Ontario Court of Appeal greenlights brothels, sweeps aside many of Canada’s anti-pros

You think SP's and agencies will eat the licensing and taxes?

Depends... how much less likely are you to book an SP if her price goes up by $20? If everyone's still going to book anyway then you will pay the $20. If few people would still book she will pay the cost. My guess is it's a split, prices rise a bit, and SP's eat some of the licensing cost.
 
Doesn't it actual say that the current status remains for 12 months, giving time for the government to rewrite the (now) illegal laws? There sounds like a way to go yet before we can call brothels "legal".

As I read the NP coverage the Court has withheld implementation of the ruling for 12 months to allow the Cons to draft a new law(s).
You are correct the decision is stayed for a year to allow Parliament if it so wishes to attempt to rewrite the law such that it would comply with the Charter.
 
Unfortunately we have a Conservative majority government.... hate to throw cold water on the party, but their moral majority base will demand the law be rewritten.
I wouldn't make a prediction. But as I understand the state of things, if prostitution itself had been a criminal offence—like the associated avails, communicating, and bawdyhouse offences—then there would have been no argument that those laws deprived any sex worker of their right to engage in a legal activity. Which would leave the Cons opposing this judgement two options: Take it to the SCC, and risk yet another unanimous defeat, or pass legislation to close this loophole and make acts of prostitution as illegal as the supporting activities already are.

It won't help them think sensibly to rush about the streets shrieking "Brothels are legal" and frightening the horses.
 
Take it to the SCC, and risk yet another unanimous defeat, or pass legislation to close this loophole and make acts of prostitution as illegal as the supporting activities already are.

What they will actually do is get a bunch of lawyers together to pore over the ruling and come back in a few months with a recommendation as to what is the most draconian law the SCC would actually accept.
 
Unfortunately we have a Conservative majority government.... hate to throw cold water on the party, but their moral majority base will demand the law be rewritten.
We dont have a Conservative majority government in Ontario, we have a Liberal govt.

Its quite plausible Ontario becomes only CDN province to legalize prostitution, much like Nevada does
 
We dont have a Conservative majority government in Ontario, we have a Liberal govt.

Its quite plausible Ontario becomes only CDN province to legalize prostitution, much like Nevada does

I'm just curious - Can a province "opt out" of a section of the Criminal Code of Canada?
 
What they will actually do is get a bunch of lawyers together to pore over the ruling and come back in a few months with a recommendation as to what is the most draconian law the SCC would actually accept.
Perhaps I will be unpleasantly surprised, however, I do not believe this is going to occur.
 
We dont have a Conservative majority government in Ontario, we have a Liberal govt.

Its quite plausible Ontario becomes only CDN province to legalize prostitution, much like Nevada does

I'm just curious - Can a province "opt out" of a section of the Criminal Code of Canada?


I have no idea, but I do know that states have jurisdiction over criminal offences in the US whereas it is a Federal matter here.


Polls run in major newspapers shows a majority of Canadians want prostitution legalized:

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...in-bid-to-protect-prostitutes/article2381372/

http://www.cp24.com/

Canadians are generally pretty liberal and laissez faire. But our sense of NIMBY is quite strong.

I wonder what the over/under is that the government skips the appeal and just passes legislation to make prostitution illegal?

That probably makes more sense, if their objective is to keep it restricted.





The marketspace for massage parlours just got a whole lot more crowded.
 
I'm just curious - Can a province "opt out" of a section of the Criminal Code of Canada?

Yes, it's called the non-withstanding clause. Bourassa used it for the language laws.

It's not something a Premier would use lightly, especially since national opinion favourises prostitution.
 
Yes, it's called the non-withstanding clause. Bourassa used it for the language laws.

It's not something a Premier would use lightly, especially since national opinion favourises prostitution.

That's for the Constitution, not the Crim Code?
 
I'm just curious - Can a province "opt out" of a section of the Criminal Code of Canada?
No, because that isn't what has occurred a Province has no authority over criminal law in Canada. This is a court ruling.

But, what you are attempting to say is the Federal Government's best argument for having this heard before the SCC. There is now what in the U.S. would be termed a divergence in the Circuits - e.g. after a year with no action certain things would be legal in Ontario that are not legal in the rest of the country.
 
Yes, it's called the non-withstanding clause. Bourassa used it for the language laws.
I stand ready to be corrected but since the 1867 Constitutional Act/BNA specifically gave the authority for Criminal Law to the Federal Government, I do not believe a Province can use "not-withstanding" with regard to the Criminal Law.
 
So really this has the biggest impact on incalls? It shouldn't effect outcalls at all, as they were already within the law.

The "new" laws seem to be trying to get girls off the street (streetwalkers) and into private areas away from the public. So, this could have a massive impact on incalls.

If Ontario play this right, it could be a huge amount of income for the province - especially as we are on the doorstep of America. I can't imagine how much $$$ American's would bring into Niagara if incalls were totally legal there!
 
So really this has the biggest impact on incalls? It shouldn't effect outcalls at all, as they were already within the law.

The "new" laws seem to be trying to get girls off the street (streetwalkers) and into private areas away from the public. So, this could have a massive impact on incalls.

If Ontario play this right, it could be a huge amount of income for the province - especially as we are on the doorstep of America. I can't imagine how much $$$ American's would bring into Niagara if incalls were totally legal there!
Yes on the first two points as I read the decision. And I would agree with what you say in your third paragraph.