Einstein on God (and Jews)

Link to email?
 
This is about the third thread I’ve seen on terb in the last few days on Einstein and religion. I’m not sure why this is a surprise to so many people. I realize that his metaphoric use if words like god and religion are often misquoted by religious types. Moreover, there are plenty of references to his disbelief in a personal god in books, articles and websites. Moreover, there is also plenty of evidence that the more educated people are, the less likely they are to be religious. One survey of the members of the American National Academy of Sciences (arguably the intellectually elite in the U.S.) found that few were religious in the traditional sense. Einstein was a scientist and it seems to me that his views are fairly typical of scientists. I suspected that some religious types would not believe me and so I did a search and found plenty of references to the Larson and Witham survey, including the following:

http://scienceweek.com/2004/sb040102-1.htm

“The authors report "near universal rejection" of the transcendent by NAS natural scientists. Overall, 93 percent of NAS scientists do not profess a belief in God (72.2 percent disbelief, 20.8 agnostic), and 92.1 percent do not profess a belief in immortality (76.7 percent disbelief, 23.3 percent agnostic). Disbelief in God and immortality among NAS biological scientists was 65.2 percent and 69.0 percent respectively, and among NAS physical scientists it was 79 percent and 76.3 percent respectively.

3) As indicated, most of the rest define themselves as agnostics, with only few believers. The highest percentage of belief was found among NAS mathematicians: 14.3 percent belief in God, 15 percent belief in immortality. Biological scientists had the lowest rate of belief (5.5 percent in God, 7.1 percent in immortality), with physicists and astronomers slightly higher (7.5 percent in God, 7.5 percent in immortality).”
 
hadn't read it here....

sorry for the reiteration.

It does amaze me the number of people who believe Einstein was a theist. I seem to recall a few who post in politics and international affairs claiming it as well.

It's a new article on Yahoo news....
 
Yet I knew a Noble Laureate - Biological Sciences (now dead) - who was a very active Church member on parochial, regional, and national levels.
 
Is this surprising? Albert Einstein, was in most ways a typical late 19th century - early 20th century secularized German Jew.
 
Religion requires a leap of faith. Science looks for proof. Science appeals to those who seek knowledge. Religion is certainty of how things were created. The two are polar opposites yet some people can live in both worlds. Sometimes accepted theories in science become a form of dogma in themselves.
 
Never thought Albert Einstein typical.
For me sheer genius with a keen analytic mind light years beyond his contemporaries then and even now is how I'd define him. Einstein had his priorities right, scientific, ethical and moral unlike todays pretenders.

Religion demands primitive childlike faith and acquiescence while Science demands proof and skepticism. Religion thrives in primitive backwards cultures, Iran, a few other Arab countries, the Taliban and the Bible Belt in the USA are just a few examples of this. Give me Science over Religion anyday.
 
WoodPeckr said:
Never thought Albert Einstein typical.
For me sheer genius with a keen analytic mind light years beyond his contemporaries then and even now is how I'd define him. Einstein had his priorities right, scientific, ethical and moral unlike todays pretenders.
Really? Albert Einstein was a brilliant physicist, however, being brilliant doesn’t necessarily go with being well rounded - rather the opposite. Describing him as having his moral and ethical priorities correct, to my mind is a claim with serious problems given his treatment of his first wife and his children.
 
DQ - brilliant!

I too have questions about human morality and moratity
beyond the spectre of the possibity.

We take ourselves far too seriously on the Existential as
well as the Scientific possibilities.


You've outdone yourself. Really. Even if we ignore your spelling on 'possibity' and 'moratity'. (Though someone saying "moratity" is rather appropriate for terb.)

Your sheer overwhelming stupidity oozes out of almost every sentence you construct. It oozes "beyond the spectre of the possibity", to quote you.

That you would continue to write sentences that you don't know what they mean - Existential vs. Scientific? - leads to the ultimate of ironies, that it is you who takes yourself far too seriously.

Maroon.
 
Oh - and DQ -

Science doesn't make decisions.

And Science doesn't employ logic from philosophy to measure it's results.

Obviously, you don't know what science is; what logic is; or what philosophy is.

Lastly on science, science can address the human condition.

Now for religion:

It rarely, if ever deals with our "self-identity".

It certainly is at best only tangentially based on ancient wisdom; more ancient foolishness than ancient wisdom.

It rarely requires true accountability; but instead seems to demand the appearance of accountability.

Other than that, you're right.
 
Aardvark154 said:
Really? Albert Einstein was a brilliant physicist, however, being brilliant doesn’t necessarily go with being well rounded - rather the opposite. Describing him as having his moral and ethical priorities correct, to my mind is a claim with serious problems given his treatment of his first wife and his children.
Very interesting!
Then by your criteria you must truly hate Dubya, Cheney, Saddam etc., because by your very standards they have done and demonstrated far more serious problems than Einstein given their treatment of their own people and others who collaterally suffer from their peculiar moral and ethical priorities....correct?

Really, if you want to smear Einstein on those grounds I can't wait for you to smear Dubya, Cheney, Saddam who by your standards have trumped anything Einstein ever did in spades!....;)
 
zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzhuhzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz
 
DonQuixote said:
Science has no moral or ethical basis for its decision making.

Science employs logic from philosophy to measure its results.

Science does not address the human condition.

In short, science is about measurement and quantification.

Religion deals with our self-identity and relationship to others.

Religion is based on ancient wisdom and customs.

Religion requires the individual to be accountable for his conduct.
Yes, the bible (as just one example) is a great “moral or ethical basis for its decision making”. Levite’s giving his daughter and servant to the mob are great examples of parental love, as was Lot’s offer of this daughter to the mob. God’s instructions to commit genocide to those inside the walls of Jericho is also a great example of humanity in war. Let’s not forget the lesson of flooding the planet and killing millions.

In case any readers of this post, don’t realize it, I was being sarcastic above. The more I learn about religious writings, the more I understand the famous statement “Good men do good things, evil men do evil things but for good men to do evil things that requires religion”. I realize that you can argue that people pick and choose which parts of the bible they want to follow. However, if you are going to pick and chose which ethical lessons to follow anyway, why do you need religion. You can pick and choose ethical rules without religion? On the general topic of “moral or ethical basis for its decision making”, it is interesting to note that when people are presented with ethical dilemmas, they tend to select the same answers, regardless of their religion (or lack of religion), part of the world they come from, culture or level of development.

Edit: BTW, unlike the response of another poster, this is was not ment as a personal attack.
 
"ethical lesions?"

Honestly, the idea of an ethical lesion is in itself, interesting.

I kind of disagree with you, someone, on your claim:

It is interesting to note that when people are presented with ethical dilemmas, they tend to select the same answers, regardless of their religion (or lack of religion), part of the world they come from, culture or level of development.

I'll give you that you used the word 'tend'. But by and large, with the "ethical dilemmas" I've seen, the tendancy is that you get different answers from different people - even within the same culture.

But surely, on women's issues, for instance, there can be a wide array of responses; the same true of race.

And then if you look at the traditional ethical issues you see major splits - abortion for instance; the nuclear attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki; the firebombing of Dresden.

Cultural differences can be subtle, but sometimes significant - there is still, to a small extent, the practice of the "vendetta" on Corsica, for instance. Dorothy Carrington has argued forcefully that this practice is very much part of the moral fabric of their culture.

Then there are dilemmas like "Sophie's Choice", which seem to give everyone pause for thought - and you certainly don't get unanimous responses here.

Anyway....
 
someone said:
“Good men do good things, evil men do evil things but for good men to do evil things that requires religion”.
Great quote!
It also seems to be the playbook that inspires BOTH Team 'w' and Iran lately!....;)