Obama and the General

Lara Logan has SERIOUS bias on this issue.....the least of which is that her husband is a defense contractor based out of Texas.They tend to like conflict.It's good for business.
 
One wonders quite what background Speaker Pelosi has that makes her qualified (and which makes her feel qualified) to second guess the best advice that General McChrystal's staff have given him, and that he agrees with.

Pelosi is not questioning his advice. She thinks he should keep his opinions out of the MSM until a strategy and plan for the changing Afghan situation are arrived at. Note that Pelosi doesnt really believe more American lives should be wasted on Afghanistan.

BTW, in the same quote(by the OP) there is an allusion to the firing of Maccarthur because of alleged differences with President truman. Actually, maccarthur was fired because he was completely incompetent and totally mismanaged and misunderstood the Chinese offensive.
 
Right now is hesitation is percieved as weakness by the enemy. Instead, he needs to be percieved as being decisive and supportive of the military.

If Obama was smart he should commit to more troups but decline to give actual numbers. This will buy him some time until he can decide how best to handle it.

Also, it's never a good idea for politicians to make military decisions for the sake of political exediency.

I just hope he looks more to Afghanistan than the mid-term elections to make this call.......

OTB
 
This is well worth the time it takes to watch.... this reporter has been on the ground in the ME since 2001.....

http://www.cbsnews.com/video/watch/?id=5371892n&tag=api

OTB

Her husbands a military contractor based out of texas with his fingers in the Iraq pie.They tend like things that go boom.Bit of a bias for her reporting of needing more military intervention.That was 10 seconds of research.i'll do more later
 
Her husbands a military contractor based out of texas with his fingers in the Iraq pie.
Have you signed the fire Andrea Mitchell petition? After all her husband is Allen Greenspan, and yet throughout she has remained a senior Washington correspondent for NBC.
 
Have you signed the fire Andrea Mitchell petition? After all her husband is Allen Greenspan, and yet throughout she has remained a senior Washington correspondent for NBC.

Oooo Aardvark154, you're getting me sexually aroused thinking of lesbian sex when you fire against Andrea Mitchell. I want a lesbian to kick her right in between her anus and the bottom of her pussy lips (that area right there), if you read my posts, for that exact same reason.

Gyaos Baltar.
 
Oooo Aardvark154, you're getting me sexually aroused thinking of lesbian sex when you fire against Andrea Mitchell. I want a lesbian to kick her right in between her anus and the bottom of her pussy lips (that area right there), if you read my posts, for that exact same reason.

Gyaos Baltar.
Sorry Gyaos, I wouldn't touch Andrea Mitchell with a barge pole!
 
That's not really true. There have been plenty of cases of Senior Military Officers advising that a smaller force is all that is necessary, or not to invade in a particular spot.

Generally more manpower and greater firepower saves lives and although it is shocking to most doves, Generals and Admirals want victory to come at the cost of the fewest lives possible.

Aardvark154 & McChrystal are both correct - there's a military adage regarding personnel: "the more you use, the less you lose". More troops would likely result in proportionally fewer casualties. And, IMHO, McChrystal is correct in wanting to change the nature of the mission. As long as Afghanis view you as an invader, you are a target. How you'll remain on the ground there and not be considered an invader is something I haven't figured out and frankly don't beleive is possible, but hopefully he's figured it out. McChrystal's biggest problem is actually what got him the top job to begin with, and the initial article has already shown that. He's spent most of his military career in special operation forces, and beleive it or not, chain of command there isn't as big of a deal as in anywhere else in the military. Tactical command often supercedes rank. Shit happens and you have to adapt. Thats one of the reasons why these guys are considered "special" because they have alot more freedom to do that without having to go up the chain of command. Poor McChrystal is doing what he's spent 20ish years being trained and training others to do, and he's getting criticized over it.
Said it before & I'll say it again.......completely f**cked up situation & Canada would do well to get out ASAP
 
Don't seem to hear much about any US wins or taking out any taliban/al queda strongholds with ensuing enemy casualties. Only seem to hear about suicide bombings, roadside bombings and our allied soldiers being picked off. What the hell is actually going on over there? Are we advancing and taking out enemy outposts or sitting around waiting for more troops to be deployed?
 
Have you signed the fire Andrea Mitchell petition? After all her husband is Allen Greenspan, and yet throughout she has remained a senior Washington correspondent for NBC.

I was referring to her advocation of escalation and his direct line to a industry that would benefit.Not sure what the connection but sure.....fire her..works for me.
 
Don't seem to hear much about any US wins or taking out any taliban/al queda strongholds with ensuing enemy casualties. Only seem to hear about suicide bombings, roadside bombings and our allied soldiers being picked off. What the hell is actually going on over there? Are we advancing and taking out enemy outposts or sitting around waiting for more troops to be deployed?

The media does not report the good work and the many victories - both tactical and humanitarian - that Western troops are achieving in Afghanistan. This is the biggest problem Western governments currently have in their efforts to convince their respective populations that the war in Afghanistan is a good war. From a civilians point of view, NOTHING is heard about Afghanistan until another soldier dies. Of course, there are countless activities going on over there every day. It is a failure of the media to tell a balanced story and a failure of the government to get that story out there.
 
The media does not report the good work and the many victories - both tactical and humanitarian - that Western troops are achieving in Afghanistan. This is the biggest problem Western governments currently have in their efforts to convince their respective populations that the war in Afghanistan is a good war. From a civilians point of view, NOTHING is heard about Afghanistan until another soldier dies. Of course, there are countless activities going on over there every day. It is a failure of the media to tell a balanced story and a failure of the government to get that story out there.

That is true, but what is also true is libreals in North America are all for helping the poor and oppressed, and promoting women's rights, but they are not willing to die to defend them, and they are not willing to fight for them to be extended to people who cannot vote for them.

The sad truth is, 9/11 is a piece of history for the left, and they want us all to just go back to that blissful state of ignorance we had in the Clinton years. Bin Laden was hitting the US in various ways, and Bill just looked the other way to it. Now we are in Afghanistan because of the harbouring of Al Quaida there and we now have to do something besides keep the Taliban out. We must try to reshape their economic future and improve the living conditions of a country that once was actually functioning to a degree before the Russians showed up in 1980. So the Americans, UK, Canada, Danes and Dutch are now losing people trying to fight a group who will turn the country back to the Muslim 13th century, and a country that allowed Bin Laden to run his operation with impunity. Losing in Afghanistan isn't much of an option, yet there is little will or understanding to what we are doing there.

Obama can stand up to the promise he gave the people of the US when he ran to win in Afghanistan by giving McChrystal the men to stablize the country. When that happens, all the humanitarian stuff can happen. What the left hasn't figured out, and you can see this by the naivety of people like Jack Layton in Canada or some of the naive idiots in the US is the humanitarian mission cannot happen if the Taliban shows up and blows your aid workers sky high, or blows up the schools and housing they build sky high. You need troops on the ground to stop the nonsense while a society strong enough to fend it off is created. Right now, we are at the tipping point...and Obama is waffling. I am not surprised....it is what libreal politicians do when they are confronted with a reality that doesn't match their naivety.....

Barack, you picked this guy to go over there and tell you how to win the war. Now you wont listen to him. Last time I looked, organzing for ACORN on the south side of Chicago didn't make you a military leader.......listen to the man and put the boots on the ground. When the violence ceases, it is out of the news, and you can go back to not getting Healthcare passed in Congress....
 
That is true, but what is also true is libreals in North America are all for helping the poor and oppressed, and promoting women's rights, but they are not willing to die to defend them, and they are not willing to fight for them to be extended to people who cannot vote for them.

The sad truth is, 9/11 is a piece of history for the left, and they want us all to just go back to that blissful state of ignorance we had in the Clinton years. Bin Laden was hitting the US in various ways, and Bill just looked the other way to it. Now we are in Afghanistan because of the harbouring of Al Quaida there and we now have to do something besides keep the Taliban out. We must try to reshape their economic future and improve the living conditions of a country that once was actually functioning to a degree before the Russians showed up in 1980. So the Americans, UK, Canada, Danes and Dutch are now losing people trying to fight a group who will turn the country back to the Muslim 13th century, and a country that allowed Bin Laden to run his operation with impunity. Losing in Afghanistan isn't much of an option, yet there is little will or understanding to what we are doing there.

Obama can stand up to the promise he gave the people of the US when he ran to win in Afghanistan by giving McChrystal the men to stablize the country. When that happens, all the humanitarian stuff can happen. What the left hasn't figured out, and you can see this by the naivety of people like Jack Layton in Canada or some of the naive idiots in the US is the humanitarian mission cannot happen if the Taliban shows up and blows your aid workers sky high, or blows up the schools and housing they build sky high. You need troops on the ground to stop the nonsense while a society strong enough to fend it off is created. Right now, we are at the tipping point...and Obama is waffling. I am not surprised....it is what libreal politicians do when they are confronted with a reality that doesn't match their naivety.....

Barack, you picked this guy to go over there and tell you how to win the war. Now you wont listen to him. Last time I looked, organzing for ACORN on the south side of Chicago didn't make you a military leader.......listen to the man and put the boots on the ground. When the violence ceases, it is out of the news, and you can go back to not getting Healthcare passed in Congress....

You nailed it right on.
 
Personally I did not think either he or McCain were the right person for the job.


What has he accomplished?

Ok having a swing set built on the White House lawn is huge.

Pappy - it will take a lot longer than 9 months to right the wrongs of 8 years worth of George W. Bush !!!!

Barack Obama is off to an absolutely great start - and the majority of people around the world <includng in your own country> agree as well !

Pappy - if you are not part of the solution - you must be part of the problem !

Cheers Pappy - and go Barack go - 2 full terms !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Sad part is, Obama should be able to see all of it. Afghanistan is burning what is left of his political capital domestically. If it keeps popping up in the news, he cant accomplish what he wants to do with healthcare. He is trying to appease his leftwing zealots who he feels most at home with, but that damned reality thing keeps getting in the way.
 
Sad part is, Obama should be able to see all of it. Afghanistan is burning what is left of his political capital domestically. If it keeps popping up in the news, he cant accomplish what he wants to do with healthcare. He is trying to appease his leftwing zealots who he feels most at home with, but that damned reality thing keeps getting in the way.

..... it's not a sad part Bearlythere - Obama can see "all of it" and he sees quite clearly "all of what he inherited" - and he has only been in office for 9 short months. Be patient - he will fix all of the problems that George created - in due course.

As you have seen in some other posts - he has already "fixed" a lot of things for myself personally < and for millions of others for sure >, and he will "fix" things even for you too - in time. Just be patient Bearlythere - just be patient.
 
..... it's not a sad part Bearlythere - Obama can see "all of it" and he sees quite clearly "all of what he inherited" - and he has only been in office for 9 short months. Be patient - he will fix all of the problems that George created - in due course.

As you have seen in some other posts - he has already "fixed" a lot of things for myself personally < and for millions of others for sure >, and he will "fix" things even for you too - in time. Just be patient Bearlythere - just be patient.

I am patient. I am patiently hoping that all but you Kool Aid drinkers will see the fraud this guy is.

HE fixed things for you personally? Right..your stock portfolio. Like Barack had ANYTHING to do with you buying the right stocks.

How is that 10% unemployment rate? The Record deficit? Healthcare reform? the stagnant economy? Obama close Gitmo? He said he would but hasn't? HAsn't figured out what to do with the guys there. Apparently they don't like the US and didn't before The CIA and Bush put them in Gitmo. He got the US out of Iraq? oh right...and we are already seeing how he isn't fixing Afghanistan

Ya...Obama hasn't fixed much, but unlike a lot of naive people, I don't expect the POTUS to actually have all the answers. I am just waiting for him to make decisions that at least allow for the economy to grow. It may do that because of or in spite of him, but it hasn't happened yet. I am at least waiting for him to do what he said he was going to do, and that is WIN in Afghanistan. He hand picks this general to go over there and assess the needs, and then ignores him and his report when he gets answers that don't fit with the libreal template. I have NO faith in this president on this one.....libreals don't do reality well when they have to solve a problem with a solution that doesn't fit with their naive notions on how the world works.
 
It's sucks having to clean up the MESS the conservative morons like Dubya & DICK left the USA & World.....:rolleyes:



The problems we face today will not be solved by the minds that created them
 
It's sucks having to clean up the MESS the conservative morons like Dubya & DICK left the USA & World.....:rolleyes:



The problems we face today will not be solved by the minds that created them

It hasn't happened Woody. Your Hero hasn't done squat. SNL has a nice skit making light of that...you should watch it.