Where do atheists get their morals? (The Atheist Experience)

Atheism is effectively incapable of generating its own morality. Atheists tend to borrow or imitate the dominant morals of the society they find themselves in, and then deny history.

Huh?

I have seen variations of this statement in a few places and it is always unsupported, usually boiling down to some kind of half baked notion that morals are absolute and ultimately anchored in god.
 
I have heard of empathy. It is lovely. IT is not universal. It is not a sufficient principle to build a civilization around.

And my understanding is that virtually every clan or tribe studied...had a religion.

Morality is not built in.

And by-the-by despite your speculation, we really don't know how clans and tribes first formed.
Who said it was built in? The desire and the need are built in; even animals have codes and rituals of behaviour. And some of our codes, like not eating our young, unlike cats for instance are too innate to require explicit prohibitions. Though eventually, after you invent all the mechanics of codified laws, you do arrive at a point where an offence and a law get put into words.

Some people, express that need by inventing gods who tell them what to make others do, and some figure that out themselves or with others. But the fact that all sorts of folks invented gods—just as they figured out fire—does not in any way prove that without inventing gods they wouldn't or couldn't have invented morals. You might consider, Confucius, Socrates and any number of philosophers among those who did without.

And we still haven't proven the 'godly morals' are any different, or better than any others.
 
I would think we all get our morals from our parents or whoever we spent our childhood around. Doesn't matter if they taught/modeled it because god told them to, if it was because it's the only way humans can live in large groups (is it okay to use evolution as a part of the argument?), or if that's what their parents taught them; the result is the same.
 
This kind of argument shows a fundamental lack of knowledge of how Christianity and Judaism work, or how they conceive god and his role.

I can't speak for other religions.

Atheism is effectively incapable of generating its own morality. Atheists tend to borrow or imitate the dominant morals of the society they find themselves in, and then deny history.

I'm pretty sure religious people created their own values as well.
 
I'm pretty sure religious people created their own values as well.

This misses the point. For the religious, morality essentially is what god says it is. This makes morality something other than just a code of conduct.

On a side (but related) note, I would like to say that all of these threads on religion seem pointless most of the time. It would save everyone a lot of time if folks would declare at the outset of a discussion whether they have faith, or not . Arguments between those with faith and those who recognize only reason are a waste of time. It is like an astronomer trying to disprove astrology.

Since about the age of 14, I have known I do not have faith. I remember the realization being kind of frightening and recall the reassuring feeling of believing in an afterlife. But I grew up.
 
We do? You just keep on chucking spears in fish barrels, don't you? All cops or are you going to back off from that one also? Is that written anywhere, like these are? Somehow I doubt it. You might want to ask Cpl Robinson if they never get caught.

Hmm so he got away with 2nd degree murder, impaired driving causing death and got caught "obstructing justice"?? That is your idea of "getting caught"? BWA HAHAHAHHAHAHAHHHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHHAHA
 
Hmm so he got away with 2nd degree murder, impaired driving causing death and got caught "obstructing justice"?? That is your idea of "getting caught"? BWA HAHAHAHHAHAHAHHHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHHAHA

It's only one example and you know it. Yes he got a way with murder as would many who did what he did. Try Kevin Gregson, another police officer who didn't get away with anything.
 
I would think we all get our morals from our parents or whoever we spent our childhood around. Doesn't matter if they taught/modeled it because god told them to, if it was because it's the only way humans can live in large groups (is it okay to use evolution as a part of the argument?), or if that's what their parents taught them; the result is the same.

Evolution should always be part of this discussion.

The problem starts to occur when the common bonds to society start to break down, and societies start turning into smaller and smaller communities or even groups of individuals. If you are going to remove religion, you need to replace it with something, and atheism, on a number of fronts just doesn't cut it...yet. Especially the negative atheism that we see from the Four Horsemen and people like CM. That is why the atheist movement on many levels, including the grass roots is moving away from that model.
 
No big building

Evolution should always be part of this discussion.

The problem starts to occur when the common bonds to society start to break down, and societies start turning into smaller and smaller communities or even groups of individuals. If you are going to remove religion, you need to replace it with something, and atheism, on a number of fronts just doesn't cut it...yet. Especially the negative atheism that we see from the Four Horsemen and people like CM. That is why the atheist movement on many levels, including the grass roots is moving away from that model.


YOU, have to understand that people who get branded as atheists, do NOT belong to a "movement", and are only negative towards religion because, sometimes, it deserves the attacks.
The term atheism, is really bull shit, it is used by the god believers as a negative connotation, like, "their out to get us".
People who do not believe in a god (pick one), are not organized, they are able to stand on their own.

FAST
 
YOU, have to understand that people who get branded as atheists, do NOT belong to a "movement", and are only negative towards religion because, sometimes, it deserves the attacks.
The term atheism, is really bull shit, it is used by the god believers as a negative connotation, like, "their out to get us".
People who do not believe in a god (pick one), are not organized, they are able to stand on their own.

FAST


So when CM, not someone I would call a believer, uses it, it's still BS? You really love stating that terms used for years by countless people in discussions are BS. Atheism is atheism and it describe a particular train of thought about existence of deities.
 
YOU, have to understand that people who get branded as atheists, do NOT belong to a "movement", and are only negative towards religion because, sometimes, it deserves the attacks.
The term atheism, is really bull shit, it is used by the god believers as a negative connotation, like, "their out to get us".
People who do not believe in a god (pick one), are not organized, they are able to stand on their own.

FAST

Not all atheists belong to a movement. Not all Christians belong to a movement either.

But there is, in the media, and amongst atheists certain people who appear to be leaders in that area, and organizations who claim to represent the interests and philosophy of atheists.

The term "atheism" is not simply a word used by theists, it is a word adopted, debated, discussed and put forward by many people who do not believe in god. It serves as a useful shorthand, unless you have something better.

But to say that atheists are not organized is hogwash. There are many atheist groups, they hold conferences, have webpages and chatrooms...they show all the signs of a movement. Not all atheists are members of these groups or involved in said movement, and I don't have any numbers on how many are.

Your suggestion that they are only hostile to religion because sometimes religion deserves it, suggests that atheists are right all of the time. Quite the premise. Are you suggesting that all atheist criticisms of religion are accurate and well founded in fact and reason?

Besides, if you want to study groups, or have a conversation about a phenomena, like religion or atheism, that is intelligible, you have to look for some common characteristics and inclusive language so you can have a conversation about the group.

Unless of course each atheist is a special little snowflake, and there is no way to discuss the millions of them as a group.
 
Not all atheists belong to a movement. Not all Christians belong to a movement either.

But there is, in the media, and amongst atheists certain people who appear to be leaders in that area, and organizations who claim to represent the interests and philosophy of atheists.

The term "atheism" is not simply a word used by theists, it is a word adopted, debated, discussed and put forward by many people who do not believe in god. It serves as a useful shorthand, unless you have something better.

But to say that atheists are not organized is hogwash. There are many atheist groups, they hold conferences, have webpages and chatrooms...they show all the signs of a movement. Not all atheists are members of these groups or involved in said movement, and I don't have any numbers on how many are.

Your suggestion that they are only hostile to religion because sometimes religion deserves it, suggests that atheists are right all of the time. Quite the premise. Are you suggesting that all atheist criticisms of religion are accurate and well founded in fact and reason?

Besides, if you want to study groups, or have a conversation about a phenomena, like religion or atheism, that is intelligible, you have to look for some common characteristics and inclusive language so you can have a conversation about the group.

Unless of course each atheist is a special little snowflake, and there is no way to discuss the millions of them as a group.

Hmmm, atheist, snowflakes. Let me think about that. Not all atheists.
 
Wrong

So when CM, not someone I would call a believer, uses it, it's still BS? You really love stating that terms used for years by countless people in discussions are BS. Atheism is atheism and it describe a particular train of thought about existence of deities.

Atheism is NOT "a train of thought", I simply DO NOT believe in a god (pick one) or religion, THAT is NOT a train of thought.

If you are not a Capitalist, does that automatically make you a communist?

NOT BELIEVING IN A MYTH DOES NOT MAKE YOU ANYTHING MORE THAN AN INDIVIDUAL, as apposed to the "believers" who are followers.

I don't give a shit if SOME people use the term, DOES NOT mean it is a "label" that can be applied to me.

Finally, go into a delivery room, and call the 1st baby you see born an atheist, WHY would you apply that label?

FAST
 
Obviously, my point was that even religious people get their morals from the Golden Rule.
They sure don't get their morals from god -- the most vicious mass murderer ever . . .
The bible tells us to hold children responsible for the sins of their fathers -- for seven generations.

Quoted by rid: Ezekiel 18:20 (New International Version)
The soul who sins is the one who will die. The son will not share the guilt of the father, nor will the father share the guilt of the son. The righteousness of the righteous man will be credited to him, and the wickedness of the wicked will be charged against him.


My point, rid baby, is that even the most bigoted religious nutter picks and chooses which bits of the bible they will follow. You have just proved that that is so (if you don't mind my alluding to you as a b.r.n.)

In other words, when it comes right down to it, they/you do not get your morals from the bible or from god. Even you can recognize, in your own mind, that it's better to follow the Ezekiel rule than the seventh-generation rule.

So, you, rid baby, must address the question - where do I, as a religious person, get my morals? You don't have to write your answer here, on an escort review board. But you do have to answer the question in your own mind -- why do I choose the Ezekiel rule over the seventh generation rule? How do I, a mere human, know which rule is better?

Something inside you? Your conscience? Those of us who are not troubled by silly fairy stories just point to the Golden Rule -- do unto others as you would have them do unto you -- which, to us, seems either to be built right into the human consciousness, or to be simply so self-evident as to serve, itself, as the starting point from which all other morals (and laws) are derived.

No need for the bible. Indeed, no room for the bible. Just the same for b.r.n.s as for atheists.
 
Singular

Unless of course each atheist is a special little snowflake, and there is no way to discuss the millions of them as a group.

And there lies the problem, your again insisting all people who do not beleive in a god (pick one), belong to/in a group.
The "special little snowflake", part, yep, thats the difference from people like me, an individual, and the "believers" who all DO belong to/in a group.

FAST.
 
And there lies the problem, your again insisting all people who do not beleive in a god (pick one), belong to/in a group.
The "special little snowflake", part, yep, thats the difference from people like me, an individual, and the "believers" who all DO belong to/in a group.

FAST.

They belong to a group that deserves to be recognized, respected, studied and understood like any other group. Just like we study or talk about any other group in science or sociology. We talk about oh say amputees as a group, and the only thing that they have in common is that they do not have a certain limb. IT does not mean they should not be talked about or understood as a group with one thing in common.

And your position ignores the fact that many atheists do belong to groups of like minded individuals. And that is cool.

Your reverse premise is also wrong. There are people who believe in certain aspects of religion or certain ideas about deism or theism if you like, who do not join organizations to express their religion. Just like there are many atheists who function the same way.

The way you talk we could never talk about groups at all. We could not talk about Canadians, or sociopaths, or anything else. The way you approach this is simply absurd.

Are you suggesting it is impossible to take a survey of atheists?
 
Quoted by rid: Ezekiel 18:20 (New International Version)
The soul who sins is the one who will die. The son will not share the guilt of the father, nor will the father share the guilt of the son. The righteousness of the righteous man will be credited to him, and the wickedness of the wicked will be charged against him.


My point, rid baby, is that even the most bigoted religious nutter picks and chooses which bits of the bible they will follow. You have just proved that that is so (if you don't mind my alluding to you as a b.r.n.)

In other words, when it comes right down to it, they/you do not get your morals from the bible or from god. Even you can recognize, in your own mind, that it's better to follow the Ezekiel rule than the seventh-generation rule.

So, you, rid baby, must address the question - where do I, as a religious person, get my morals? You don't have to write your answer here, on an escort review board. But you do have to answer the question in your own mind -- why do I choose the Ezekiel rule over the seventh generation rule? How do I, a mere human, know which rule is better?

Something inside you? Your conscience? Those of us who are not troubled by silly fairy stories just point to the Golden Rule -- do unto others as you would have them do unto you -- which, to us, seems either to be built right into the human consciousness, or to be simply so self-evident as to serve, itself, as the starting point from which all other morals (and laws) are derived.

No need for the bible. Indeed, no room for the bible. Just the same for b.r.n.s as for atheists.

It is funny how you refer to people who believe in religion as bigotted and nutty. No bias there.

And no personal offense taken because I am not religious.

It is an interesting theory that the Golden Rule is hardwired into us. Any evidence for it.

The one about Ezekiel and the one you are referring to but are too lazy to look up or quote is that they are talking about two different subjects. If you really wanted to be honest about the topic, why not post both quotes fully in their context. Then we can talk about one being about breaching the covenant and the other about mundane laws. Then we can talk about what the covenant means. And it is only four generations by the by.

You might also want to look at history, a real world study. Have a look at all the countries that have been explicitly atheist and those that are based on religious principles. How do they work? Which do better?

Now, you may not be big on the bible, or other religious texts, but the society and culture that gave you all the advantages you enjoy today was based on it.

And you will note that capitalism does not embrace the Golden Rule.

And in your scheme, what makes humans more important than animals? If there is no essential dignity why is there crime at all? Or is your answer just going to be "I think it is wired into us and it is all self evident."
 
You might also want to look at history, a real world study. Have a look at all the countries that have been explicitly atheist and those that are based on religious principles. How do they work? Which do better?
I'd rather know which people did better. What conclusions can I come to using history of countries where religion is used by those in power to keep the plebs working?
 
re golden rule - there is absolutely no fucking golden rule outside of religion or upbringing by parents whose parents were religious.

If anything, the real golden rule is Homo homini lupus est*

*it is a Latin phrase meaning "man is a wolf to [his fellow] man." First attested in Plautus' Asinaria (495, "lupus est homo homini"), the phrase is sometimes translated as "man is man's wolf", which can be interpreted to mean that man preys upon man. It is widely referenced when discussing the horrors of which humans are capable. - wiki
 
I'd rather know which people did better. What conclusions can I come to using history of countries where religion is used by those in power to keep the plebs working?

You can come to conclusions about what systems of governance and what shared moral ideas make a community thrive and which don't work well at all.

Studying people, or individuals is fascinating, but it doesn't really take you too far with governance or political science.