Any value in buying a quad core now?

Twister

Well-known member
Aug 24, 2002
4,984
694
113
GTA
My friend MB is blown and looking to replace the unit, its old. I'm looking around and I see some system with a Intel quad core q6600, 500mg, 4gig etc for 500 bucks, a clone. My concern is that not many programs are set up for quad core nowadays.
Is it a waste of money for a user that basically will be doing nothing special with the pc, and maybe better off saving the money and just get a core 2 or and AMD.? Or perhaps in the soon future common programs like office will be available to operate on a quad core?
Thanks
 
Twister said:
My friend MB is blown and looking to replace the unit, its old. I'm looking around and I see some system with a Intel quad core q6600, 500mg, 4gig etc for 500 bucks, a clone. My concern is that not many programs are set up for quad core nowadays.
Is it a waste of money for a user that basically will be doing nothing special with the pc, and maybe better off saving the money and just get a core 2 or and AMD.? Or perhaps in the soon future common programs like office will be available to operate on a quad core?
Thanks

The future is multi-core and newer O/S's like Windows 7 will make better use of them. For everyday surfing, email you won't notice any difference but for specific apps you can benefit big time. Excel 2007 is multi-threaded and here the extra cores makes a HUGE difference. Certain games (i.e. chess) scale very well to # of processors. Video encoding, photo editing will soon be/are multi-threaded as well. Personally I can never get enough processing power as I use specific apps that will max out all the processing cycles. If time is money, you will appreciate the extra speed.

The one thing to keep in mind is that a quad core chip like the Q6600 can consume twice as much power as a dual core.
 
Whether you have a dual core or a quad core isn't what will make the difference. And whether any given program is designed to make use of multiple cores won't make much of a difference to most users - your computer usually has about a dozen things to do; having multiple cores lets it do those things faster regardless of whether what you're focused on is making the absolute best use of it.

If you want to see how the Q6600 performs when compared with other cpu choices, check out the graphs at Tom's Hardware.
 
I tend to agree with Anynym. I would use Quad core in servers of course, but Dual vs. Quad for the average user won't make a difference as the average user doesn't really multitask in any real form. Let your pocket book decide.

Just my 2 cents.
 
If you don't do anything demanding or are not a 'gamer' you don't need a Quad or the even more higher performing Intel® Core™ i7 Processor that runs DDR3 RAM. If you want top performance specs, get an i7 with DDR3 RAM.

There is one advantage in PC longevity, in that a Quad core or and i7 processor will run further into the future than a dual core PC.

As far as apps/programs the move is to the 64 bit OS over the 32 bit OS.
A 64 bit OS runs leaner and more snappy than a 32 bit OS. This seems to be where development is heading rather than utilizing a Quad core better.
 
I just ordered a 2 X Quad with 8gb of memory and 2TB of disk..... getting into high-def video.....

OTB
 
Cool

What CPU speed?
Which brand?
What size monitor will it drive?
 
onthebottom said:
I just ordered a 2 X Quad with 8gb of memory and 2TB of disk..... getting into high-def video.....

OTB

Sounds like Mac Pro?

I'm seriously considering getting one myself for music production. Just bought the new Logic 9 and it is very efficiently programmed for multiple cores, and although I have 1 quad Hackintosh now already, the 8 core may be worth it now with the new software and snow leopard around the corner.
 
WoodPeckr said:
If you really want a high end box get one with an Intel® Core™ i7 Processor that uses DDR3 RAM. It blows away the Quad cores.....:cool:

Ya, I have an i7 920 right now on my main Windows box. It's pretty fast indeed. But i7's can't run more than one I don't believe, you need to step up to Xeon (i.e. Nehalem etc) and a server board if you want 2x, which is costly... a la Mac Pro.
 
It's a Mac Pro - lowest speed processors

I have a 23" Cinema display from Apple (with the aluminum case) that it will drive to start....

OTB
 
As everyone has already stated: multi core processors aren't needed unless you're running a lot of apps at the same time.

If you're just doing word processing/email/internet a P4 will do just fine.

Heck, I'm running a P4 prescott and it's been fine for the past 5 yrs. Plays high def video, surround sound, a little slow if I have a lot of things running and then open a video or audio but other than that? It's fine.

Unless you really are pushing the envelope, it'd be better to invest in a good sound card and a better video card and memory.

I equate all the new processors with a Bugatti Veyron or a Gallardo on the dvp at rush hour: sure, it can do 200+ mph but do you need it to? Not in toronto..........
 
onthebottom said:
It's a Mac Pro - lowest speed processors

I have a 23" Cinema display from Apple (with the aluminum case) that it will drive to start....
Unless you really want/need it now, I'd wait a couple months till Snow Leopard is out then get it. Snow Leopard is a pure 64 bit OS and will run better than the present OS and you won't have to do the OS upgrade from 32bit to 64 bit.
 
snow leopard??? SNOW leopard? What a name for an operating system.

Oh man you Mac people are strange........
 
LOL!
Snow Leopard ain't bad.

Look at Ubuntu 9.04 which is called Jaunty Jackalope!....lol.
Next upgrade coming out October, Ubuntu 9.10 will be called Karmic Koala!...:D
 
WoodPeckr said:
Unless you really want/need it now, I'd wait a couple months till Snow Leopard is out then get it. Snow Leopard is a pure 64 bit OS and will run better than the present OS and you won't have to do the OS upgrade from 32bit to 64 bit.

I thought about that but deferred gratification isn't my strong point (actually brought me here, but that's another story) and I have HD video piling up and need a decent place to put it. I'll suffer thru the upgrade a pay the few bucks to do it when it's released (actually I'll probably wait 2-3 months and let the bugs shake out....)

OTB
 
I have to ask: why do you have HD video "piling" up? What difference does it make if the O/S is 32 or 64 bit other than the speed in which you load it?

HD video plays fine on my P4.......
 
tboy said:
I have to ask: why do you have HD video "piling" up? What difference does it make if the O/S is 32 or 64 bit other than the speed in which you load it?

HD video plays fine on my P4.......
Editing HD video .... The new macpro's are the Nehalem processors. I just got 20 of the SUn 4170s with Nehalem .... all the specs are lower then other processors .... but wow are they fast .... new architecture rocks.
 
ok, I can understand one needing the latest and greatest to edit HD video. ANY video for that matter.

Don't forget a proper video card and memory too. Something many forget about. A multicore processor is just one part of the whole system.
 
tboy said:
ok, I can understand one needing the latest and greatest to edit HD video. ANY video for that matter.

Don't forget a proper video card and memory too. Something many forget about. A multicore processor is just one part of the whole system.

Yes, I went with 8gb of memory and will see how that goes, the 2gb cards are cheep so I could double that if need be....

The (very smart) kid at my local Apple Dealer assured me that the video card I selected is plenty fast until I start getting into 3d animation or cad - not going to happen any time soon.

The move to intel has brought the internal upgrade prices down on the Mac Pro - 150 for 1T drives, cheap memeory.....

OTB