Have they ever "re-called" a pope?.....

Doctrinally, the Pope is infallible and therefore, all his decisions are unarguably correct. It's only the critics and whiners who are in error.

So why should they recall him?

The only real remedy is to set up an Anti-Pope in Avignon to struggle with the first Pope for the control of the Catholic church.

Aardy, there's no statute of limitations in Canada for felonies.
 
Under what power did he do that?


The President can pardon Federal offenses he cannot pardon state offenses (only the Governor of that State can do that)

Then a state AG may be able too make a case for state prosecution, though I don't know enough too know how you would argue state jurisdiction in what is an international conspiracy too protect child raping preists from prosecution
 
Then a state AG may be able too make a case for state prosecution, though I don't know enough too know how you would argue state jurisdiction in what is an international conspiracy too protect child raping preists from prosecution

Child-buggery would actually seem to be a state offence. In the US, criminal law is a state jurisdiction. (In Canada, it's federal BTW.) If the crime occurred within the territory of the state and contravened the state laws, then the state has jurisdiction to prosecute. Conspiracies to cover the crime must also be triable by the state concerned or else the system would make no sense.
 
Then a state AG may be able too make a case for state prosecution, though I don't know enough too know how you would argue state jurisdiction in what is an international conspiracy too protect child raping preists from prosecution
It can and has been done, but in this instance it would be difficult - and a complicated explanation as to why.
 
It can and has been done, but in this instance it would be difficult - and a complicated explanation as to why.

I think we can accept "extraditing and prosecuting the pope" would be difficult without the actual explanation. Sure would be nice too see somebody try though
 
Doctrinally, the Pope is infallible and therefore, all his decisions are unarguably correct. It's only the critics and whiners who are in error.

So why should they recall him?

The only real remedy is to set up an Anti-Pope in Avignon to struggle with the first Pope for the control of the Catholic church.

Aardy, there's no statute of limitations in Canada for felonies.

I was pretty much going to say the same thing. Furthermore, the Church spins the doctrine of forgiveness: "Forgive our sins, as we have forgiven those who have trespassed against us,"

Until governement decide to enforce separation of Church and State, these scum will continue to get re-assigned. I'm hoping the rash of molestation cases does force governments to act and start prosecuting priests, however, forget about taking Ratzinger down. He's not only #1 of the RCC, he's also head of a State... Diplomatic Immunity
 
Doctrinally, the Pope is infallible and therefore, all his decisions are unarguably correct. It's only the critics and whiners who are in error.

...there's no statute of limitations in Canada for felonies.

I may be wrong, but I think that Canon law dictates that the Pope is only 'infallible' when speaking 'ex cathedra'. I think that the Pope's actions/inactions of which he is being blamed have nothing to do with Church doctrine or dogma, thus making him open to fallibility.

The issue isn't so much as to whether Ben XVI should quit. It should be whether individual Catholics can still have faith in a Church that is accused of these heinous acts of abuse, heirarchical ignorance & cover up.

It may result that Ben XVI's flock will have tremendously shrunken because followers have had enough of this crap. That would be exponentially worse than having a bad Pope.

And we don't have 'felonies' in Canada. That's a distinctively American term. We have 'indictable offences' instead. (Sorry, I don't mean to be picky.)
 
The abuse is unforgivable and reprehensible. Those guilty of it should be kicked out of the Church and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. I think priests should be allowed to marry.

Some comments on other comments in this thread:

- there are a billion Catholics in the world and something like a half million priests. The vast vast vast majority of the priests are normal, loving, caring people who are as appalled by all this abuse as we are

- the failings of the Catholic Church are the failings of human beings. A Catholic is not going to drop his beliefs because a handful of assholes are criminals. The actions of these creeps does not change the word of God. Those of you who don't believe or who hate the Church for whatever reason will make fun of this, but so what?

- the Pope is infallible in matters pertaining to the interpretation of God's word/God's will. That's all. He is as human as the rest of us and can/has/will make bad decisions in regards to everything else. If you aren't Catholic or if you don't accept Peter as the rock and all that stuff, then you don't believe in the Catholic interpretation of the bible and so the Pope's infallibility is all science fiction to you anyways.

Again, the abusers are sick fucks who should swing for their crimes. Doesn't mean people are going to abandon their faith.
 
The abuse is unforgivable and reprehensible. Those guilty of it should be kicked out of the Church and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. I think priests should be allowed to marry.

Some comments on other comments in this thread:

- the failings of the Catholic Church are the failings of human beings. A Catholic is not going to drop his beliefs because a handful of assholes are criminals. The actions of these creeps does not change the word of God. Those of you who don't believe or who hate the Church for whatever reason will make fun of this, but so what?

Again, the abusers are sick fucks who should swing for their crimes. Doesn't mean people are going to abandon their faith.

First, the abuse is horrible enough. What is so offensive on top of it is that the heirarchy let the abusers loose into the flock when they knew of their problems. Or that the hierarchy protected these evil priests when perhaps they should have let justice serve its course. It is the structural pratice of covering up the abuse or not keeping the pedophiles away from kids that is pissing Catholics off today. It also doesn't help when your #1 guy is being accused of doing exactly those things.

Second, while it may be apples & oranges, it wasn't that long ago that Martin Luther thumb-tacked his 95 complaints of Church abuses on a cathedral door. The result was the largest migration of Catholics away from the Church ever. I think they may have called that the Protestant Reformation, you may have heard of it. Don't underestimate the fragility of a church-goer's devotion. Shit, the numbers have dwindled down in the last 2 generations without any help from scandals & abuses like these. Their faith may not crumble, but they may just have had enough of Rome & go elsewhere for Christian salvation. It's been happening for the last 500 years.
 
Second, while it may be apples & oranges, it wasn't that long ago that Martin Luther thumb-tacked his 95 complaints of Church abuses on a cathedral door. The result was the largest migration of Catholics away from the Church ever. I think they may have called that the Protestant Reformation, you may have heard of it. Don't underestimate the fragility of a church-goer's devotion. Shit, the numbers have dwindled down in the last 2 generations without any help from scandals & abuses like these. Their faith may not crumble, but they may just have had enough of Rome & go elsewhere for Christian salvation. It's been happening for the last 500 years.

Are you advocating further heresies such as those of the Lutheran sect, SH?

If so, then it is high time that His Holiness re-summoned......... the Holy Inquisition.
 
Last edited:
First, the abuse is horrible enough. What is so offensive on top of it is that the heirarchy let the abusers loose into the flock when they knew of their problems. Or that the hierarchy protected these evil priests when perhaps they should have let justice serve its course. It is the structural pratice of covering up the abuse or not keeping the pedophiles away from kids that is pissing Catholics off today. It also doesn't help when your #1 guy is being accused of doing exactly those things.
Great point. It makes them just as guilty.
 
The question is why is it so accepted in society? Average sentences usually around couple of years and yet no out cry for longer sentences. Simple answer is castration and branding.
 
Our descendants will look back on this and marvel at the reluctance the general public has shown to prosecute these pedophiles. It is sad the victims have to suffer, and see the majority of these criminals get away with their crimes. If there's a silver lining here, lets hope that it is increasing disenchantment with organized religion.
 
The abuse is unforgivable and reprehensible. Those guilty of it should be kicked out of the Church and prosecuted to the fullest extent of the law. I think priests should be allowed to marry.

Some comments on other comments in this thread:

- there are a billion Catholics in the world and something like a half million priests. The vast vast vast majority of the priests are normal, loving, caring people who are as appalled by all this abuse as we are

- the failings of the Catholic Church are the failings of human beings. A Catholic is not going to drop his beliefs because a handful of assholes are criminals. The actions of these creeps does not change the word of God. Those of you who don't believe or who hate the Church for whatever reason will make fun of this, but so what?

- the Pope is infallible in matters pertaining to the interpretation of God's word/God's will. That's all. He is as human as the rest of us and can/has/will make bad decisions in regards to everything else. If you aren't Catholic or if you don't accept Peter as the rock and all that stuff, then you don't believe in the Catholic interpretation of the bible and so the Pope's infallibility is all science fiction to you anyways.

Again, the abusers are sick fucks who should swing for their crimes. Doesn't mean people are going to abandon their faith.
Good post CapitalGuy.