politicians, diplomats, environmentalists, etc. should be allowed in.

You hilighted post starts off really well by putting forward and absurd notion that no one will believe the climatologists, as we've clearly shown differently, and goes downhill from there.

Did you actually read the article?

But I can say this — the notion that human industrial activity is causing our planet to warm up is completely plausible. Even if the exact process and likely outcome of such warming remains to be seen, most reasonable people would probably agree with the following declaration: That human industrial activity does release unintended byproducts in sufficient quantities to alter the planet’s atmosphere, and such alterations could potentially change the planet’s natural weather patterns and processes. That’s not a hard thing to accept.

He then bases acceptance on the information from the last IPCC meeting, even after we've shown so much more new data has been examined since.

then we have this.

The irony, of course, is that it’s entirely possible that 100 years from now, virtually everything that was predicted to occur will have occurred, and mankind will be living on a very different, generally less hospitable, planet. With the benefit of hindsight, the variance between projections and reality seen over the last 20 years or so may seem like small beer. But in the here and now, it’s getting increasingly difficult even for those who know little about climate science to take anything the experts say without a heaping spoonful of salt. People like me, without any particular expertise but an open mind and an overall interest in civilization not collapsing, have been told that climate change would manifest obvious effects in the short term and devastating ones in the long term. But the obvious, short-term effects are MIA. If the experts were wrong about that, why should we believe they’re right about long term?
 
Yes, I did read the article. You missed the point. Whether the long-term projections are plausible not, the point of the article was that the IPCC has a huge credibility problem.

As I said, I would go further.

There is no room for political participation in science. Thus, the IPCC's reputation cannot be salvaged. It should be scrapped. If an international body is needed, one should be created that is focused solely on science.