YMMV is just that.. and different for every girl I am sure.
As for me... nice guys/gentlemen/sweethearts/guys who talk a lot/communicate/funny guys/those who have something interesting to say -- i've caught myself giving them more attention.
The problem here is that guys often confuse physical attraction for ATTRACTION with women -- we do not think the same as men.

Emotionally driven, not visually (Not to say that we do not appreciate a good looking guy.. Just like you guys appreciate a smart/funny/sweet girl.)
Ive fallen head over heels for guys who are not the best looking to start off with, but after you get to know them via their personality become the most attractive man ive seen at that point.

And I can easily be repulsed by a physically attractive guy based just on how he acts, what he says etc..