mur11 said:
You`re wrong about protected anal sex being as risky as anal sex without a condom. Very very wrong.
No, mur, i`m right, always right. Haven`t you noticed? To err is human, to be lenny is divine ;
But, seriously, in the absence of any info to the contrary from you, why should i believe you?
Why should you believe you? For all i know you are just emotionally reacting from mind numbing
brainwashing leading to blind faith in an almighty con-dumb.
mur11 said:
You`re wrong about protected anal sex being as risky as anal sex without a condom. Very very wrong.
Just to be clear here, what i said was risk re HIV, not STIs, diarrhea, constipation or gas.
Moreover, the comparison is between anal sex with a condom & bareback vaginal sex.
You do understand the fact that anal sex is much more risky than vaginal sex, right?
mur11 said:
The fact that you get your information from a website called the `straight dope` is unfortunate.
There`s a lot more to my viewpoint on this subject than info from that article. But, now that
you mention it, perhaps the most pertinent comment from it as regards our subject is this:
"Though research is thin, one study claims unprotected anal sex subjects a heterosexual woman to between 20 and 500 times the risk of HIV infection compared to unprotected regular sex."
Given that is the case, condoms would have to provide at least 20 times more protection
vs HIV, relative to being condomless, in order for covered anal sex just to have any chance
of even being equally as safe re HIV as BB vaginal sex.
Do you think condoms give 20 times as much protection as when you don`t use one? Only
the most optomistic estimates i`ve read say they do, and that is for vaginal sex. Furthermore,
in anal sex, it has been claimed, condoms may break more easily.
Here`s a question posed as food for thought. Why do you think there`s such an epidemic of HIV
amongst homosexuals & gay sex workers, much more so than the heterosexual populations?
Maybe something to do with the hole they prefer to stick it in?
mur11 said:
The fact that you get your information from a website called the `straight dope` is unfortunate.
If the "research is thin" on this topic, as the above article stated, where do you want me to get it?
I doubt many people here would understand research studies anyway.
So how can we figure out which of the two sex acts in question is riskier re HIV?
To calculate that you need to know how often condoms fail & how much they reduce risk for HIV relative to condomless sex. Is it 5, 10, or 20 times more risky not using a condom compared to using one?
Then comparing that number to the increased risk of anal sex over vaginal sex, one finds out which act is riskier, vaginal BBFS or covered Greek. Is anal 5, 10, or 20 times riskier than vaginal?
If the answer is about 10 in both cases, then the two are of similar HIV risk.
"As regards unprotected heterosexual contacts...estimates for high-income countries are 0.04% per act for female-to-male transmission, and 0.08% per act for male-to-female transmission.[33] The risk of transmission from anal intercourse is especially high, estimated as 1.4–1.7% per act in heterosexual as well as homosexual contacts.[33]..."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HIV/AIDS#Transmission
That implies that anal sex is about 20 to 40 times more risky re the disease than vaginal sex.
"The risk reduction of safe sex is not absolute; for example the reduced risk to the receptive partner of acquiring HIV from HIV seropositive partners not wearing condoms compared to when they wear them is estimated to be about four to fivefold.[5]...During each act of anal intercourse, the risk of the receptive partner acquiring HIV from HIV seropositive partners not using condoms is about 1 in 120. Among people using condoms, the receptive partner`s risk declines to 1 in 550, a four to fivefold reduction.[5]...Anal sex is a higher risk activity than vaginal intercourse because the thin tissues of the anus and rectum can be easily damaged.[36][37] Slight injuries can allow the passage of bacteria and viruses, including HIV. This includes by the use of anal toys. Condoms may be more likely to break during anal sex than during vaginal sex, increasing the risk.[38]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safe_sex
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safe_se...ective_methods
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Safe_sex#Anal_sex
"A healthy man who has unprotected sex with a non drug-using woman has a one in 5 million chance of getting HIV. If he wears a condom, the odds drop to one in 50 million."
http://www.psychologytoday.com/articles/200706/five-shocking-stats-about-men-and-sex
The above quotes suggest condoms make one 4 to 10 times safer re HIV than not using a condom.
They also imply that anal sex is about 20 to 40 times more risky re the disease than vaginal sex.
Together, that would mean that vaginal BBFS is 2 to 10 times less risky re HIV than covered anal genital intercourse.
Finally, here is a quote from a worker in the statistics field & the Health Nurse`s reply
to a query about it at the url below.
Well....yes. Statically speaking of course. Anal sex with condom is MORE risky for transmitting Hiv over BBFS.
This is using statistics. With condom manufactures claimed effectiveness ratings. Most I believe say 97% per use, or sometimes 85% effective over a year. Its easiest to use the 97% as who knows how often they think people have sex in a year. Combined with current medical estimates for Hiv transmission for receiving anal sex, compared to vaginal sex. Which is 10-50 times more likely. If we use these numbers, the two sex acts risks are very close. If we use the figure of 10 times higher transmission anal over vaginal..then anal sex with condom is roughly a third the chance of contracting hiv over vaginal. If we use the 50 times figure. Then anal sex with a condom, is about a 50% greater chance to contract hiv over bbfs.
This is just me using figures provided by the condom manufactures, along with figures from current medical estimates. With some basic second year stats.
But regardless, both acts are very similar in risk, within a magnitude for sure. No matter what methodology or ranges you use.
Currently one is a common offering, the other is considered a deathwish.
https://perb.cc/vbulletin/showthrea...m-risks&p=1242344&highlight=greek#post1242344