Global Warming. Fact or grossly exaggerated??

Whats your opinion on global warming?

  • Its too late! We're all gonne bake, frie and die in a few years

    Votes: 44 30.1%
  • Its not as bad as scientists say. We got at least 100 to 200 years before shit hits the fan

    Votes: 33 22.6%
  • Its not real at all. Its a carbon credit money making scam

    Votes: 45 30.8%
  • Its all a big conspiracy MAN!!!

    Votes: 9 6.2%
  • Its way too cold in Canada, I wish it were real. Start up the SUV's

    Votes: 15 10.3%

  • Total voters
    146
  • Poll closed .
Question gents:

I'm on an email distribution list that includes Americans. You have too camps which are politically polarized as opposed to basing arguments on pure science.

RW argues that CO2 levels are single digit percentages from human sources. This is too low to account for AGW. I argue that maybe single digits percentage compositions is enough to tip the scales when it comes to the Greenhouse Effect. What is the sensitivity of that is the big question.

Anyone?

BTW, is there any truth that other planets within our solar system are getting hotter too?
 
Question gents:

I'm on an email distribution list that includes Americans. You have too camps which are politically polarized as opposed to basing arguments on pure science.

RW argues that CO2 levels are single digit percentages from human sources. This is too low to account for AGW. I argue that maybe single digits percentage compositions is enough to tip the scales when it comes to the Greenhouse Effect. What is the sensitivity of that is the big question.

Anyone?

BTW, is there any truth that other planets within our solar system are getting hotter too?

It's not just the CO2 levels. It's all the other crap that is being released into air and water that causes further failure. Fertilizers are being released into Lake Erie, that is make it anoxic, give rise to algae, killing fish, and keeping the water from being getting too hot to mitigate temperature fluctuations on land and in the air, effecting rainfall cycles.
 
Last edited:
It's not just the CO2 levels. It's all the other crap that is being released on to air and water that causes failure. Fertilizers are being released into Lake Erie, that is make it anoxic, give rise to algae, killing fish, and keeping the water from being getting too hot to mitigate temperature fluctuations on land and in the air, effecting rainfall cycles.

Thanks. Keep it coming!
 
No, we dont know what caused the arctic ice decrease. Couldve been part of a natural cycle, or it couldve been manmade. I just find it interesting that with so many more CO2's in the air, somehow arctic ice increased 50% over the previous year

It could have been the elves at the north pole working too hard but we do know that CO2 is up, Arctic temperature is up, and ice cover is down. We also know CO2 is a greenhouse gas and we know precisely the physics of how the CO2 molecule traps infrared radiation. Combined with a clear pattern of increasing surface and water temperature over the past many decades, it makes a clear scientific case. If you have a better theory, try backing it up with some evidence instead of 'what ifs'.
 
I may not have the lingo right, but in plain English, it's the setting of clear standards for evidence that would prove the theory is false.....

Quick lesson on the nature of science.

There is no such thing is science as proving a previously accepted theory wrong. What science looks for is to replace it with a BETTER theory. Unless you can do that, the theories and predictions about climate change are still the best scientific explanations. You can hum and haw all you want about them not being perfect but that doesn't change how science works.
 
surfacetemp2010.gif


ipcc_anom_1901-2012.png


proxy-based_temperature_rec.png


anthropogenic_natural_chg.gif


http://nsidc.org/cryosphere/sotc/intro.html

Of course if you don't believe the science from yet another source, the facts won't matter
 
There is no such thing is science as proving a previously accepted theory wrong. What science looks for is to replace it with a BETTER theory. Unless you can do that, the theories and predictions about climate change are still the best scientific explanations. You can hum and haw all you want about them not being perfect but that doesn't change how science works.

"No amount of experimentation can ever prove me right; a single experiment can prove me wrong.” - Quote attributed to Albert Einstein.

http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/51573-no-amount-of-experimentation-can-ever-prove-me-right-a

I would quibble with your definition of the theory of global warming as an "accepted" theory, given that it isn't currently supported by evidence.

As for the rest of your points, I don't know how you think the theory could be replaced through scientific means when the researchers have refused to make the methodology and data available, when predictions aren't required to have any reliability, and when all observed facts -- regardless of what they are -- are treated as supporting evidence of the theory. It's not clear that there are any facts that would be accepted by the climate researchers as ones that would disprove the theory.

Finally, you are entitled to your views, but please stop misrepresenting mine. I didn't say the predictions were guilty of "not being perfect." I said they were spectacularly wrong. No one would think that's the same thing.

---

The 15 year was a guideline, not a hard and fast rule.

Actually, what Phil Jones said was: "Bottom line: the 'no upward trend' has to continue for a total of 15 years before we get worried."

I don't have time to go looking for the original Climategate email but I'm pretty sure it can be found online if someone really wants to see it.

What I find interesting is that Jones (in his private exchanges) was OK with using short-term periods to assess the computer-model predictions. These days, that seems to be heresy (for obvious reasons).

---

I gave you three supporting and independent studies backing up my claim and you have nothing.
You lose.

And now the coup de grace. Let's take another look at Groggy's so-called "science."

I already proved the Cook report on the 97 per cent "consensus" was a load of crap. In the weakest attempt ever to defend himself, Groggy responded (in post 357) by claiming the original source was Doran, 2009. He then proceeded to taunt me by claiming I had lost the debate about the "consensus" numbers.

Never mind the fact that science isn't determined by "consensus" (as I have repeatedly told him). Let's take a closer look at Doran. This will be easier to rip apart than the Cook study.

Here is the actual report: http://tigger.uic.edu/~pdoran/012009_Doran_final.pdf

Let's begin with the statistics. The survey was sent to 10,257 Earth scientists. Yet, as is made clear in the third column of the first page, only about 3,100 people responded and the results were broken down further so that the so-called "consensus" numbers come from an analysis of just 77 responses. Seventy-seven from a starting point of more than 10,000!

Even worse, look at the questions that were asked (also on the third column of the first page). Quoted directly:

1. When compared with pre-1800s levels, do you think that mean global temperatures have generally risen, fallen, or remained relatively constant?
2. Do you think human activity is a significant contributing factor in changing mean global temperatures?

The second question is the one that is so damning. It only asks about "human activity." Humans are engaged in all kinds of activities -- ie, cutting down large forests, building huge cities, etc. -- that go far beyond the release of man-made carbon dioxide emissions.

Pretty much everyone -- including me -- believes that man's existence on the planet affects the climate (although not necessarily in alarming ways). Whether you believe man-made carbon dioxide emissions affect the climate in any significant way is a completely different question.

The survey never asked the scientists about anything related to the theory of anthropogenic global warming, and the results were reduced to such a tiny level that they became statistically insignificant.

The survey is total rubbish.

Doran's paper is political propaganda, and nothing more. No one who knows about science or believes in good science would ever have cited such an atrocious piece of propaganda.

That leads to the inconvenient truth: Groggy knows nothing about science.

No other conclusion is possible.
 
"No amount of experimentation can ever prove me right; a single experiment can prove me wrong.” - Quote attributed to Albert Einstein.

http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/51573-no-amount-of-experimentation-can-ever-prove-me-right-a

I would quibble with your definition of the theory of global warming as an "accepted" theory, given that it isn't currently supported by evidence.

As for the rest of your points, I don't know how you think the theory could be replaced through scientific means when the researchers have refused to make the methodology and data available, when predictions aren't required to have any reliability, and when all observed facts -- regardless of what they are -- are treated as supporting evidence of the theory. It's not clear that there are any facts that would be accepted by the climate researchers as ones that would disprove the theory.

Finally, you are entitled to your views, but please stop misrepresenting mine. I didn't say the predictions were guilty of "not being perfect." I said they were spectacularly wrong. No one would think that's the same thing.

No other conclusion is possible.

No quite sure what you're trying to say withe the quote.

Science is not "things." It is a way of thinking. Classical Scientific Method is simply a method for objectively applying logic to the solution of problems.
1) The problem must be stated in clear terms, and obscure words must be defined clearly. The goal sought must also be stated clearly.


2) Everything known about the problem must be studied, and all references must be acknowledged. There must be no "hidden facts," and it is not clever to "blindside" the opposition. Carefully planned observations should be made. Different methods of observation should be made when possible, and results must be checked for internal consistency and agreement with reported results
All observations must be taken seriously, until some justifiable and clearly stated reason can be found to eliminate any.


3) A "brainstorming" session, preferably with other workers familiar with the problem, should try to develop as many potential explanations (hypotheses) as possible (Method of Multiple Working Hypotheses), All hypotheses must be clearly stated. And


4), all of the hypotheses must be tested equally against the same, complete list of observations and facts. Testing may often involve making predictions on the basis of the hypotheses and testing the predictions by experiment. The Principle of Parsimony (Occam's Razor) states that the hypothesis that includes the largest number of facts and observations will be closest to the truth. Hypotheses that do not accept many facts without "special pleading" should be discarded.


R.N. Rogers

Here are the five axioms or assumptions that must be made for the scientific method to function reliably. These assumptions are unprovable via the scientific method.


The world is real.
The real world is knowable and comprehensible.
There are laws that govern the real world.
Those laws are knowable and comprehensible.
Those laws don't [radically] change according to place or time, since the early stages of the big bang.


from the Graham Kendall
 
You mean you did get your father to read the footnote of death for you? Or did you get someone from the heartland institute to give you a ready made talking point?
No, I did something much better, groggy. Lets go through our 2 posts again:

I read it over more carefully this time, and here's the footnote in a nutshell:

When it comes down to global temperatures, everything hinges on the control runs and inherent natural variability of the global coupled climate models. The TAR showed multi-model results for future changes in climate, however since the TAR is an unprecedented internationally coordinated climate change experiment thats been performed by over 23 models from around the world, you tend to get a variable output of surface temperatures versus atmospheric temperatures.

If you then use a mean average of both, you should get an oscillated output, which will give a more accurate global temperature reading. The TAR noted that much of the regional variation of the annual mean warming in the multi-model means is associated with high- to low-latitude contrast. But since you're oscillating both surface temperatures versus atmospheric temperatures, you will get a better model mean in terms of zonal averages


Not bad, you got most of it but still missed the relevant bit for the bet.
Maybe there's hope for you yet
I got most of it, you say??! Ha ha ha.

What I did was groggy, I just put a bunch of sentences together to make them sound scientific, except they were not. They were complete bullshit!! All I did was fuse a bunch of paragraphs together from that same website where you got your footnote from, plus I added some stuff I just made up.

I dont even know WTF I wrote to be honest, and you fell for it, hook line and sinker. That tells me you have no fucking clue what you're talking about. Whats even more worrisome is you werent smart enough to catch on to my ruse. Even when I gave you a hint in my next post.

Thanks for playing though :biggrin1:


EDIT: now lets see how groggy is gonna bullshit his way out of this one
 
"No amount of experimentation can ever prove me right; a single experiment can prove me wrong.” - Quote attributed to Albert Einstein.

http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/51573-no-amount-of-experimentation-can-ever-prove-me-right-a

I would quibble with your definition of the theory of global warming as an "accepted" theory, given that it isn't currently supported by evidence.....

As I said, if you have a theory that better explains the observed pattern of increasing temperatures you should publish it instead of trying to pretend the predictions are 'spectacularly wrong'.
 
As I said, if you have a theory that better explains the observed pattern of increasing temperatures you should publish it instead of trying to pretend the predictions are 'spectacularly wrong'.

I'm not pretending anything. It is what it is.

Furthermore, I'm puzzled by your challenge: Are you saying that all of the changes to the climate that have ever occurred on the planet were caused by man-made CO2 emissions?
 
Gtemps480.jpg
 
Thanks. Keep it coming!

And don't forget the positive forcings or feedback. For instance, much has been written lately about how much more energy is being absorbed by a darker, non-reflective and not icy Arctic ocean vs a white and reflective ice coated one. Warmer arctic oceans mean they are also absorbing more heat. The oceans have also been absorbing vast amounts of CO2, increasing their acidity and putting all shellfish and coral at some risk.
 
Doran's paper is political propaganda, and nothing more. No one who knows about science or believes in good science would ever have cited such an atrocious piece of propaganda..

Great, so now we can also count statistics as another area of study where you know nothing.

If you would like to talk margins of errors vs poll size and web surveys vs other methods, we can talk details.
But as of now it really sounds like you know about as little about stats as you climatology.
 

Hey, that's a good one.

Cliff Harris?
Insurance salesman trying to pretend he's a climatologist?

Talk about idiotic posts.
Do you really think that graph is legit?

If this is a good example of what you think the science is, I think you really are way, way out of your league.

Loser.
 
I'm not pretending anything. It is what it is.

Furthermore, I'm puzzled by your challenge: Are you saying that all of the changes to the climate that have ever occurred on the planet were caused by man-made CO2 emissions?

Where did I say that?


And it's not 'my challenge', it is the way science works. The current models of climate change and the role played by human activity are the best scientific explanation available. If you have a better one, put it forth.

Fact is that no one in the scientific community has been able to put forward a theory that better matches the evidence.
 
Great, so now we can also count statistics as another area of study where you know nothing.

If you would like to talk margins of errors vs poll size and web surveys vs other methods, we can talk details.
But as of now it really sounds like you know about as little about stats as you climatology.

Now, you're defending the worst kind of propaganda? How sad.

If you have a better one, put it forth.

Sure. The climate changes the same way the climate has always changed.
 
No, I did something much better, groggy. Lets go through our 2 posts again:
I got most of it, you say??! Ha ha ha.

What I did was groggy, I just put a bunch of sentences together to make them sound scientific, except they were not. They were complete bullshit!! All I did was fuse a bunch of paragraphs together from that same website where you got your footnote from, plus I added some stuff I just made up.

I dont even know WTF I wrote to be honest, and you fell for it, hook line and sinker. That tells me you have no fucking clue what you're talking about. Whats even more worrisome is you werent smart enough to catch on to my ruse. Even when I gave you a hint in my next post.

Thanks for playing though :biggrin1:

That's why I said you got some of it but missed the point, next time I'll less kind and take you to task on every error.


It does confirm a couple of things though.
a) you really aren't smart enough to understand the science.
b) I skim your posts.
c) Your posts are filled with bullshit, but I will still be more diligent reading them next time. I admit I let some bullshit get past me.

But yes, you still don't understand the footnote nor why its relevant to the argument.