Gawker Claims Video Exists of Rob Ford Smoking Crack

Being sceptical isn't kooky.

When you are skeptical of claims that a diet pill will help you lose 90lbs in two weeks, or claims that major newspapers wholesale make up stories, it isn't kooky.

When you you are skeptical of claims the earth is round, or just outright disbelieve the news claiming not merely that the facts are wrong, but that the news is completely made up -- you're a kook.
 
Pretty good for business and political agendas, though. Not so kooky.

They would sell even more papers if they ran a front page headline stating that earth was being invaded by giant death robots, but I don't know how many more newspapers they would sell the day after that. News media have a strong interest in maintaining a reputation for integrity. They do not just make up the news.
 
News media have a strong interest in maintaining a reputation for integrity. They do not just make up the news
Bullshit. I can give you a few examples right off the bat
 
Bullshit. I can give you a few examples right off the bat

Go for it -- cite some front page headline news stories that were completely fabricated by mainstream newspapers. Not just a few facts wrong, wholesale made it up, the way that some on this thread are claiming that the Star just made up a story about seeing a video when no video actually exists and their reporters never actually saw one.
 
Go for it -- cite some front page headline news stories that were completely fabricated by mainstream newspapers. Not just a few facts wrong, wholesale made it up, the way that some on this thread are claiming that the Star just made up a story about seeing a video when no video actually exists and their reporters never actually saw one
I can give you 2 US examples right now. You'll have to give me a few days to search for Canadian ones, but I'm sure they exist. In fact I know they do, because I vaguely remember one explicit one (will post later).

Here's the first American bullshit story, completely fabricated by NBC's dateline:

http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,305709,00.html

'Dateline' Disaster

It was a story that literally blew up in NBC's face. On Nov. 17, Dateline NBC aired a report titled ''Waiting to Explode?'' questioning the safety of some General Motors trucks. To try to ensure dramatic footage, the show's producers allowed incendiary devices to be strapped to trucks for a crash-test demonstration. When GM discovered the setup, the carmaker sued NBC for defamation and temporarily removed its ads from the network's news programs. Then came the ultimate embarrassment: Dateline anchors Jane Pauley and Stone Phillips were ordered to read a 3.5-minute on-air apology to viewers and GM.

In a statement to his staff, NBC News president Michael Gartner said, ''The best thing to do when we make a mistake is to admit it.'' But not everyone at . the network was satisfied. ''They gave Jane Pauley, who's never done anything wrong in her life, the lead role in the apology,'' one NBC correspondent says. Adds an NBC News producer, ''If I were Jane, I would have no more read that f---ing apology than I would have jumped in front of a semitrailer. She had no connection with the story.''

The incident was the most devastating in a series of ugly controversies that has seriously damaged the reputation of third-place NBC News over the last few years. ''When they read that apology, everyone who has ever been associated with that place was embarrassed,'' says former NBC News president Reuven Frank. ''Morale is in the toilet,'' adds a veteran NBC producer. ''Most people who've been here a while feel there's nobody at the rudder.''

Some staffers blame Gartner — a former newspaperman hired in 1988 even though he had no background in TV news — for trying to satisfy parent company General Electric's bottom-line mentality by replacing veteran journalists with cheaper, less experienced reporters and producers. After GE took over the network in 1986, says one NBC correspondent, ''they threw out the policy manual and put in the profit manual — and this is the result.''

NBC and Dateline officials, who are conducting their own probe of the incident, refused comment, but heads may roll. The at-risk list includes:

*Dateline executive producer Jeff Diamond, formerly senior producer of ABC's 20/20. ''No story goes on Dateline without Diamond having tight control of it,'' an NBC producer says. ''If anybody's going to be the fall guy, he ought to be it.''

*Robert Read, producer of the GM segment. Colleagues point to Read's training at the tabloid TV show Inside Edition as evidence of the network's lowered standards. ''If you hire people like that,'' says a fellow NBC producer, ''you're bound to get into trouble.''

*Correspondent Michele Gillen, who reported the GM story. Gillen was said to be up for an anchor post on a new NBC prime-time newsmagazine — a prospect that now seems less likely.

The scandal is a potentially crushing blow to Dateline, NBC's 18th try at duplicating 60 Minutes' popularity. The program had appeared to be on the verge of success. ''NBC seems to have a voodoo curse on its ability to field a competitive show,'' says media critic Jon Katz.

Competition among network newsmagazines — there are now six on the air — has contributed to the atmosphere of ethical corner-cutting. ''It's a descending escalator of journalistic values. You go down very slowly,'' says former NBC correspondent Marvin Kalb. The proliferation of such shows also depletes the talent pool of reporters and producers. ''There aren't that many good people in this business,'' says 60 Minutes executive producer Don Hewitt. ''Sooner or later you start scraping the bottom of the barrel.''

TV's need for sensational images, however, seems to have been the driving force in Dateline's case. To get a picture of an exploding truck, the show broke basic journalistic rules against staging events. ''Producers are under phenomenal pressure to illustrate everything with strong visual images,'' Katz says. ''Ironically, they had a fairly substantial story — they simply illustrated it inappropriately.'' (In fact, four days before GM sued NBC, the automaker lost a $105.2 million suit brought by the parents of a Georgia teen who was killed when his pickup exploded.)

The impact of the Dateline debacle will no doubt be felt in newsrooms far beyond NBC's. ''This reminded everybody, 'Hold your horses when you're going to report on a major advertiser,''' says Ben Bagdikian, professor emeritus of journalism at the University of California at Berkeley. ''NBC did a disservice to itself and to the news business.''

''There's a great sense of pain when you see the Peacock lose a couple more feathers,'' a veteran NBC reporter laments. ''We don't know how many are left.''
 
Here's another, NBC again doctoring a tape to make George Zimmerman appear racist. This got one of their producers fired:

http://scaredmonkeys.com/2012/04/07...-zimmerman-9-11-tape-misleading-it-was-a-lie/


NBC Fires Producer of Edited, Doctored and Misleading George Zimmerman 9-11 Tape

We have always said that the MSM would never lets the facts get in the way of a good made up story. However, this might take the cake. NBC News knowingly produced a doctored audio tape that they knew would draw the ire of many and fan the flames of racism while boosting their viewership as they exploited a tragic news story.

An NBC producer has been fired who took part in the production of the doctored and misleading George Zimmerman tape. Sorry, but this tape was not only misleading, it was deceptive. The audio segment in question was shown on NBC’s “Today” show on March 27, 2012. The audio included George Zimmerman making comments regarding Trayvon Martin saying, “This guy looks like he’s up to no good. He looks black.” However, what NBC broadcast on air was nothing of what actually happened as they took Zimmerman’s word out of context and edited out the 9-11 dispatchers questions. NBC had opened an internal investigation after it was shown that the edited and inflammatory audio segment that was played resembled nothing of the original 9-11 tape between the operator and Zimmerman.

NBC News has fired a producer who was involved in the production of a misleading segment about the Trayvon Martin case in Florida.

The person was fired on Thursday, according to two people with direct knowledge of the disciplinary action who declined to be identified discussing internal company matters. They also declined to name the fired producer. A spokeswoman for NBC News declined to comment.

The action came in the wake of an internal investigation by NBC News into the production of the segment, which strung together audio clips in such a way that made George Zimmerman’s shooting of Mr. Martin sound racially motivated. Ever since the Feb. 26 shooting, there has been a continuing debate about whether race was a factor in the incident.

What is unbelievable is that NBC refused to give the producers name. This guy and NBC does a hatched job on Zimmerman and fans the flames of racism in the death of Trayvon Martin, but he gets to remain anonymous. Are you joking?

 
This just goes to show how fucking stupid you are oldjones, and why I really need to stop responding to your posts.

Rob Ford: "I dont use crack cocaine, nor am I an addict of crack cocaine". That's now, what about then? Ford's statement should answer all questions right there, but unfortunately it does not even begin to. But then again what should we expect from you oldfart, you can barely follow debates in this thread

See above for the same video denial you already saw elsewhere
I added proper notices about the holes you left in your ill-thought remark about what little Ford said (and note that he's since altered that). His words I left as is and your original overstatement is in the post immediately above, for comparison. If only it was as easy to fix the holes in Ford's thinking and speaking, we'd long since have left this unpleasant topic well behind. Back there is where you'll find the detail about why the denial doesn't hold up.

As to the other stuff about you not responding to my posts, I definitely agree. This attempt was particularly weak, even without the profanity which detracts from any credibility you might claim. I did post directions to the Ignore function awhile ago, did you miss them?.

PS: With Flashblock, the video's just a black blob, but just for you I clicked and ran what I'd already seen countless times. Yet another repetition of Rob's too-little, too-late and entirely inconclusive statement only weakens the idea that he actually made any case for himself. Except that he doesn't currently smoke and isn't addicted now. Good for the morning after even though it begins to unravel even then, more holes than a fishing net a week later, and two weeks on …? Only the True Believers are still behind him while all the rest of us wait for the next Ford shoe to drop.

While we wait, and while the video guys are staying outta sight, Ford nation would do better to let interest die and allow human nature to revive presumptions of innocence and good will, rather than keep reminding us how thin and limited Rob's only real statement was.

Before he made it worse.
 
I don't think TV news is up to the same standards, particularly in the US. I also think your allegation against the Star is completely unfounded - you have absolutely no reason to believe that they made anything up, and yet you are willing to make that blatant assertion and believe in it. It's kooky.

Certainly if the story turns out to have been fabricated, Ford is going to sue them -- and yet we know that the Star has had lawyers all over this story. Seems unlikely that they would go high profile with something like that when they themselves have put it under such scrutiny.
 
I don't think TV news is up to the same standards, particularly in the US
Come on now, fuji. You asked for 2 examples. I gave you 2. Now suddenly you're backtracking by saying US isnt up to same standards.

I'll get you a few Canadian newspaper examples. Gimme a day or two
 
I don't think TV news is up to the same standards, particularly in the US.


From the Dateline debacle: "Some staffers blame Gartner —— a former newspaperman hired in 1988 even though he had no background in TV news —hired in 1988 even though he had no background in TV news — for trying to satisfy parent company General Electric's bottom-line mentality by replacing veteran journalists with cheaper, less experienced reporters and producers. After GE took over the network in 1986, says one NBC correspondent, ''they threw out the policy manual and put in the profit manual — and this is the result.''


(oh and nice ninja editing fuji)
 
Maybe because he's already answered he doesnt do crack, and maybe therefore he thinks the question isnt even worthy of a response.

How many times is he supposed to keep answering the question?? Are reporters hard of hearing?? Do they not understand the words "I don't do crack cocaine". Or how about "the video doesnt exist"??

Seems like 2 fairly straightforward responses to me

You're easily duped then.

Because it's just a play on words.

All Mayor McCheese said was, "I am not addicted to crack cocaine" - which could mean that he feels that he has his crack cocaine habit under control. He is a casual user from time to time, but is not addicted to crack - i.e. needs to hit every day, or several times a day.

Then Mayor McCheese said, "I do not use crack cocaine" - present tense. I.e. "I may have used it in the past, but I am not currently using crack cocaine"

A simple question to ask Ford would be, "Have you EVER smoked crack cocaine in your life?"

Of course, Ford is a pathological liar (he's been caught in so many lies, it's not funny e.g. that DUI charge in Florida, e.g. the marijuana possession, e.g. the altercation at the Leafs game, etc. etc).

So really, someone could ask McCheese, "Have you EVER smoked crack cocaine in your life?" and Ford would just lie and say no.

Ford is avoiding answering any questions because the media will pound away at him until he eventually slips. (And he will slip because he isn't that smart and can't keep all of his lies straight.)
 
Here you go fuji, not one, not two, but three Canadian cases. And what do we have here, a Toronto Star reporter who admitted to and apologized for plagiarism :D

http://www.globaljournalist.org/stories/2005/01/01/journalisms-chronic-crisis/

1. Multiple cases of plagiarism have occurred in three other British Commonwealth countries. IPI Fellow Paddy Sherman, retired publisher of the Pacific Press in Canada, wrote of “three significant cases … since The New York Times perfected and exposed the art form.” In April, a prize-winning veteran reporter on the Toronto Star, Canada’s largest daily, lifted nearly a third of a story that appeared in The Village Voice about a U.S. Army deserter who had fled to Canada rather than go to Iraq. She had been given The Voice article by an editor. The reporter apologized. Managing Editor Mary Deanne Shears said the plagiarism was a “serious and unfortunate incident that arose out of equally unfortunate personal circumstances.”


2. In July, the editors of the National Post in Toronto fired medical reporter Brad Evenson after he faked quotes and identities in nine stories

3. In February, the Vancouver Sun used a piece by freelancer Angele Yanor about senior citizens learning to snowboard. The story bore a strong enough resemblance to a New York Times travel article for the Sun to dismiss Yanor
 
I get a kick out of "debates" involving true believers. Nothing anyone posts on this thread is going to convince Ford Nation. No defence of Ford is going to impress those who find him contemptible. All you are really doing is venting at each other in cyberspace. If Butler weren't one of the ones venting on this thead, he would have long since made popcorn for the hundreds of us watching from the peanut gallery.
 
You're easily duped then.

Because it's just a play on words.

All Mayor McCheese said was, "I am not addicted to crack cocaine" - which could mean that he feels that he has his crack cocaine habit under control. He is a casual user from time to time, but is not addicted to crack - i.e. needs to hit every day, or several times a day.

Then Mayor McCheese said, "I do not use crack cocaine" - present tense. I.e. "I may have used it in the past, but I am not currently using crack cocaine"

A simple question to ask Ford would be, "Have you EVER smoked crack cocaine in your life?"

Of course, Ford is a pathological liar (he's been caught in so many lies, it's not funny e.g. that DUI charge in Florida, e.g. the marijuana possession, e.g. the altercation at the Leafs game, etc. etc).

So really, someone could ask McCheese, "Have you EVER smoked crack cocaine in your life?" and Ford would just lie and say no.

Ford is avoiding answering any questions because the media will pound away at him until he eventually slips. (And he will slip because he isn't that smart and can't keep all of his lies straight.)
So now we're down to pedantic nitpicking over what Ford meant and didnt mean.

His denial should be good enough until that video shows up, which so far it hasnt
 
News media have a strong interest in maintaining a reputation for integrity. They do not just make up the news.
Did The Star ever retract and apologize for their article falsely accusing the Fords of ordering the destruction of emails?
 
National Post's Elizabeth Nickson was dismissed in November 2004 for plagiarism:

http://catalog.freedomforum.org/FFLib/JournalistScandals.htm

Confirmed on wiki: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Post

Elizabeth Nickson (Canada’s National Post) – Nickson was dismissed in November 2004 after it was learned that a column she wrote in 2002 contained five sentences that should have been attributed to a 2001 article originally written by columnist Jonah Goldberg of the National Review Online. Nickson was the second writer in less than five months dismissed from the National Post for questionable actions
 
This one is about "Gawker claims video exists of Rob Ford smoking crack."
That might be the title but the substance of the thread is about accusing someone of committing a crime or misdeed without producing hard evidence. BTW: Has anyone found that mysterious video yet?
 
I can give you 2 US examples right now. You'll have to give me a few days to search for Canadian ones, but I'm sure they exist. In fact I know they do, because I vaguely remember one explicit one (will post later).

Here's the first American bullshit story, completely fabricated by NBC's dateline:

http://www.ew.com/ew/article/0,,305709,00.html

Don't forget about "Rathergate" which led to Dan Rather's departure from the CBS evening news. Rather/CBS cited forged documents in a story criticizing George W Bush's National Guard Service. CBS/Rather were criticized for failing to properly authenticate the documents.


Killian documents controversy
Further information: Killian documents authenticity issues**and**George W. Bush military service controversy

Charles Johnson's animated GIF image comparing what CBS claimed to be a 1973-era typewritten memo with a proportional-spaced 2004-era Microsoft Word document made with default settings
The Killian documents controversy (also referred to as Memogate, Rathergate or Rathergate[1]) involved six documents critical of President George W. Bush's service in the Air National Guard in 1972–73. Four of these documents[2] were presented as authentic in a 60 Minutes Wednesday broadcast aired by CBS on September 8, 2004, less than two months before the 2004 Presidential Election, but it was later found that CBS had failed to authenticate the documents.[3][4][5] Subsequently, several typewriter and typography experts concluded the documents are blatant forgeries,[6][7] as have most media sources. No forensic document examiners or typography experts have authenticated the documents, and this may not be technically possible without original documents.[8] The provider of the documents, Lt. Col. Bill Burkett, claims to have burned the originals after faxing copies to CBS.[9]

CBS News producer Mary Mapes obtained the copied documents from Burkett, a former officer in the Texas Army National Guard, while pursuing a story about the George W. Bush military service controversy. The papers, purportedly made by Bush's commander, the late Lieutenant Colonel Jerry B. Killian, included criticisms of Bush's service in the Guard during the 1970s. In the 60 Minutes segment, anchor Dan Rather stated: "We are told [the documents] were taken from Lieutenant Colonel Killian’s personal files"[10] and incorrectly asserted that "the material" had been authenticated by experts retained by CBS.[11]

The authenticity of the documents was challenged within hours on Internet forums and blogs, with questions initially focused on alleged anachronisms in the documents' typography and content soon spreading to the mass media.[12] Although CBS and Rather defended the authenticity and usage of the documents for a two-week period, continued scrutiny from other news organizations and independent analysis of the documents obtained by USA Today and CBS raised questions about their validity and led to a public repudiation on September 20, 2004. Rather stated, "if I knew then what I know now – I would not have gone ahead with the story as it was aired, and I certainly would not have used the documents in question,"[13] and CBS News President Andrew Heyward said, "Based on what we now know, CBS News cannot prove that the documents are authentic, which is the only acceptable journalistic standard to justify using them in the report. We should not have used them. That was a mistake, which we deeply regret."[13][14]

Several months later, a CBS-appointed panel led by Dick Thornburgh and Louis Boccardi criticized both the initial CBS news segment and CBS' "strident defense" during the aftermath.[15] CBS fired producer Mary Mapes, several senior news executives were asked to resign, and CBS apologized to viewers. The panel did not specifically consider whether the documents were forgeries but concluded that the producers had failed to authenticate them and cited "substantial questions regarding the authenticity of the Killian documents."

Background and timeline

September 8 segment and initial reactions

CBS' defense, apology

Review panel established

Aftermath

Authentication issues

Accusations of bias

See also

Footnotes

External links

Read in another language

Last modified 3 months ago
MobileDesktop
Text is available under CC BY-SA 3.0; additional terms may apply.
Terms of UsePrivacy

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Killian_documents_controversy