Teacher Appreciation Week? You've got to be joking!

Highly specialized = narrow view point

Labour relations within that field. You do know arbitrators are highly speciaized, right? An erbitrator specializing in education knows what the results of contract talks are the world over, they know what benefits exist everywhere, they know the economic situation of where they work, they have information on sick leave bank sizes and usage rates, how many are certified by doctors, they know vacation usage, etc.

Is that "expert" enough for you? It is for me. If you need more info, just look into binding arbitration. My company, for example, has a list of arbitrators. If we can't reach an agreement, we (the bargaining group) go thorough their list and select one. We also have some room to move if we don't like their list (though their list is very comprehensive, so we don't usually have a problem).

IF they actually know any of the stats you state, they sure as hell don't apply what they claim to know.
"they know the economic situation of where they work", I guess they have their own strange concept of what "economics" means.

"they know what benefits exist everywhere,", except,...their so called expertise seems to be limited to the union environment only, otherwise there wouldn't be as much of a difference between the unionised and non union benefits.

Its already been determined that these so called "experts" always side with employees, kinda explains why the government had no choice with the teachers unions, and to do the right thing, and actually govern.

As you belong to a union, and are debating with a unionists view point, I do understand were you are coming from.

FAST
 
Last edited:
It is irresponsible of the govt to waste taxpayers hard earned tax dollars on any excessive benefit for any public employee group

Bang on. If this was the Teamsters or the CAW, the government would have pulic support to challenge the unions more aggresively.

The OSSTF positions itself in the media very carefully - and in the mind of the voters - as the "Protector" of children's education. What a load of manure. And I'm tired of it.
 
One question which none of the teachers or their supporters appear willing to address is
"Where is the money going to come from to ensure Teachers are able to continue recieving their unbelievably expensive compensation?"

The province is running deficts & huge Health care costs increases will soon appear
When faced with such a problem one can only
a) cut costs or
b) raise taxes

Since the loony left does not see the wisdom of cutting back on wasteful excessive spending (i.e banking of sick days), the only other option is higher taxes

Just remember it takes three ontario taxpayers full year Ont tax to cover the pay of a teacher during the summer months when they add no value

My guess is the lefties do not have a clue and have not given the question any real thought, yet form their opinion because they think someone else will pick up the tab AS THEY HAVE BEEN TAUGHT
 
Or print more money

One question which none of the teachers or their supporters appear willing to address is
"Where is the money going to come from to ensure Teachers are able to continue recieving their unbelievably expensive compensation?"

The province is running deficts & huge Health care costs increases will soon appear
When faced with such a problem one can only
a) cut costs or
b) raise taxes

Since the loony left does not see the wisdom of cutting back on wasteful excessive spending (i.e banking of sick days), the only other option is higher taxes

Just remember it takes three ontario taxpayers full year Ont tax to cover the pay of a teacher during the summer months when they add no value

My guess is the lefties do not have a clue and have not given the question any real thought, yet form their opinion because they think someone else will pick up the tab AS THEY HAVE BEEN TAUGHT

Sure they do John,...its soooo simple,...all you got to do is raise the taxes for the rich, and those dammed corporations that employ people,...problem solved over night.

Well until the next contract anyway !!!

FAST
 
Would think the teacher’s total compensation was closer to 4x the average taxpayer when benefits are included. Not many taxpayers have summers off and can retire in their mid 50s on about 50K/year pension that’s indexed to inflation.

Not many people have more than 10% of their income automatically deducted to help pay for that pension. Granted the goevernment chips in as well.
 
One question which none of the teachers or their supporters appear willing to address is
"Where is the money going to come from to ensure Teachers are able to continue recieving their unbelievably expensive compensation?"

The province is running deficts & huge Health care costs increases will soon appear
When faced with such a problem one can only
a) cut costs or
b) raise taxes

Since the loony left does not see the wisdom of cutting back on wasteful excessive spending (i.e banking of sick days), the only other option is higher taxes

Just remember it takes three ontario taxpayers full year Ont tax to cover the pay of a teacher during the summer months when they add no value

My guess is the lefties do not have a clue and have not given the question any real thought, yet form their opinion because they think someone else will pick up the tab AS THEY HAVE BEEN TAUGHT

First of all can you tell us how much money is needed? Cause that would help.

Here are a few suggestions

0) Go out and collect on the 1 billion in unpaid taxes which doesn't even include the other 1 billion that was written off (probably businesses that went belly up)

1) use assets owned by school boards to generate income (e.g. develop some of the properties owned by schools as office spacce or whatever)
2) when building new schools build them at the base of government buildings to save money
3) sell advertising space within schools
4) stop using textbooks and replace them with other methods be it electronic or course packs made by the teachers (at 80 to 100 bucks a pop textbooks are expensive)
5) have an auditor monitor spending of budgeted money
6) auction off cafeteria contracts and caretaking
7) cut out the middle men for school supplies
8) sell school uniforms at a modeset profit and give tax breaks to parents for the uniforms

9) Make similar adjustments in other parts of the goverment as it's not the education systems responsibility as the shortfall is due to a number of reasons. ORNGE, moving power plants didn't help out either to name just a few.

That's a start

10) Restructure the pay scale so it takes longer to max out
11) Raise the retirement age

12) Get rid of the Catholic board, not sure why anyone other than catholics are okay with this one.
 
1. The number of sick days a teacher currently gets is excesive 20 -30 (please correct me if you know the specific number), even if they spend time with snot filed little germ generators.
The private sector the norm is 5 days a year
2. The ratio of sick days available to days worked for teachers is then inflated further by the fact that there is less than 200 teaching days in a year vs 250 working days in the private sector.
3. The real issue was the banking of this excessive benefit for a cash payout for half a years pay.
4. In the private sector if sick days are not used in a calander year they can not be ank & no way in hell can you cash them out.

Given the provinces dire financial state, eliminating this wasteful and absurd perk was long over-due

Teachers should have been thanking their lucky stars that a wage frezze and elimination of the sick days banking were the only restraint o their excessive compensation
I would been far more aggressive in restructuring thier comp package to reflect a more equitable use of taxpayers hard earned dollars

So teachers are using kids as pawns because they are being prevented from abusing the taxpayer one last time via the banking of sick days?

It is pretty obvious we need
a) a new agreement with teachers
b) or a completly new group of people to accept resonsibility for educating our youth.
The current group is obviously more preoccupied with extorting the taxpayer instead of developing young minds

See here's the problem you've got a post rife with things you don't know

e.g.

-number of sick days that they have
-terms they were offered
-what they are currently working under
-assuming teachers are using kids as pawns...... it's no different that hateres of teachers pointing out "what about the children" i.e. guilt trip
-teachers are not abusing taxpayers..... they just want what their contract dictates..... if you job had a contract you wouldn't be upset if the terms weren't met? Would you just sit and do nothing? IF you can't understand that people would fight for their livelihood then you have no empathy

Anyways, keep giving us the same old (uninformed) lines..... at least have the decency to do some research
 
OK FRANK and dtjohnst,...got a question for ya,...how would you describe the outcome of the "negotiaions" that recently transpired between the BIG 3 and the unions ???

FAST

Someone already answered that already..... it's not the outcome it's the process or lack of process that's the issue.
 
If teachers only want to be paid for their work. . .
Then put a time clock at the front door and punch them in & out. Therefore a teacher working 6 hours a day for 194 days would receive at $83,000 per year $71.30 per hour. As for all the preparation time, if you teach grade 4 then teach grade 4 for the next thirty years and you should have it down pat.
Secondly, I would like to see a middle-aged teacher take their English or History BA out on the market and see what sort of job they could receive. I f I was hiring for my business I would rather employ a 2 year graduate with a business diploma and no experience compared to a union-schooled thirty year veteran of the ETFO. I know which one would get along with the public better.
Lastly consider this;
194 school days in the year @ 6 hours per day = 1,164 hours
24 hrs/ day x 365 = 8,760 less two weeks holiday = 8,424 hours
Therefore schools are functioning for 13.8% of the year. The other 86% are paying fixed costs with no results.
If this were a business I would close the schools and outsource education to the Chinese!

You could say the same thing about most jobs with a salary. Sure let's move to an hourly model for everything then.
 
2 Realities of economics

Originally Posted by FAST
OK FRANK and dtjohnst,...got a question for ya,...how would you describe the outcome of the "negotiations" that recently transpired between the BIG 3 and the unions ???

FAST



Someone already answered that already..... it's not the outcome it's the process or lack of process that's the issue.


I did NOT see anybodies comment/description on how those "negotiations" went, other than reverting back to civil servants unions concept of economics !!!
The point is,...the process is NOT working in the public sector,...especially teachers.

A side note Frank,...you came up with some good ideas on how to save/raise money to pay for civil servant excess's, but the question is WHY !!!
Plus,...this would only be a temperary "fix" anyway.



FAST
 
I did NOT see anybodies comment/description on how those "negotiations" went, other than reverting back to civil servants unions concept of economics !!!
The point is,...the process is NOT working in the public sector,...especially teachers.

A side note Frank,...you came up with some good ideas on how to save/raise money to pay for civil servant excess's, but the question is WHY !!!
Plus,...this would only be a temperary "fix".



FAST

Wh? Because John asked for them.

I don't begrudge people for having a good job. The raises they've recieved over the years have been in line with inflation. So they were always doing better than the average canadian..... and they are probably better educated than the average canadian. It's for those reasons plus my belief that education is important that I have no problems with teachers being compensated how they are. I wouldn't be where I am without teachers. Nor would I have had the options in life without education. I was also raised by immigrant parents who taught me to value education and rspect teachers.... old habits die hard.

I believe that paying well is the way to ensure that there's continued interest in people wanting to do this job. I look at what is going on inthe US where education is not being valued and given the choice I don't mind paying for it. I thnk on my property tax I pay around 1K towards education and to me that's a small price to know that everyone gets a chance to go to school.

It's just my personal beliefs.

The way I look at it is that the benefits and pay for jobs is reasonably well known. If you didn't align yourself with a good job/career it's your fault..... by your I mean that figuratively and not personally (FAST) as I don't know a thing about you.
 
john your argument of economic disparity makes sense but ...

i find it stunning that intelligent right wingers like you will scream about a worker ant making a few $ more than other worker ants because they belong to a union while the wealthy own so much and yet you defend the rich

if you believe this inequality can go on then you are the one on glue and tearing apart unions is not the solution to social inequality
QUOTE]

You are dreaming in technicolor

Overpaying the public sector is not a solution to social inequality
Just look at the results
The province is broke
1/3 of the expenses go to education, the majority of that sum goes to teachers
The province is going to face huge increases in Health care costs in the next 5 years
Unless public service unions become more reasonable, we will have a health care crisis

If you think asking over-paid teachers to take a wage freeze for two years is a form of social inequality, then I suspect you will be very alarmed, when your Aunt has to wait six- nine months or pay for her exploratory surgury.

You can not have both and fools like you ignore the reality there is a cost for every social agenda.
Are you willing to sacrific the health care safety net of the province to ensure teachers contine to be over-paid?
Make no mistake, this is the choice

i agree with you about the problem (although i have always heard this doomsday scenario but it never happens)

but the solution is to take money from the rich 10% that consume 90% of all consumer products while causing manmade disaters like financial collapses

look at all they got !!!!!!!!

not doing so will destroy us all according to this Nobel prize winner


 
Last edited:
i agree with you about the problem (although i have always heard this doomsday scenario but it never happens)

but the solution is to take money from the rich 10% that consume 90% of all consumer products while causing manmade disaters like financial collapses

look at all the got !!!!!!!!

not doing so will destroy us all according to this Nobel prize winner



And the rich will try and scare you into thinking that if raise taxes that they will leave.

I agree that the rich should pay more but I left it out as my belief is that there's a lot of ways to maintain things as they are in the government by looking at how the money is spent, how assets are used etc....... clearly for some paying teachers the current amount is a waste. All the while dismissing and ignoring that our education system is quote good on an international level.

Notice how in all these discussions universities and colleges never even get a mention and how our tuitions are probably 1/2 to 1/4 of what you'd pay in the US. Do Canadian schools have some magic way of keeping costs down? Government funding.

People have problems paying for teachers in elementary and high school but they don't even mention how their taxes make it easier for a kid to take fine arts, experiment with drugs and find themselves. Of course that's just a generalization but seems people liketo use broad brushes around here.
 
And are there teachers with families and elderly parents who need constant care? Should those teachers be forced to volunteer when you aren't?

Teachers are not being forced to volunteer. If that was the case they would have been protesting and withholding extracurricular activities years ago. However, that has not been the case. They only started this job action which does nothing but punish students because they don't agree with what the government has proposed.

If I had teachers hours and the same amount of vacation days I would probably have time to volunteer throughout the year, but that's not the case.

Forced to volunteer, what a joke!
 
And the rich will try and scare you into thinking that if raise taxes that they will leave.

unsure of how it is to be done but there must be a way


your right they put their money in tax havens off shore

but the argument they just reinvest in the economy is absurd as they reinvest into where there is the most profit and if that means destroying third world economies through the money market or IMF repayment burdens so be it then pacify themselves with the belief that "greed is good"


but to say there is no way to distribute the money better without destroying freedom and wealth and capitalism seems like a folk tale that the elite themselves created


if an economist has such a solution he will be ridiculed and the rich would never allow him into politics with there well oiled machine


we are fucked so accept it and we are just having a theoretical debate here

and fight like crazy when they try to take away what you got while not touching that 80% of social wealth that the top 10% have stolen by their control of the system
 
Teachers are not being forced to volunteer. If that was the case they would have been protesting and withholding extracurricular activities years ago. However, that has not been the case. They only started this job action which does nothing but punish students...
You were among the bunch saying that teachers are expected to volunteer. Even in this statement you say that by choosing not to volunteer they are punishing students, implying that it's an obligation, not a choice.

... because they don't agree with what the government has proposed.

You might have missed the news but this wasn't about a proposed but a legislated one. Makes a huge difference.

If I had teachers hours and the same amount of vacation days I would probably have time to volunteer throughout the year, but that's not the case.
...

As I said, you can easily find the time if you chose. My typical week has me working 60+ hours (I'm well compensated) but I still choose to volunteer a few hours a week since I think it's important. If I stop volunteering, no one will accuse me of 'punishing kids' but you applying that logic to teachers clearly makes the point that you think they must do it..
 
Teachers are not being forced to volunteer. If that was the case they would have been protesting and withholding extracurricular activities years ago. However, that has not been the case. They only started this job action which does nothing but punish students because they don't agree with what the government has proposed.

If I had teachers hours and the same amount of vacation days I would probably have time to volunteer throughout the year, but that's not the case.

Forced to volunteer, what a joke!

Easy to say what you would do if you had the spare time. Heck there are teachers who don't do extracurriculars so what makes you think you'd be one of the special ones to help out. The thing about extracurriculars is that you choose one based on the time that you have (assuming you want to do it). Clearly since you don't even donate an hour why should we believe that you'd give any more than that?

This is a clear case of being an armchair teacher.
 
unsure of how it is to be done but there must be a way


your right they put their money in tax havens off shore

but the argument they just reinvest in the economy is absurd as they reinvest into where there is the most profit and if that means destroying third world economies through the money market or IMF repayment burdens so be it then pacify themselves with the belief that "greed is good"


but to say there is no way to distribute the money better without destroying freedom and wealth and capitalism seems like a folk tale that the elite themselves created


if an economist has such a solution he will be ridiculed and the rich would never allow him into politics with there well oiled machine


we are fucked so accept it and we are just having a theoretical debate here

and fight like crazy when they try to take away what you got while not touching that 80% of social wealth that the top 10% have stolen by their control of the system

Agreed take a look at some of the recent collapses and the people affected.... it's usually not the ones at the top who are hurting. Some walk away quite handsomely compensated.
 
A rational discussion can't be had if one side doesn't even understand what the issue is about.

A freeze was agreeable, having a contract legistlated without negotiations (as per the traditional route) was not agreeable.

All the stuff about being overpaid, good benefits, long holidays and extracurriculars distracts from the point above.

It's kinda like this..... I'm sure teachers understand that there is a limit to what the government can afford. But being forced to help out with the limit is far different than being asked. If you and a friend were out for dinner and for whatever reason the bill came up short. If your friend reached over and took money out of your wallet.... you'd probably be pissed because it was unnecessary for them to do that.
 
teachers do not get paid for extraciricular so how can you be mad at them for refusng to work for free ????


that seems totally unreasonable


Teachers enjoy benefits that other vocations do not, namely: summers off, limited hours with prep time, gold-plated pension second to none, and for Ontario, being one of the highest paid teachers in North America.