Mr Bean in Church

Are you suggesting the Jews are a racial group? Been spending your time at Stormfront?

No, spending time with someone who is a geneticist, a staunch atheist, and a Lebanese Jew, and if I don't accept what she says I may be sleeping on the couch.

Oh, you mean you didn't know?

I agree that defining a Jewish race may be a bit tight, there is significant intermingling among most ethnicities, but there are genetic markers that have been well studied, you really should keep up with modern biology.

http://www.khazaria.com/genetics/abstracts.html

http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/judaica/ejud_0002_0007_0_07174.html
 
No, spending time with someone who is a geneticist, a staunch atheist, and a Lebanese Jew, and if I don't accept what she says I may be sleeping on the couch.

Oh, you mean you didn't know?

I agree that defining a Jewish race may be a bit tight, there is significant intermingling among most ethnicities, but there are genetic markers that have been well studied, you really should keep up with modern biology.

http://www.khazaria.com/genetics/abstracts.html

http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/judaica/ejud_0002_0007_0_07174.html

Nothing like dropping the Britannica and a bibliography of research, say 'see', and expecting us to read them. Could you offer up a summary? So you friend is a Jew, but not a follower of Judaism?:confused:
 
Friend? Read it again, she's a bit closer than that...

Would she have to be? Or have you never heard of an atheist Jew? I think there's quite a few of them.

I may stand corrected on 'friend', yet 'spending time' is a pretty light description, but my point still stands. The estimate I've seen for atheist Jews is ~12%, obviously higher in some countries, but not what I'd call quit a few, but hey. It's the old classic question of how much jewishness do you have to have to be called jewish. Never fails to bring laughter into a dual cocktail party.

Does your friend celebrate the various feast, festivals, and various ritual with other friends and family? It would be interesting to know.
 
I may stand corrected on 'friend', yet 'spending time' is a pretty light description, but my point still stands. The estimate I've seen for atheist Jews is ~12%, obviously higher in some countries, but not what I'd call quit a few, but hey. It's the old classic question of how much jewishness do you have to have to be called jewish. Never fails to bring laughter into a dual cocktail party.

Does your friend celebrate the various feast, festivals, and various ritual with other friends and family? It would be interesting to know.

Looks like I have to spell it out: sleeping on the couch = pissed-off wife. And no, she doesn't any of the cultural or religious stuff. Her immediate family are also atheist, and as they have no relatives in Canada they don't need to get together with any other family members for such things. Apparently she has a cousin who is a rabbi in England, but there's no communication. And, while anyone who has dealt with people could probably peg her as middle-eastern, she doesn't 'look Jewish', whatever the hell some mean by that. Except, maybe, her big tits, but she's no Chesty Morgan. Is it just me, or does it seem that a lot of Jewish women are rather well endowed? :eyebrows:
 
So instead of just braying, what part of his post is wrong? Every one of his points have been covered and supported in past threads.

Let me count the ways.

RID: In the western world religion was crucial for the development of women becoming persons instead of property.

Of all the influential organizations in the history of the world, surely you cannot be suggesting that the standout organizations that have promoted women's interests have been the religions?

RID: Religion preserved literacy and the classics in the early middle ages and invented the entire institution of universities. The thing that preserved literacy and the classics in the early middle ages was the invention of the printing press -- religions led the hostility to that. The RCC was the leader in seeking to suppress translations and mass printing of the bible, for example.
What organizations have there ever been, that have suppressed education and mass literacy, especially of the poor, more than religions?

RID: Our current models of fundamental human rights comes from the ideas of early Christian writers.

Our current models of fundamental human rights come from the UN Charter, signed in 1945. The thing that kickstarted the current model was the Renaissance (which marked the end of centuries of medieval domination and suppression by religions, esp the RCC.) The French Revolution was quite influential. Even more so the US Bill of Rights. When have the religions put out any kind of leadership statement defining human rights? At each incremental step along the way, religions have provided the main opposition to human rights.

RID: Religion was crucial in the elimination of slavery.

You might care to consult such articles as "Christian Views on Slavery", in Wiki.

RID: In the United States, while many powerful people were arguing people like you should be sterilized against their will, the only large organization that publically opposed the eugenics movement was the RCC.

My dear chap, I'm from Yorkshire. You must know that world-men, when they compare themselves with a Yorkshireman, can only hold their manhood cheap, and forever regret they were not born Yorkshire. Seriously, many have called eugenics, itself, a religion -- as a mark of how bad the eugenics movement was.
 
Let me count the ways.

RID: In the western world religion was crucial for the development of women becoming persons instead of property.

Of all the influential organizations in the history of the world, surely you cannot be suggesting that the standout organizations that have promoted women's interests have been the religions?

RID: Religion preserved literacy and the classics in the early middle ages and invented the entire institution of universities. The thing that preserved literacy and the classics in the early middle ages was the invention of the printing press -- religions led the hostility to that. The RCC was the leader in seeking to suppress translations and mass printing of the bible, for example.
What organizations have there ever been, that have suppressed education and mass literacy, especially of the poor, more than religions?

RID: Our current models of fundamental human rights comes from the ideas of early Christian writers.

Our current models of fundamental human rights come from the UN Charter, signed in 1945. The thing that kickstarted the current model was the Renaissance (which marked the end of centuries of medieval domination and suppression by religions, esp the RCC.) The French Revolution was quite influential. Even more so the US Bill of Rights. When have the religions put out any kind of leadership statement defining human rights? At each incremental step along the way, religions have provided the main opposition to human rights.

RID: Religion was crucial in the elimination of slavery.

You might care to consult such articles as "Christian Views on Slavery", in Wiki.

RID: In the United States, while many powerful people were arguing people like you should be sterilized against their will, the only large organization that publically opposed the eugenics movement was the RCC.

My dear chap, I'm from Yorkshire. You must know that world-men, when they compare themselves with a Yorkshireman, can only hold their manhood cheap, and forever regret they were not born Yorkshire. Seriously, many have called eugenics, itself, a religion -- as a mark of how bad the eugenics movement was.

Your first point is debatable.

Your second point is that the press preserved knowledge when more correctly it allowed knowledge to spread, but before that, what played a large part in sustaining much of the great pools of knowledge was the great libraries of the muslims world, which helped the ancient world's knowledge to survive and the libraries maintained by the centers of learning, often ruin by the churches of the time.

Your third point is weak as the Presbyterian church was one of the first major organization to argue against slavery in the late 18th century.

Your points go down hill from there, 'eugenics is a religion' :confused:. I especially laughed at the expectation of you're being from Yorkshire to carry any weight. Remember the Yorkshire ripper?
 
Your third point is weak as the Presbyterian church was one of the first major organization to argue against slavery in the late 18th century.
Not to mention the Relgious Society of Friends (Quakers)


In the Yorkshire connection surely a Yorkshireman would know that William Wilberforce was not only born in, but was the M.P. first for Kingston upon Hull, in the East Ridding of Yorkshire and was then one of Yorkshire's two Knights of the Shire.
 
I especially laughed at the expectation of you're being from Yorkshire to carry any weight. Remember the Yorkshire ripper?

I didn't mean that the opinions of Yorkshiremen should carry more weight. Your man was noting that some say people "like you" should, be sterilized. I was just pointing out that, being from Yorkshire, I am lucky in that I have never, ever, in the slightest degree, been on the receiving end of derogatory discriminatory prejudice. In this naughty world, there are "victimized people" at one end of the scale, and Yorkshiremen at the other. Or maybe I should say the very first time is right now -- if I'm being blamed for my part in creating the Yorkshire Ripper.

On the human rights point, I hope you can identify something, from the early Christian writers, that we could recognize as a statement of fundamental human rights -- of any kind, let alone the current models.

As a generality: Religions don't make declarations of human rights. If you were in the Boy Scouts, you'll remember one of the scout laws: "A scout is a friend to all, no matter to what country, class or creed the other may belong." Simply as a statement of human rights, even that beats anything the churches have come up with.
 
Not to mention the Relgious Society of Friends (Quakers)

I doubt Quakers in those days were considered Christians by mainstream
churches such as Prebyterian. Quakers I believe didn't believe in the divinity
of Christ. Thomas Paine was a Quaker and his non-belief is well known.

In the Yorkshire connection surely a Yorkshireman would know that William Wilberforce was not only born in, but was the M.P. first for Kingston upon Hull, in the East Ridding of Yorkshire and was then one of Yorkshire's two Knights of the Shire.


The evangelist William Wilberforce was a sincere Christian. But his stand against
slavery dated back to his younger days when he was still a skeptic. Read about
this many many years ago from 'The martyr of men'. I'd say the magnificient effort
of Wilberforce and the Quakers in fighting slavery were as humanistic as religious.
 
A related inspirational story for our 'believers' here.....Enjoy!

 
I didn't mean that the opinions of Yorkshiremen should carry more weight. Your man was noting that some say people "like you" should, be sterilized. I was just pointing out that, being from Yorkshire, I am lucky in that I have never, ever, in the slightest degree, been on the receiving end of derogatory discriminatory prejudice. In this naughty world, there are "victimized people" at one end of the scale, and Yorkshiremen at the other. Or maybe I should say the very first time is right now -- if I'm being blamed for my part in creating the Yorkshire Ripper.

On the human rights point, I hope you can identify something, from the early Christian writers, that we could recognize as a statement of fundamental human rights -- of any kind, let alone the current models.

As a generality: Religions don't make declarations of human rights. If you were in the Boy Scouts, you'll remember one of the scout laws: "A scout is a friend to all, no matter to what country, class or creed the other may belong." Simply as a statement of human rights, even that beats anything the churches have come up with.

I don't have an easy comprehensive answer your initial 'human rights' question, but I suspect others might, yet your your Boy Scout parallel is more easy to answer. It's called the 'Golden Rule' interestingly enough a common thread with as many as 14-20+ major religions.
 
RID: In the western world religion was crucial for the development of women becoming persons instead of property.

Of all the influential organizations in the history of the world, surely you cannot be suggesting that the standout organizations that have promoted women's interests have been the religions?

It would be nice if you would a) be honest, and b) read the earlier sources on the thread.

I am suggesting actually what I said, your attempt to twist my assertion is dishonest.

Please go up thread to the already posted Science Nordic subject that discusses this process in Denmark. Let me summarize the historical flow for you. In almost every european pagan culture women were property. Christianity defined them as people. Did you read the science nordic article?


RID: Religion preserved literacy and the classics in the early middle ages and invented the entire institution of universities. The thing that preserved literacy and the classics in the early middle ages was the invention of the printing press -- religions led the hostility to that. The RCC was the leader in seeking to suppress translations and mass printing of the bible, for example.
What organizations have there ever been, that have suppressed education and mass literacy, especially of the poor, more than religions?

Do you disagree with my statement? It appears you dance away. You make some generalizations but have no real facts or sources.

You really have this bizarre modern worldview. Allow me to educate a bit. Before very recent times, almost all education was religiously based, there were no public schools. The church in Europe did found, fund and invent modern universities.

The invention of the printing press was a late development, after a thousand years of the church being the main provider of literacy and preserving and recovering the classics, including pagan classics. Your knowledge of the church's position on artistole etc and why we still know about socrates and others is a bit lacking.

The RCC has never engaged in supressing literacy. You are simply lying on this. The church in europe did not oppose the printing press.

As discussed in another recent thread. The church just banned unapproved of badly translated bibles, which also included polemical introductions and some pretty bizarre editing. The church approved a number of vulgate translations of the bible well before the invention of the printing press.

RID: Our current models of fundamental human rights comes from the ideas of early Christian writers.

Our current models of fundamental human rights come from the UN Charter, signed in 1945. The thing that kickstarted the current model was the Renaissance (which marked the end of centuries of medieval domination and suppression by religions, esp the RCC.) The French Revolution was quite influential. Even more so the US Bill of Rights. When have the religions put out any kind of leadership statement defining human rights? At each incremental step along the way, religions have provided the main opposition to human rights.

Look another unsupported assertion. Up thread there is a link to an published academic book covering the issue. I hate to tell you this but the idea of human rights did not appear fully formed from the head of Zeus in 1945. The idea as it exists now started in the writings of church fathers and advanced through Magna Carta etc up to today's date. I know you are badly biased but history does not change because of your bias.

RID: Religion was crucial in the elimination of slavery.

You might care to consult such articles as "Christian Views on Slavery", in Wiki.

Fortunately my education is broader than wikipedia. If your yorkshire education has left you leaning on wiki for important opinions perhaps that explains your foolishness on this issue. This has been well covered up thread, which it appears you are either to lazy to read or too dishonest to admit.

RID: In the United States, while many powerful people were arguing people like you should be sterilized against their will, the only large organization that publically opposed the eugenics movement was the RCC.

My dear chap, I'm from Yorkshire. You must know that world-men, when they compare themselves with a Yorkshireman, can only hold their manhood cheap, and forever regret they were not born Yorkshire. Seriously, many have called eugenics, itself, a religion -- as a mark of how bad the eugenics movement was.

Anyone who calls eugenics a religion clearly does not know the meaning of the world. But despite that fact that in hindsight the idea is pretty universally despised that does not change the fact that thousands of people were harmed through this pervasive and popular movement. Nazism is a pretty bad idea in hindsight but it does not mean it did not harm anyone. The fact is while thousands were being harmed the only organization in the US that opposed this plan publically was the RCC.

Unfortunately your comments clearly lead to the conclusion that a) you are not well informed on the areas you try to comment on and b) you refuse to recognize any facts that you don't like. Not a healthy way to think or live.
 
Quakers I believe didn't believe in the divinity
of Christ. Thomas Paine was a Quaker and his non-belief is well known.
Friends most assuredly believe in the dual nature of Christ and consider themselves to be Christians. However it is true that Friends at that time and many Friends today do not practice Baptism.

Thomas Paine was indeed a pain, as well as being a not particularly good example of Friends witness.

While you may think that both Quakers and William Wiberforce where driven by humanistic considerations, they would say that they were driven by faith.
 
Anyone who calls eugenics a religion clearly does not know the meaning of the world. But despite that fact that in hindsight the idea is pretty universally despised that does not change the fact that thousands of people were harmed through this pervasive and popular movement. Nazism is a pretty bad idea in hindsight but it does not mean it did not harm anyone. The fact is while thousands were being harmed the only organization in the US that opposed this plan publically was the RCC.

Unfortunately your comments clearly lead to the conclusion that a) you are not well informed on the areas you try to comment on and b) you refuse to recognize any facts that you don't like. Not a healthy way to think or live.

Regarding the stance of religion against eugenics you might care to consider http://www.nrlc.org/news/2004/NRL08/preaching_eugenics_religious_lea.htm

As to eugenics as religion, perhaps http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/sociopolitica/esp_sociopol_depopu33.htm
 
Regarding the stance of religion against eugenics you might care to consider http://www.nrlc.org/news/2004/NRL08/preaching_eugenics_religious_lea.htm

As to eugenics as religion, perhaps http://www.bibliotecapleyades.net/sociopolitica/esp_sociopol_depopu33.htm

One article is written by Iain Mckenzie known for the hypothesis that Global Warming is caused by eugenics, yup.

The second article doesn't say eugenics is a religion, just that early in it popularity it was erroneous supported by some religious leaders and totally discredited by WWII, different than your claim.
 
Regarding the stance of religion against eugenics you might care to consider http://www.nrlc.org/news/2004/NRL08...s.net/sociopolitica/esp_sociopol_depopu33.htm

did you read this article?

It claims that eugenics and religions have been brought to earth by manipulative aliens:

The learned research of John Lash on the Gnostics suggest that Eugenics is in fact an “alien religion” brought to Earth by Manipulative Extraterrestrials, that have been seeking to disseminate their “anti-spirituality” through organized religions.

These organized religions apparently include Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. Dr. Lash referred to the context of a “super religion” as “the doctrine of the aliens”.

If that is what you call a source, or how you shape your thinking, we can simply discount you now. It makes me comments on the people who describe eugenics as a religion perhaps far too tame.

How is your tinfoil hat fitting today?
 
Tell you what.

Rather than go through all the nonsense about "that's not what I was trying to say", let's just say that you have respect for organizations that promote belief in the idea of a guy in the sky who made the universe and gave us our human morality and sometimes answers individual prayers. I regard such organizations as no more worthy (but no less worthy) of my respect than those who believe in santa claus.

I will never respect such organizations, no matter what you say. You will not cease to respect them, no matter what I say. You regard me as a nincompoop. I think you're a clown.

Sounds like a good time to move on.