Stripper vs The Federal Taxman

definitely. He is also in his 80s and could possibly leave some money for her in his will.
 
(From The Star)

"What blossomed was an 11-year relationship that quickly took on – according to Landry's court testimony – a "father-daughter" dynamic. :D

Landry would often accompany her benefactor to the Montreal casino, where he would give her the winnings to deposit in her account."

LOL Nice Dad!
 
JohnFK said:
A gift is a gift. If she received the money for lap dances, then it's a different story. As long as it wasn't part of a 'transaction'. I'm sure the customer confirmed these were gifts.

I'm sure the feds have a clause for this but I know even a relative can only give another relative a specific amount. Anything over that amount is taxable. I have to assume that a gift from a non-relative also has limits???

Well, sounds like she won! Good for her putting CRA in its place. Now she has to deal with Quebec lol. You just can't win......
 
tboy said:
I'm sure the feds have a clause for this but I know even a relative can only give another relative a specific amount. Anything over that amount is taxable. I have to assume that a gift from a non-relative also has limits???

This is not true. There is no gift tax in Canada; there is no dollar limit on gifts.
 
JohnFK said:
I'm sure the customer confirmed these were gifts.

If you read the judgement (do NOT rely on the journalists' version of the case), the customer was not cooperative with the taxpayer and was questioned as a hostile witness. During the audit the taxpayer sought to protect the customer's identity, and when the customer was eventually questioned he denied making the gifts/payments. The judge found the customer's testimony less credible than that of the taxpayer, and found the CRA at fault for automatically believing the customer during the audit. Another factor that sunk the CRA's case was that they could not come up with a credible explanation where the money came from, if not from the customer.

Based on the judge's written decision, it was not seriously argued that the money was payment for services, as the customer had denied making the payments. The CRA could not identify any unreported income in her business. Thus the judge found the taxpayer's version of the facts the most credible of the alternatives presented to him, and he ruled accordingly.

What is funny about the judgement is that the judge refers to the customer as "Mr X" to conceal his identity; but then he names one of "Mr X's" companies by name, so it became a trivial exercise to identify him.
 
johnhenrygalt said:
This is not true. There is no gift tax in Canada; there is no dollar limit on gifts.

Then that's a big loophole in terms of moving $$ around to avoid paying taxes. All cash income could be declared as "gifts" from supportive friends and family, no?
 
what's to stop every dancer from here on out requesting customers pay them in gift cards or some variation thereof?specifically regulars? "father-daughter" right:rolleyes: oh to have a pretty vagina,just for a couple of years.
 
This story reminds me of two other strippers who struck it rich. Anna Nicole Smith who married an 89 year old billionaire and Denise Nadeau who was showered with over $1MM by a male patron. How many other strippers are receiving such largesse from their clients?
 
Serpent said:
Then that's a big loophole in terms of moving $$ around to avoid paying taxes. All cash income could be declared as "gifts" from supportive friends and family, no?

It's no loophole. Calling something a gift does not make it so.
 
Scarey said:
what's to stop every dancer from here on out requesting customers pay them in gift cards or some variation thereof?specifically regulars? "father-daughter" right:rolleyes: oh to have a pretty vagina,just for a couple of years.

Nothing would stop the parties from reaching such an agreement. As for the tax consequences, if the gift card was delivered in payment for services rendered, the fair market value of the gift card would be considered revenue in the hands of the dancer.
 
Yes. To be a "gift", it cannot be payment for services rendered. It must be freely given and not exchanged.

So being paid for pussy with gift cards is basically just earning a salary of gift cards - which is taxable as per their FMV, as stated above.
 
johnhenrygalt said:
It's no loophole. Calling something a gift does not make it so.

But how do you say that the $x,000 you received from someone is not a gift? "He liked me and therefore he gifted me the money!"

AFAIK, in the US, gifts are taxable up to a limit of USD 12,000 to the donor.