Outplaying vs. Winning

new2game, you're absolutely right on about the scoreboard being the final arbiter and these guys just not getting it.
:)
I could point out some useful references on sports analysis to these guys - statistics as they pertain to hockey, comparing players, the usefulness and applicability of various stats, etc. I'm afraid they wouldn't have a clue what was being talked about, though.
 
Last edited:
For those of you who still don't grasp the concept:
the Leafs lost, having been outplayed by the Flyers in the series.

:)
 
Give it a rest. Nobody cares Ranger!
 
"blah blah blah" - random Ottawa Senator fan whining
 
"If the goaltender plays great, the entire team outplayed the other."

Therefore the corollary must be true as well:

"If the goaltender plays awful, the entire team was outplayed by the other."

Yes?
 
Goober Mcfly said:
"If the goaltender plays great, the entire team outplayed the other."

Therefore the corollary must be true as well:

"If the goaltender plays awful, the entire team was outplayed by the other."

Yes?

Of course - assuming the skaters couldn't overcome the deficit the goaltender put them in.
 
Ranger68 said:
Of course - assuming the skaters couldn't overcome the deficit the goaltender put them in.
So now the skaters' performance matters?
 
Who said it didn't matter before??
Come on, Goob, at least TRY to follow what I'm saying:
when you want to talk about the performance of a team *as a whole* (to use your terminology), you've got to factor in EVERYONE in their relative proportions.
That is, when Domi puts up a good game, it's not nearly as important to how well the team plays as when Belfour does, or Leetch (who plays more than twice as much).
 
Just say "The only thing that matters is the final score" and be done with it. Okay?

:rolleyes:
 
Fine. Stop saying "the Sens outplayed the Leafs" because, if you wanna talk about who outplayed whom, "the only thing that matters is the final score".
Okay?
:rolleyes:
Until that time ......
 
Ranger68 said:
Fine. Stop saying "the Sens outplayed the Leafs" because, if you wanna talk about who outplayed whom, "the only thing that matters is the final score".
That's your opinion.
 
Nope. It's a fact. And a testiment to either some fundamental lack of understanding on your part, or egregious stubborness.
Either way, clearly I won't be able to stop trying to make people see the truth for what it is.
That the Leafs outplayed the Sens.
:)
.......
Senators in Infinity!
 
Ranger68 said:
And a testiment to either some fundamental lack of understanding on your part, or egregious stubborness.
*hands Ranger68 a mirror*
 
"I know you are but what am I?!"

Nice comeback.

Hey, Goober, any time you want to actually try to have an intelligent discussion on the topic, we can do so. Last time, you just walked away from it saying "You'll never convince me!" So, who exactly, is the one who can't / won't understand?

I'm waiting.
 
Goober Mcfly said:
YOU say that goaltending is the most important part of a hockey team. I say, no. It is a VERY important part, but not the most important. If you don't have at least SOME offence, you're done. That's why I originally gave props to Nieuwendyk, Roberts and McCabe as well as Belfour. So, there you go: Belfour, Nieuwendyk, Roberts and McCabe OUTPLAYED the Senators. But that's as far as I'm willing to go, and everything I've said so far is my opinion only.

In MY opinion, MOST of the Senators players out-shot, out-hustled, out-worked, out-hit, out-chanced and out-played the Leafs. Generally speaking, of course. There were games that the Leafs out-played the Senators (game 5 for example). ON THE WHOLE, however, the Senators out-played the Leafs.

And there's absolutely NOTHING you're going to say that will make me think otherwise. Sorry.
An intelligent conversation goes both ways.

Here is my viewpoint, corroborated and agreed upon not only by other TERBites, but by the media writers and the Leafs' coaches and players as well.

But they're all wrong and you're right, correct?
 
First off, "appeal to authority" is a fine point to use when you're making a case. However, "other TERBites" don't really count when you're talking about "authorities on the subject". And some TERBites agree with me, so it's not even an accurate statement.

Now, as I've pointed out, when writers / coaches / mascots say that "one team outplayed another", they typically mean "the skaters". They do EXACTLY what you're doing - separating out the performance of the goaltender. This is understood. I'm not saying these experts are "wrong" - just that they're being imprecise. Coaches do it because they coach SKATERS. Most of them have NO CLUE what to do with goaltenders - that's why there are goaltender coaches. The coach deals with, talks about, analyzes THE SKATERS. Is this not bloody obvious?! Analysts then do the same thing - just parrot the coach. I'm sure the vast majority of these guys would understand what I'm talking about, so the only clear thing is that we're all right and YOU'RE wrong.

Goober, would it be accurate to say that "the Leafs, including Ed Belfour, were outplayed in the first round"?
Just answer the question, please. We can make this very quick.
 
Ranger68 said:
Goober, would it be accurate to say that "the Leafs, including Ed Belfour, were outplayed in the first round"?
Just answer the question, please. We can make this very quick.
Yes they were. It would be like me saying that "the Senators, with the exception of Patrick Lalime, outplayed the Leafs in the first round."

But that's not what I've been arguing.

My point is that the Leafs wouldn't have advanced (probably) had it not been for the stellar play of Ed Belfour. So, yes, Belfour outplayed the Senators. But the Senators skaters out-hit, out-shot, out-muscled, out-played the Leafs (generally).

Therefore, on the whole, the Senators team (90% of the roster) outplayed the Leafs.