Get tough on crime legislation will cost taxpayers billions

fuji

Banned
Jan 31, 2005
79,936
9
0
¯\_(ツ)_/¯
is.gd
http://www.nationalpost.com/news/story.html?id=2958526

Next week, Parliamentary Budget Officer Kevin Page is expected to release a report on the first major costing of the truth in sentencing legislation, one of seven tough-on-crime bills. By all accounts, the impact is said to be in the billions -- a far cry from the $89 million earmarked in the budget this year and next to cover increased costs, such as building or expanding prisons.
 
If you actually intended to pay all the real costs of 'getting tough on crime': more police with much better training (more cars and copshps too), more prosecutors, judges and legal aid lawyers, more courtrooms and offices, more jails, prisons and probation officers, you'd quickly realize that doing something serious about the broken families, child poverty and mis-education that contributes to a lot of crime is not such a bad idea. And always remember the crime drop that synched with abortion availability.

But since we're already skimping there, and none of your voters give a crap about skimping on crooks, you can boast you're tough on crime while actually doing nothing at all about it.

Because that costs money.
 
Hopefully there'll be billions available for domestic purposes once we cease our looney adventures in Afghanistan.

jwm
 
Afghanistan only costs about 2B/year....not gonna cover this utter waste of money. 8B spent for nothing....what utter idiocy.
 
Hopefully there'll be billions available for domestic purposes once we cease our looney adventures in Afghanistan.

jwm

Hopefully taxes will drop as government spending drops. Just because we had to spend money one place doesn't mean we should waste it after the original need has been met.
 
Hopefully taxes will drop as government spending drops. Just because we had to spend money one place doesn't mean we should waste it after the original need has been met.

Guess you missed it: Harpo already dropped taxes we pay—the GST went down 2%—then posted the biggest deficit ever (Steve himself said, "our government will never run deficits". Either that was his evil twin, or he's no more competent at predictions or keeping his mouth shut than Jean 'the Olympics can no more run a deficit than a man can have a baby' Drapeau). Works out to in the red either way.

More corporate tax breaks in the works though, but don't 'spect that Afghan peace dividend soon.
 
Last edited:
Guess you missed it: Harpo already dropped taxes we pay—the GST went down 2%—then posted the biggest deficit ever (Steve himself said, "our government will never run deficits". Either that was his evil twin, or he's no more competent at predictions or keeping his mouth shut than Jean 'the Olympics can no more run a deficit than a man can have a baby' Drapeau). Works out to in th red either way.

More corporate tax breaks in the works though, but don't 'spect that Afghan peace dividend soon.

A little context on the comment you made would be nice not to mention accurate
 
Bring back the chain gangs without the chains, put electronic bands on them and make them clean the streets and other tasks instead of watching tv and getting an education. They will learn much more from that lesson even before they step one foot in jail. Oh and you can get rid of their pensions and their right to vote as well.
 
Why don't we just kill them all after conviction? Surely that would be cheaper wouldn't it? May not be "justice" as such, but wtf, who really cares about that anyways?
 
A little context on the comment you made would be nice not to mention accurate

Hopefully taxes will drop as government spending drops. Just because we had to spend money one place doesn't mean we should waste it after the original need has been met.

That was the original post, to which I replied:
Guess you missed it: Harpo already dropped taxes we pay—the GST went down 2%—then posted the biggest deficit ever (Steve himself said, "our government will never run deficits". Either that was his evil twin, or he's no more competent at predictions or keeping his mouth shut than Jean 'the Olympics can no more run a deficit than a man can have a baby' Drapeau). Works out to in the red either way.

More corporate tax breaks in the works though, but don't 'spect that Afghan peace dividend soon.
Is that what you're after? Or do you want a time-wasting primer on recent Canadian political history? If an exegisis of the stuff I referred to is 'needed', someone will ask. Or you can supply it I am sure.
 
Why don't we just kill them all after conviction? Surely that would be cheaper wouldn't it? May not be "justice" as such, but wtf, who really cares about that anyways?
Guy Paul Morin, Donald Marshall, Thomas Sophonow, Stephen Truscott.

Oh, and a buncha people a bungling, incompetent Ontario pathologist gave untrue testimony about.

But none of that ever happens these days, right all_wet_one?
 
Guy Paul Morin, Donald Marshall, Thomas Sophonow, Stephen Truscott.

Oh, and a buncha people a bungling, incompetent Ontario pathologist gave untrue testimony about.

But none of that ever happens these days, right all_wet_one?

I believe wet-suit-one was making the point that cost shouldn't be the over-riding concern in providing for the just sentencing of criminals. If it were, then...his scenario. He wasn't actually pushing the death penalty.

jwm
 
Bring back the chain gangs without the chains, put electronic bands on them and make them clean the streets and other tasks instead of watching tv and getting an education. They will learn much more from that lesson even before they step one foot in jail. Oh and you can get rid of their pensions and their right to vote as well.

Simple, Easy to Implement, Costs very little, and effective.... Unfortunately, that is not what these guys have in mind. They were thinking that they needed to upgrade the jails to a 4 1/2 star quality, provide them with better TV, legalize marijuana in jails, make the jails co-ed, daycare programs (so that the pedophiles have somewere to work), and of course getting the prisoners their own union...
 
Why don't we just kill them all after conviction? Surely that would be cheaper wouldn't it? May not be "justice" as such, but wtf, who really cares about that anyways?

Typical over reaction to a reasonable suggestion. This is the reason why our criminal justice system works for criminals and not for the benefit of society.
 
We should create a new "dirty dozen" and force them to fight in Kandahar... lol
 
Don't tell me you guys are moving towards a US style of justice system. You know, the one that has quadrupled the number of people in jail since 1980. Trust me, you can't afford it.
 
Don't tell me you guys are moving towards a US style of justice system. You know, the one that has quadrupled the number of people in jail since 1980. Trust me, you can't afford it.

I'd like to see harsher sentencing but not California-style. That's just plain unsustainable. It's a balancing act.

jwm
 
I believe wet-suit-one was making the point that cost shouldn't be the over-riding concern in providing for the just sentencing of criminals. If it were, then...his scenario. He wasn't actually pushing the death penalty.

jwm

Thanks for showing me the positive spin. Having seen many such posts that gleefully advocated speedy death for all convicted without exception, it was too easy to read that in.

And there's that wise advice that sarcasm doesn't travel well in cybersapce.
 
Don't tell me you guys are moving towards a US style of justice system. You know, the one that has quadrupled the number of people in jail since 1980. Trust me, you can't afford it.

Yes we are, the Harpo voters read slow.
 
I'd like to see harsher sentencing but not California-style. That's just plain unsustainable. It's a balancing act.

jwm

It's not just California, it's nation wide. Careful what you wish for.