This whole Arizona law thing

Don

Active member
Aug 23, 2001
6,286
10
38
Toronto
There seems to be a lot of hoopla over that new Arizona law. But what i don't get is that many countries do something like this already. In parts of East Europe like Ukraine and Russia, the police will come up to anyone they think looks foreign (i.e. not slavic) and can ask for your documentation. Hence you need to carry your ID or passport around with you otherwise they can lock you up. People who are darker in complexion get harassed the most. This sounds like racial profiling to me. But no calls for boycotts for those countries and the many others who do this. It's just how it is and no one makes a big deal of this. I got used to this. I assume that if you have your documentation in Arizona, you are ok?
 
Yes, that's true.

But despite it all, a lot of people still like to think of the USA as a free and democratic nation. Do we want the USA to be like Eastern European nations, that the USA fought against during the Cold War?

And, the problem here is for a legal citizen of Hispanic descent. Why should a citizen be required to show proof of citizenship in his home country? I believe that may pose a Constitutional issue there.

That'd be like if you were walking around in Calgary, and required to show your Canadian passport.
 
In parts of East Europe like Ukraine and Russia, the police will come up to anyone they think looks foreign (i.e. not slavic) and can ask for your documentation.

It's supposedly one of your fundamental democratic rights that the police have no power over you whatsoever unless they have probable cause to believe that you have committed a crime. The notion that police can harass and demand papers of people who are not suspected of any wrongdoing is offensive to democracy.

But no calls for boycotts for those countries and the many others who do this. It's just how it is and no one makes a big deal of this. I got used to this. I assume that if you have your documentation in Arizona, you are ok?

Well I think those tin pot dictatorships have even bigger problems than their draconian ID laws, and I also think that we've accepted that we have to have dealings with countries that aren't democratic or free. We single out the most abusive states for sanctions, like Myanmar, but we're realistic and maintain relations with the majority of non-democracies.
 
what is worse is most people do not even understand the "new law" is State enforcement of existing Federal Law.
 
Can you cite this existing federal law that authorized police to demand papers arbitrarily?


I would be happy to research that if you would site the section of Arizona Law that allows that.
 
Can you cite this existing federal law that authorized police to demand papers arbitrarily?

Police cannot do this under the new law....

OTB
 
And, the problem here is for a legal citizen of Hispanic descent. Why should a citizen be required to show proof of citizenship in his home country? I believe that may pose a Constitutional issue there.

When I was there, I was on a business trip and one of the people I was with actually is a citizen. But he got asked for his ID because he is not of typical Slavic origin. "That's the way it is" he said.

I'm just saying that stuff like this has been going on all the time. People make it sound like they are shocked something like this can happen.

I've been questioned and asked for identification when leaving airports in Paris and Munich. Since I am not of European background, I tend to stick out. They let me go after a few questions. No biggie. Anyone who has traveled knows this kind of thing happens all over the world.
 
Police cannot do this under the new law....

OTB

You're right, I went to the Arizona State Legislature website and read the text of the law. The version that was ultimately passed was watered down significantly from the one originally proposed. The original one allowed the police to consider the race of an individual in deciding to ID them, and allowed them to ID people they simply had "contact" with. The final version states that they cannot consider race at all, and that they can only ID people that they have already stopped or arrested for some unrelated reason.

So I was wrong. The law as passed isn't really all that bad, although it was hideous as originally presented in the legislature before it was amended.
 
You're right, I went to the Arizona State Legislature website and read the text of the law. The version that was ultimately passed was watered down significantly from the one originally proposed. The original one allowed the police to consider the race of an individual in deciding to ID them, and allowed them to ID people they simply had "contact" with. The final version states that they cannot consider race at all, and that they can only ID people that they have already stopped or arrested for some unrelated reason.

So I was wrong. The law as passed isn't really all that bad, although it was hideous as originally presented in the legislature before it was amended.

You think there is any chance the NY Times and their op-Ed staff will change their tune.... It's a rhetorical question.

OTB
 
but it does open a door

you could argue when people become desensitized to giving up freedoms, no matter how minute, it's that much easier for the government the next time

look at the airports
 
but it does open a door

you could argue when people become desensitized to giving up freedoms, no matter how minute, it's that much easier for the government the next time

look at the airports

Have you ever been pulled over by the police for speeding?

If you can not produce a valid license would you be expected to be asked to show additional ID??
 
You're right, I went to the Arizona State Legislature website and read the text of the law. The version that was ultimately passed was watered down significantly from the one originally proposed. The original one allowed the police to consider the race of an individual in deciding to ID them, and allowed them to ID people they simply had "contact" with. The final version states that they cannot consider race at all, and that they can only ID people that they have already stopped or arrested for some unrelated reason.

So I was wrong. The law as passed isn't really all that bad, although it was hideous as originally presented in the legislature before it was amended.

I was not privileged to the original draft. Unlike you I am not elected to the Arizona Legislature. So I only have what was provided to the media.

I am shocked you did not know what was in the bill before you opened your yap.
 
Quick question people

Are you saying Canadian officials should not be allowed to ask for proof of valid entry into Canada???


How many people here are in Canada or the US illegally?

I recall at least one socialist/liberal member confessed to entering Canada illegally and made quite a fuss when I quoted him in my signature.
 
It's supposedly one of your fundamental democratic rights that the police have no power over you whatsoever unless they have probable cause to believe that you have committed a crime. The notion that police can harass and demand papers of people who are not suspected of any wrongdoing is offensive to democracy.



Well I think those tin pot dictatorships have even bigger problems than their draconian ID laws, and I also think that we've accepted that we have to have dealings with countries that aren't democratic or free. We single out the most abusive states for sanctions, like Myanmar, but we're realistic and maintain relations with the majority of non-democracies.


One of the things I appreciate about you is you think you are better than other people.


I love the fact you have a superior attitude to others.


You are a great example of the elite.
 
One of the things I appreciate about you is you think you are better than other people.


I love the fact you have a superior attitude to others.


You are a great example of the elite.

Yeah, it's great that American finally got over their superior, 'We're a shining beacon of liberty' elitism and joined the rest of the world in the darkness where government can push us around however it wants. Way to go for not being better than others.

"Hey, you, yeah with the beard. Papers. Now!"
 
One of the things I appreciate about you is you think you are better than other people.


I love the fact you have a superior attitude to others.


You are a great example of the elite.

Fuji admitted he was wrong...

OTB
 
One of the things I appreciate about you is you think you are better than other people.


I love the fact you have a superior attitude to others.

You are a great example of the elite.


I believe the OP was commenting about civil liberties. If you think that concern about civil liberties is elitist, I guess that would explain a lot of your posts.